TLDR
The midterm elections delivered a stunning rebuke to data center expansion, with ballot measures restricting them passing by an average 77% support across at least 38 jurisdictions despite a 100-to-1 spending disadvantage. Earthjustice experts Mandy DeRoche and Meg Slattery discuss the legal battles — including a Clean Air Act lawsuit against Elon Musk's XAI gas-powered facility in Mississippi — and outline legislative priorities for the new Democratic Congress: enforcing environmental laws, stopping regulatory carve-outs, improving federal energy tracking, and empowering state/local governments to protect communities from pollution and rate hikes. The issue has forged a rare bipartisan coalition crossing political and socioeconomic lines.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Despite a 100-to-1 spending advantage, data center backers lost almost every local ballot measure.
The federal government intervened in the XAI lawsuit claiming national security necessity — a justification voters resoundingly rejected.
Data center energy consumption is hidden in EIA data under the vague category 'commercial buildings other,' obscuring its massive, distinct demand.
Behind-the-meter gas plants for data centers are being deployed at unprecedented speed using dirtier, less efficient turbines specifically to avoid regulatory review.
Key takeaways
Ballot measures restricting data centers won with ~77% average support across 38+ jurisdictions; only one known restriction measure failed.
Data center interests outspent opponents ~100:1 nationwide yet lost nearly every local referendum.
Earthjustice litigation challenges illegal behind-the-meter gas plants, notably 69 turbines at XAI's Mississippi facility emitting smog, particulates, and formaldehyde.
Over 80% of rapid 'shadow grid' gas generation for data centers uses inefficient, more polluting turbines that evade energy and environmental regulations.
Voters issued a clear mandate for transparency, community input, clean air/water, and protection from energy bill hikes driven by data center demand.
Federal priorities: enforce Clean Air Act, halt EPA carve-outs for data centers, fix EIA data categorization (currently 'commercial buildings other'), and investigate agency-industry collusion.
State/local action is pivotal: governors and legislatures must convert campaign promises into enforceable safeguards for public health and ratepayers.
Opposition to unchecked data center growth crosses political and socioeconomic lines, creating a broad 'big tent' coalition.
Notable quotes
“Ballot measures restricting data centers received an astonishing average of 77% central support according to the election night tracker.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:21“There's a clear mandate for legislators to protect people's air, water, energy bills, and general quality of life moving forward.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:25“Musk's company installed 69 gas engines. They are turbines that release staggering amounts of smog-forming pollution, particulate matter, and chemicals like formaldehyde.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:56“Over 80% of that was gas that mostly inefficient and more polluting turbines and that it was evading all sorts of regulations on the both the energy and environmental front.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:49“This is an issue that crosses socioeconomic lines, political lines.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:55“The argument that sort of maximum data center build-out at all costs and the necessity of that has not resonated with voters.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:18Chapters
0:00 — Midterm Election Results: Data Center Restrictions Win Overwhelmingly: Host cites Data Center Resistance data: opponents outspent 100:1, yet 38+ jurisdictions passed restrictions with 77% average support; only one measure failed.
3:00 — Earthjustice Litigation: XAI's Illegal Gas Plant in Mississippi: Mandy DeRoche details Clean Air Act lawsuit against Elon Musk's XAI for 69 unpermitted gas turbines in Southaven, MS; court denied motion to dismiss.
5:50 — Environmental Impacts: The 'Shadow Grid' of Behind-the-Meter Gas Generation: DeRoche and Slattery describe local pollution (smog, formaldehyde, particulates) from rapid, unregulated gas build-out; over 80% uses inefficient turbines evading rules.
7:00 — Legislative Priorities for New Democratic Congress: Slattery outlines federal goals: enforce Clean Air Act, stop EPA carve-outs, fix EIA data tracking, ensure ratepayer protection, and defend state/local siting authority.
10:20 — State/Local Action and Bipartisan Coalition: DeRoche emphasizes state-level implementation of campaign promises; both note issue unites voters across political and socioeconomic lines.
14:00 — National Security Claims vs. Voter Mandate: Discussion of federal intervention for XAI citing national security; experts say 'maximum build-out at all costs' argument failed with voters.
Speakers
Host — Host of All Rise News / Legal AF
Mandy DeRoche — Director of Emerging Issues, Earthjustice
Meg Slattery — Staff Scientist, Earthjustice