DEBATING if Jaguars or Bills are the BEST IN THE AFC + Have Patriots lost their magic?! | First Take

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

The panel debates the AFC's best team, centering on the Buffalo Bills and Jacksonville Jaguars. They analyze Josh Allen's evolution under Joe Brady, the Bills' defensive turnaround, and the Jaguars' completeness under Liam Cohen. The conversation shifts to the struggling New England Patriots, questioning whether Mike Vrabel has lost his edge amid injuries and off-field distractions, and whether their 2024 Super Bowl run was inflated by the easiest schedule since 1999.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The 2024 Patriots played the easiest schedule of any NFL team since 1999, and their playoff path featured opponents missing elite linemen (Chargers), a struggling CJ Stroud, and an injured Bo Nix before facing a fully healthy Seattle team in the Super Bowl.

•

Buffalo's defense has knocked out three opposing quarterbacks (Lamar Jackson, Tyler Huntley, and Joey Flacco) in a three-game span since Ed Oliver returned from injury.

•

Josh Allen's 24-to-8 touchdown-to-turnover ratio this season represents a stark departure from his historically riskier play under previous defensive-minded coaching staffs.

Key takeaways

•

The Buffalo Bills are favored as the AFC's best team due to Josh Allen playing 'carefree not careless' under offensive coordinator Joe Brady, coupled with a defense that has allowed only 28 points over three games since the bye week and Ed Oliver's return.

•

The Jacksonville Jaguars are presented as the league's most complete team, boasting a balanced offense, upgraded defensive front, and a head coach in Liam Cohen whose sideline demeanor has 'breathed confidence' into the roster.

•

Buffalo's quarterback sneak — the 'Bulldozer' — has effectively given the Bills four-down territory on offense, mirroring the 2024 Eagles' advantage and making their offense the AFC's most explosive with Allen at 24 total touchdowns to eight turnovers.

•

The Bills' defense has transformed under new coordinator Jim Leonard, generating pressure from Gregory Rousseau, Ed Oliver (11 QB hits), and Bradley Chubb while safety Amari Hooker has sparked a takeaway surge with multiple in each of the last three games.

•

The New England Patriots' collapse — five losses after only four in all of 2024 — stems from a confluence of injuries (AJ Brown, Romeo Doubs, offensive line), an easy 2024 schedule that masked deficiencies, and Vrabel's potential distraction from off-field issues preventing in-season correction.

•

Mike Tomlin's postgame comments about 'fire along with that smoke' in New England signal legitimate concern about the Patriots' locker-room culture and whether the team has lost the physical identity that defines Vrabel-coached squads.

•

The AFC is described as a genuine 'arms race' where Kansas City, Buffalo, Jacksonville, and Cincinnati have all invested heavily in pass rush and secondary play to counter elite quarterback play, making the conference wide open heading into the playoffs.

Notable quotes

“The thing that impresses me the most about the Bills this year under Joe Brady is that the quarterback is playing a lot more carefree. And that doesn't mean that he's playing careless, but he's also not playing careful.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:54

“I'm going to lean towards the Jacksonville Jaguars and everybody's going to talk you, you know, about the Bills and they deserve it. They deserve it. When you look at the Jacksonville, this is the most complete team in the AFC.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:58

“There's something about he has some kind of attitude about him. when you watch him on the sidelines, the way he walks, the way he cares, he has breathed confidence into this football team.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:28

“I would give the edge to the Buffalo Bills still. I believe that football is won and lost in the trenches.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:48

“Last year, they had the easiest schedule on record of an NFL team since 1999. That's what Mike Tomlin was alluding, right?”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:18

“You went up against a real team and it wasn't really a contest because Seattle did what they want when they wanted to your offense.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:52

Chapters

•

0:00 — AFC Best Team Debate: Bills vs Jaguars: The panel opens by discussing the AFC playoff picture and debates whether the Buffalo Bills or Jacksonville Jaguars are the conference's best team, with CC favoring Buffalo and Jeff advocating for Jacksonville's completeness.

•

0:36 — Buffalo Bills Analysis: Allen, Brady, and the Bulldozer: CC details why the Bills are the top team: Josh Allen playing carefree under Joe Brady, the unstoppable quarterback sneak giving them four-down offense, and a defense allowing only 28 points in three games since the bye.

•

1:58 — Jacksonville Jaguars Case: Complete Team, Cohen's Leadership: Jeff argues the Jaguars are the AFC's most complete team with a balanced offense, upgraded defensive line, and highlights Liam Cohen's confident sideline presence as a culture-changing factor for Trevor Lawrence's ascent.

•

3:00 — Head-to-Head: Bills vs Jaguars Matchup: The panel handicaps a hypothetical Bills-Jaguars game; Jeff picks Jacksonville on a neutral field but concedes Buffalo in cold weather, while CC stays with Buffalo citing trench dominance and offensive line superiority.

•

4:32 — Bills Defensive Turnaround Under Jim Leonard: CC explains the Bills' defensive improvement since the bye: pressure from Rousseau, Oliver, and Chubb, plus Amari Hooker's ball-hawking creating takeaways, acknowledging early-season growing pains under new coordinator Jim Leonard.

•

7:49 — New England Patriots Collapse and Vrabel's Magic: The discussion shifts to the Patriots' five losses, with CC citing missing edge, Vrabel's off-field distraction, and Christian Gonzalez's regression, while Jeff adds injury accumulation and a fatigued roster unable to morph its identity.

•

10:10 — Patriots' 2024 Schedule and Super Bowl Reality Check: The host reveals the 2024 Patriots had the easiest schedule since 1999 and a favorable playoff path, suggesting their Super Bowl run masked deficiencies now exposed in 2025.

Speakers

•

CC — Analyst

•

Jeff — Analyst

•

Host — Moderator

⋮