TLDR
At Crooked Con, Democratic strategists Liz Smith, Danielle Butterfield, and Morris Katz dissect the 2026 midterm victories, emphasizing candidate authenticity over fundraising, a massive digital advertising gap, and AIPAC's $80M intervention in Michigan's primary. Senator Chris Van Hollen then demands no coronation for Senate leader, urging Democrats to use all leverage to end the Iran war, impeach Pete Hegseth, block Trump judicial nominees, and cut off unconditional aid to Israel — framing the wins as a grassroots-up movement, not a Washington-driven one. Both panels reject rigid ideological labels and call for structural party reform. Key lesson: Democrats won by running candidates who look, sound, and live like their districts — not by chasing donor approval or consultant orthodoxies. The party must now translate that energy into governing power, starting with a public debate over Senate leadership and an aggressive legislative agenda.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Republicans are investing in AI chatbot infrastructure to manipulate search results while Democrats have almost no comparable operation.
AIPAC spent $80 million in the Michigan Democratic primary alone — more than the $60 million spent to elect Abdul El-Sayed in the general election.
Democrats spend only about 2% of paid media budgets on search advertising while corporate advertisers spend roughly 25%.
Roger Marshall's Kansas Senate seat was winnable largely because he was personally unpopular and little-known, not just because Adam Hamilton was a strong candidate.
Bobby Pulido, a Tejano music star, won a South Texas House race by doing quinceañeras after his opponent mocked him as only qualified to perform at them.
Democratic consultants charge fees so high that Danielle Butterfield calls it an 'oligarchy problem' diverting resources from actual campaigns.
Key takeaways
Candidate authenticity and community connection matter more than fundraising ability — The Bench recruited 16 candidates by prioritizing 'how much do you look, sound, and live like the people in your district' over money, yielding wins in Texas, Kansas, Montana, and North Carolina.
Democrats severely underinvest in digital advertising relative to voter behavior — only ~50% of budgets go digital while voters spend 80%+ of time online, and just 2% on search vs 25% for corporate advertisers, leaving a massive persuasion gap.
Earned media through authentic candidate moments breaks through better than traditional paid ads — James Tallarico's viral faith-based speeches and Bobby Pulido's quinceañera tour defined them before Republican attacks could stick.
AIPAC spent $80 million in the Michigan Democratic primary alone to boost Haley Stevens against Mallory McMorrow and Abdul El-Sayed — more than the $60 million spent to elect El-Sayed in the general — revealing the power of dark money in primaries and the complicity of Senate leadership.
The Democratic consultant class has an 'oligarchy problem' with excessive fees that divert resources from campaigns — Danielle Butterfield called for fixing a system where working in politics affords lifestyles far beyond what campaigns can sustain.
Senate Democrats must not coronate a new leader without a public debate on agenda — Van Hollen demands commitments on ending the Iran war, clawing back ICE funding, advancing a public option, and passing anti-corruption measures before any leadership vote.
Democrats should use all legislative leverage (NDAA, funding bills) to end the Iran war and block Trump nominees — Van Hollen advocates holding up the defense authorization and judicial confirmations until the war stops and extremist nominees are rejected.
The 2026 victories were a grassroots-up movement, not top-down — Van Hollen emphasizes the American people's resilience drove the wins, not Washington strategy, and the party must honor that energy with bold action.
Notable quotes
“the first question they start with is how much money can you raise? And that's a piss-poor way to pick a a nominee.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:16“we're a car brand trying to advertise to people who don't even have a driver's license.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:17“the reason there's such a hunger for outsiders is because most insiders suck.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:34“he's just like uh oof too many to count... let me tell you this, I named my son Remington.”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:08“there should be no coronation of the next Democratic leader.”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:05“this was a movement from the grassroots up to Washington. This was not a Washington to the country election.”
▸ Notable quotes · 95:24Chapters
0:48 — Election Night Realizations: Panelists describe the moments on election night when they knew Democrats would win big — Morris Katz watching Kalshi odds shift, Liz Smith seeing Florida's 22nd district flip, and Danielle Butterfield's data chief vibrating as Indiana and Florida returns came in.
2:40 — Campaign Roles in 2026: Each panelist outlines their campaign work: Morris Katz on Texas, Alaska, Georgia, Michigan, and California races; Liz Smith on The Bench's 16 recruited candidates; Danielle Butterfield on Priorities USA using the midterm as a learning lab for 2028 presidential pathways.
3:42 — Candidate Recruitment & Authenticity: The Bench's model prioritizes candidates who look, sound, and live like their districts over fundraising ability — yielding stars like Bobby Pulido (Tejano musician in South Texas), James Tallarico (faith-driven viral speeches in Texas), and Jamie Ager (outperformed top of ticket in Western NC).
6:02 — Ad Spending & Digital Gap: Priorities USA reveals Democrats spend ~50% of budgets on digital while voters spend 80%+ of time online; only 2% goes to search vs 25% for corporate advertisers. Butterfield warns the party is too slow adapting to a rapidly changing internet and lacks metrics to measure ad breakthrough.
10:35 — Earned Media vs Paid Ads: Authentic candidate moments — Tallarico's viral speeches, Pulido's quinceañera tour — built identity before attacks landed. Morris Katz argues ad quality matters more than quantity: ads must not look like political ads, using candidates comfortable creating content (walk-and-talk style).
21:48 — Insiders vs Outsiders & Labels: Morris Katz defends 'good insiders' like Roy Cooper: people want government that works, not just outsiders. Danielle Butterfield warns against labeling candidates (moderate/progressive/insider/outsider) — MAGA has a verb, Democratic labels are empty. The through-line: candidates willing to fight the status quo based on local concerns.
38:43 — Michigan Primary & AIPAC Influence: AIPAC spent $80M boosting Haley Stevens against Mallory McMorrow and Abdul El-Sayed — more than the general election spend. Morris Katz details AIPAC's dark money, deceptive ads, and Schumer's behind-the-scenes pressure. Panelists call for super PACs to build infrastructure, not just buy ads.
64:06 — Van Hollen: Senate Leadership & Trump Accountability: Senator Van Hollen rejects a coronation for Senate leader, demanding a public caucus debate on agenda: end the Iran war via NDAA leverage, impeach Pete Hegseth, block Trump judicial nominees, claw back ICE funding, advance public option/Medicare for All, and pass anti-corruption reforms. He frames 2026 as a grassroots-up mandate.
Speakers
John Lovett — Host
Liz Smith — Democratic Strategist
Danielle Butterfield — President, Priorities USA
Morris Katz — Partner, Fight Agency
Alex — Host
Chris Van Hollen — U.S. Senator