Stephen A. on the impact of Kirk Cousins on Justin Jefferson | First Take

Original Media · 14m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

The Minnesota Vikings traded for Kirk Cousins, sending a 2027 third-round pick to the Raiders, reuniting the quarterback with Justin Jefferson after a year and a half of offensive futility. Panelists sharply criticize head coach Kevin O'Connell for cycling through eight starting quarterbacks and 14 in-season changes since Cousins' departure, calling the decision to hand the offense to rookie J.J. McCarthy arrogant. While the Vikings' elite defense under Brian Flores has carried them to a 6-2 record, the panel debates whether Cousins — who has one playoff win in 15 seasons — makes Minnesota a true Super Bowl contender in a brutal NFC North where all four teams could miss the playoffs due to head-to-head losses.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Kirk Cousins ranks fourth in NFL history in on-field earnings ($337.9 million) behind only Stafford, Rodgers, and Prescott despite just one playoff victory.

•

The Vikings have made 14 in-season quarterback changes and started eight different quarterbacks in less than two seasons since Cousins left.

•

Sam Darnold left Minnesota, won a Super Bowl with Seattle, and the Vikings replaced him with a rookie who had never thrown an NFL pass.

Key takeaways

•

Kirk Cousins returns to Minnesota after the Vikings' quarterback carousel — eight different starters and 14 in-season changes since his 2023 Achilles injury — wasted Justin Jefferson's prime.

•

Kevin O'Connell faces fierce criticism for handing the offense to rookie J.J. McCarthy after a 14-3 season, a move panelists call arrogant and the primary reason the GM was fired.

•

Cousins knows the offense and can start immediately against Green Bay, providing a 'breath of fresh air' for a defense that played 44 minutes on Monday night.

•

Justin Jefferson's production dropped sharply without Cousins; he averaged nearly 100 yards per game with him and has not looked like an all-world receiver since.

•

The Vikings' Super Bowl hopes hinge on Cousins' fit with Kevin O'Connell's system; panelists agree the defense is championship-caliber but question whether Cousins elevates the offense enough.

•

The NFC North is so competitive that all four teams could miss the playoffs because they must play each other, making the division a 'gauntlet' where 11 wins may be needed.

•

Brian Flores' defense is the sole reason Minnesota is 6-2; panelists argue he should be a head coach elsewhere and would be carried off the field if the Vikings win a Super Bowl.

•

Sean McVay draws criticism for running a jet sweep with Puka Nacua on third-and-11 late in a game, continuing a pattern of questionable decisions this season.

Notable quotes

“It was an utter disgrace what the Minnesota Vikings have done to him. I called out Kevin Okonnell yesterday and I meant every damn word of it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:39

“There is no wide receiver that has ever been successful throwing the football to himself. It has never happened. You can't throw the football to yourself. You need a quarterback.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:06

“Eight different starting quarterbacks, 14 different inseason quarterback changes. What the hell is going on with Kevin O'Connell, right?”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:46

“You cannot have a Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison, and Hockenson, and you hand the reigns to a guy that never threw an NFL pass. That is arrogance.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:55

“Minnesota could be a champion. They could be a champion or they could miss the damn playoffs. That's how wide the gap is.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:08

“Cousins won 15, one playoff victory in 15 NFL seasons. Fourth most on field earnings in NFL history.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:05

Chapters

•

0:00 — Cousins Trade Announced: The Vikings acquire Kirk Cousins from the Raiders for a 2027 third-round pick; Raiders turn to rookie Fernando Mendoza. Minnesota is 6-2 but has only 11 offensive touchdowns, tied for fewest in the league.

•

0:35 — Jefferson Wasted Without QB: Panelists argue Justin Jefferson has been disserved by the Vikings' quarterback instability; his best numbers came with Cousins, and no receiver can succeed throwing to himself.

•

7:00 — O'Connell's QB Mismanagement: Since Cousins' Achilles injury, Minnesota has started eight quarterbacks and made 14 in-season changes. Handing the offense to rookie J.J. McCarthy after a 14-3 season is called arrogant and criminal.

•

4:00 — Cousins' Immediate Impact: Cousins knows the offense and can start this week against Green Bay, relieving a defense that played 44 minutes on Monday night. His familiarity with the system is a major advantage.

•

8:00 — Vikings' Playoff Ceiling Debated: Panel splits on whether Cousins makes Minnesota a Super Bowl contender; defense is elite but Cousins has one playoff win in 15 years. Consensus: they are a playoff team, but 11 wins likely needed in a brutal NFC North.

•

9:00 — NFC North Gauntlet: All four NFC North teams are strong but must beat each other, meaning at least one will miss the playoffs. The division's depth creates a wide variance in Minnesota's possible outcomes.

•

10:30 — McVay Criticism: Sean McVay criticized for running a jet sweep with Puka Nacua on third-and-11 late in a game, part of a pattern of questionable decisions including the Melbourne flight and play-calling against Stafford.

Speakers

•

Stephen A. Smith — Host/Analyst

•

Steve — Analyst

•

Kimberly — Host/Reporter

•

Former Coach — Guest Analyst

⋮