DATA Centers Even BIGGER Losers Than TRUMP?!!?

Original Media · 17m · English · YouTube · Legal AF

TLDR

The midterm elections delivered a stunning rebuke to data center expansion, with ballot measures restricting them passing by an average 77% support across at least 38 jurisdictions despite a 100-to-1 spending disadvantage. Earthjustice experts Mandy DeRoche and Meg Slattery discuss the legal battles — including a Clean Air Act lawsuit against Elon Musk's XAI gas-powered facility in Mississippi — and outline legislative priorities for the new Democratic Congress: enforcing environmental laws, stopping regulatory carve-outs, improving federal energy tracking, and empowering state/local governments to protect communities from pollution and rate hikes. The issue has forged a rare bipartisan coalition crossing political and socioeconomic lines.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Despite a 100-to-1 spending advantage, data center backers lost almost every local ballot measure.

•

The federal government intervened in the XAI lawsuit claiming national security necessity — a justification voters resoundingly rejected.

•

Data center energy consumption is hidden in EIA data under the vague category 'commercial buildings other,' obscuring its massive, distinct demand.

•

Behind-the-meter gas plants for data centers are being deployed at unprecedented speed using dirtier, less efficient turbines specifically to avoid regulatory review.

Key takeaways

•

Ballot measures restricting data centers won with ~77% average support across 38+ jurisdictions; only one known restriction measure failed.

•

Data center interests outspent opponents ~100:1 nationwide yet lost nearly every local referendum.

•

Earthjustice litigation challenges illegal behind-the-meter gas plants, notably 69 turbines at XAI's Mississippi facility emitting smog, particulates, and formaldehyde.

•

Over 80% of rapid 'shadow grid' gas generation for data centers uses inefficient, more polluting turbines that evade energy and environmental regulations.

•

Voters issued a clear mandate for transparency, community input, clean air/water, and protection from energy bill hikes driven by data center demand.

•

Federal priorities: enforce Clean Air Act, halt EPA carve-outs for data centers, fix EIA data categorization (currently 'commercial buildings other'), and investigate agency-industry collusion.

•

State/local action is pivotal: governors and legislatures must convert campaign promises into enforceable safeguards for public health and ratepayers.

•

Opposition to unchecked data center growth crosses political and socioeconomic lines, creating a broad 'big tent' coalition.

Notable quotes

“Ballot measures restricting data centers received an astonishing average of 77% central support according to the election night tracker.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:21

“There's a clear mandate for legislators to protect people's air, water, energy bills, and general quality of life moving forward.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:25

“Musk's company installed 69 gas engines. They are turbines that release staggering amounts of smog-forming pollution, particulate matter, and chemicals like formaldehyde.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:56

“Over 80% of that was gas that mostly inefficient and more polluting turbines and that it was evading all sorts of regulations on the both the energy and environmental front.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:49

“This is an issue that crosses socioeconomic lines, political lines.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:55

“The argument that sort of maximum data center build-out at all costs and the necessity of that has not resonated with voters.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:18

Chapters

•

0:00 — Midterm Election Results: Data Center Restrictions Win Overwhelmingly: Host cites Data Center Resistance data: opponents outspent 100:1, yet 38+ jurisdictions passed restrictions with 77% average support; only one measure failed.

•

3:00 — Earthjustice Litigation: XAI's Illegal Gas Plant in Mississippi: Mandy DeRoche details Clean Air Act lawsuit against Elon Musk's XAI for 69 unpermitted gas turbines in Southaven, MS; court denied motion to dismiss.

•

5:50 — Environmental Impacts: The 'Shadow Grid' of Behind-the-Meter Gas Generation: DeRoche and Slattery describe local pollution (smog, formaldehyde, particulates) from rapid, unregulated gas build-out; over 80% uses inefficient turbines evading rules.

•

7:00 — Legislative Priorities for New Democratic Congress: Slattery outlines federal goals: enforce Clean Air Act, stop EPA carve-outs, fix EIA data tracking, ensure ratepayer protection, and defend state/local siting authority.

•

10:20 — State/Local Action and Bipartisan Coalition: DeRoche emphasizes state-level implementation of campaign promises; both note issue unites voters across political and socioeconomic lines.

•

14:00 — National Security Claims vs. Voter Mandate: Discussion of federal intervention for XAI citing national security; experts say 'maximum build-out at all costs' argument failed with voters.

Speakers

•

Host — Host of All Rise News / Legal AF

•

Mandy DeRoche — Director of Emerging Issues, Earthjustice

•

Meg Slattery — Staff Scientist, Earthjustice

⋮