TLDR
In June 2016, a mobile home fire in Bemidji, Minnesota killed 35-year-old Melissa Norby and led to the disappearance of 5-year-old Brittany Rose Bulger, who had been staying the night. Investigation revealed the fire was arson set to cover up Melissa's murder — she had been bound, strangled, and hidden under a mattress. The perpetrator was Jake Kinn (aka Chance), Melissa's secret boyfriend and a registered sex offender with a prior conviction for seeking children for sexual photos. Text messages proved Melissa and Jake had plotted together to kidnap Brittany for Jake's sexual gratification, with Melissa intending to stage her own assault as a cover. Jake killed Melissa when the plan changed, abducted Brittany, assaulted her, and hid her in a camper in a rural field, where she was found alive 26 hours later. Jake pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, first-degree criminal sexual conduct, and kidnapping, receiving 52 years in prison. Brittany survived but suffers lasting trauma.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The victim Melissa Norby was complicit in planning the kidnapping of her best friend's daughter, intending to procure the child for her boyfriend's sexual gratification.
A registered sex offender with a prior conviction for seeking children for sexual photos received only 120 days in jail and was free on probation to commit murder and kidnapping.
The kidnapping plan was so thoroughly documented in text messages that a special agent called it 'one of the most well-documented crimes' he had ever worked on.
Brittany's only physical complaints when rescued were scrapes and bruises on her arms and hands, despite having been sexually assaulted, suggesting either shock, dissociation, or lack of understanding of the abuse.
Jake Kinn used kittens to bribe and groom 5-year-old Brittany, and at sentencing she thanked him for letting her play with the kittens while also saying she hated him and didn't like how he played with her.
Key takeaways
Melissa Norby was not just a victim but an active participant in planning the kidnapping of her best friend's 5-year-old daughter, Brittany, texting Jake Kinn detailed plans to stage Melissa's own assault and hand Brittany over for his sexual gratification.
Jake Kinn had a documented history of predatory behavior toward children, including a 2012 Craigslist ad seeking girls aged 2-9 for 'modeling' and a conviction for possession of child sexual abuse material, yet served only 120 days in jail and was on probation at the time of the murder.
Melissa knew about Jake's criminal history and registry status but continued the relationship and kept it secret, even telling her cousin 'he did something really bad, but he didn't do it and he got in trouble' to justify keeping him around children.
The kidnapping plan was meticulously documented in deleted text messages recovered from Jake's phone, including the original plan for Jake to assault Melissa, carjack her vehicle, and take Brittany, with Melissa pretending it was a random attack.
Brittany was found alive in a camper sealed with electrical tape in a remote field, with tape bound around her ankles, after investigators matched tire tracks and vegetation on Jake's Jeep to the location.
Jake initially denied any relationship with Melissa during police questioning, but cell phone data placed him 40 miles from his claimed fishing location, and multiple witnesses — including Melissa's son, cousin, coworkers, and a friend in another state — confirmed the sexual relationship.
After his arrest, Jake briefly admitted that Brittany had been present and nude during a sexual encounter with him and Melissa before the kidnapping, confirming she was victimized even before the abduction.
The case highlights systemic failures: Jake's lenient 2012 sentence allowed him to reoffend, Melissa's pattern of relationships with men who had sexual offense histories went unaddressed, and Brittany's family trusted Melissa completely due to their 30-year friendship.
Notable quotes
“I'm looking for a young girl, 2 to 9 years old, to model for my private collection. Nothing illegal, just skimpy outfits and whatnot.”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:34“She told him she hated him. She doesn't like the way that he plays with her. She doesn't want to play with him, but thank you for letting me play with your kitties.”
▸ Notable quotes · 85:54“The original kidnapping was supposed to happen a week before the fire and Melissa's death. The original plan was for Jake to assault Melissa, and I don't know if this was physically, sexually, or both, but then he was going to quote carjack her car and take Britney.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:45“In these messages, they allegedly referred to Britney as Jake's toy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 66:16“I didn't do anything to the little girl. I haven't seen the little girl. I didn't walk into the room.”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:01“It was for Melissa, but it was... Did you know that she was going to be there? Yeah. Was she part of the role-playing? Did Melissa bring her in for role-playing?”
▸ Notable quotes · 82:04Chapters
2:10 — Fire and Discovery: A mobile home fire in Bemidji, Minnesota kills Melissa Norby; her best friend Amanda arrives screaming that her 5-year-old daughter Brittany spent the night there and is missing. Firefighters find Melissa bound with duct tape under a mattress, and evidence of arson with explosives.
10:00 — Investigation Begins: Police clear Amanda and Brittany's father. Focus shifts to Melissa's relationships. Her ex-boyfriend with an arson conviction is cleared by alibi. A neighbor with a sexual relationship is also cleared. Melissa's cousin Tuesday reveals a secret boyfriend named Chance who liked 'rough' sex and once choked Melissa unconscious.
27:00 — Jake Kinn's History: Chance is identified as Jacob Kinn (Jake), owner of Jake's Eats food truck. He has a 2012 conviction for possession of child sexual abuse material after a Craigslist ad seeking girls 2-9 for 'modeling.' He served only 120 days and was on probation. Melissa knew his history but kept the relationship secret.
36:00 — Interrogation and Lies: Police interview Jake voluntarily. He denies a relationship with Melissa, claims he was fishing alone 40 miles from where his phone pinged. Multiple witnesses contradict him. He refuses a vehicle search but leaves his phone, clothes, and Jeep when he walks out.
63:00 — Text Messages Reveal Plot: Recovered deleted texts show Melissa and Jake planned to kidnap Brittany for Jake's sexual gratification. Original plan: Jake assaults Melissa, carjacks her car, takes Brittany; Melissa claims random attack. Plan delayed when Brittany got sick; executed a week later.
71:00 — Brittany Found Alive: Tire tracks and vegetation on Jake's Jeep lead investigators to a rural field where they find a camper sealed with electrical tape. Inside, Brittany is alive, ankles taped, wearing pink pajamas. She tells officers a friend brought her there.
76:00 — Arrest and Confession: Jake is arrested driving toward the camper. Shown a photo of Brittany safe, his demeanor collapses. He admits Brittany was present and nude during a sexual encounter with him and Melissa before the kidnapping, then lawyers up.
85:00 — Sentencing and Aftermath: Jake pleads guilty to second-degree murder, first-degree criminal sexual conduct, and kidnapping; sentenced to 52 years. Brittany's godmother reads her letter at sentencing. Brittany survives with therapy but suffers night terrors; Amanda grieves her friend and her daughter's trauma.
Speakers
Annie Elise — Host
Jake Kinn — Suspect/Perpetrator
Melissa Norby — Victim/Co-conspirator
Brittany Rose Bulger — Victim
Amanda Smith — Brittany's Mother
Tuesday (Cousin) — Witness
Investigators — Law Enforcement