STEPHEN A. IS ROOTING FOR THE COWBOYS?! 😭 'I know they're going to lose!' | First Take

Original Media · 8m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

The panel debates whether a Cowboys upset over the 49ers would legitimize Dallas as a playoff contender, with most arguing the team's chronic inconsistency and defensive flaws make any regular-season win meaningless. Stephen A. Smith delivers a blistering critique of the franchise's 30-year title drought, Dak Prescott's emotionless leadership, and Jerry Jones' mismanagement, ultimately predicting another predictable loss.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The NFC East is weak enough that an 8-win team could win the division, making Dallas's playoff path unusually easy despite their flaws.

•

Stephen A. Smith, a notorious Cowboys critic, says he may start rooting for them out of pity for Jerry Jones after three decades of futility.

•

The Cowboys' defense repeatedly bailed out the offense against the Colts, contradicting the narrative that the defense is the sole problem.

•

Dak Prescott has lost four consecutive games against the 49ers, a specific streak that underscores the matchup difficulty beyond general inconsistency.

Key takeaways

•

A Cowboys win over San Francisco would put them at 7-5 with a favorable remaining schedule (Titans, Eagles, Giants, Commanders) and a realistic path to 10 wins and the NFC East title.

•

Dallas's offense can beat any team on a given Sunday but has shown zero week-to-week consistency, and the defense is not reliable enough to win playoff games regardless of record.

•

The NFC East is so weak that an 8-9 win team could win the division, lowering the bar for Dallas's playoff entry but not proving they are a true contender.

•

Stephen A. Smith emphasizes the Cowboys' last championship was January 28, 1996, arguing that regular-season wins are irrelevant without a deep playoff run.

•

Dak Prescott's perpetually polished, unemotional sideline demeanor contrasts sharply with greats like Brady and Rodgers who visibly demand excellence from teammates.

•

The Cowboys have a decades-long pattern of winning games they're expected to lose and losing games they're expected to win, making them consistently disappointing.

•

Even if Dallas beats the 49ers and reaches 10 wins, their defensive limitations prevent a genuine playoff run in January.

•

Stephen A. Smith admits he is considering rooting for the Cowboys out of sympathy for Jerry Jones after 30 years of predictable, soul-crushing failure.

Notable quotes

“January 28th, 1996 is the last time they won anything.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:13

“The Dallas Cowboys could win eight games this year and still have the potential to win the division.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:29

“They are consistent in the disappointment that they reign.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:04

“I am getting sick of the Dallas Cowboys messing up the holiday season for so many people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:50

“You see the same old reaction from Dak Prescott, always polished, always saying the right thing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:24

“MAYBE GET SOME ATTITUDE. MAYBE GET TICKED OFF. MAYBE CALL SOME CATS OUT. MAYBE YOU'LL GET A DIFFERENT RESULT.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:30

Chapters

•

0:00 — Game preview and stakes: The Cowboys host the NFC-leading 49ers seeking their first back-to-back wins since late last season; San Francisco aims for an 8-1 start that historically leads to conference championship appearances.

•

0:32 — Debate: Would a win change perception?: Jordan argues a win would shift the outlook given a soft upcoming schedule putting Dallas at 7-5 with a bye; another panelist counters that offensive inconsistency and defensive unreliability make any single win meaningless.

•

2:06 — Stephen A. Smith's reality check: Smith cites the 1996 championship drought, predicts a loss, and notes the NFC East's weakness means 8 wins could take the division — but that doesn't equal contention.

•

3:25 — Heated exchange on expectations: Panelists clash over whether beating a top team should change perceptions, with Smith insisting the Cowboys' pattern of winning 'supposed-to-lose' games and losing 'supposed-to-win' games makes them consistently disappointing.

•

5:44 — Stephen A.'s passionate rant: Smith delivers a fiery monologue about Cowboys misery ruining holidays, sympathy for Jerry Jones, Dak Prescott's lack of sideline fire compared to Brady and Rodgers, and a demand for Prescott to show emotion and accountability.

•

7:44 — Final predictions and personal dynamics: The panel converges on an inevitable Cowboys loss, citing Prescott's 0-4 record against the 49ers; the segment ends with banter about co-host Shay holding a grudge over Indiana sports.

Speakers

•

Stephen A. Smith — Lead analyst

•

Jordan — Co-host/analyst

•

Shay — Co-host

•

Host/Moderator — Segment host

⋮