Are We The Only Ones Who Think This Is Better Than The First?! HALLOWEEN II (2009) MOVIE REACTION

Original Media · 1h 43m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Jackie and John react to Rob Zombie's Halloween 2 (2009), praising its gritty realism, psychological depth, and visceral direction while critiquing its supernatural mother/white horse imagery. They then answer viewer questions and rank all 13 Halloween films, both placing the 1978 original at #1 but diverging on Rob Zombie's entries.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The white horse/mother hallucinations are diegetic — both Michael and Laurie experience them, implying a shared psychic bond rather than just Michael's psychosis.

•

Octavia Spencer appears in a brief nurse cameo during the hospital dream sequence.

•

Tyler Mane (Sabertooth from X-Men 2000) plays Michael Myers, bringing imposing physicality that explains the character's supernatural durability.

•

The director's cut ending has Laurie shot by police after stabbing Loomis, then a sad cover of 'Love Hurts' plays over her dying fantasy of reuniting with her mother.

•

Rob Zombie's dialogue for non-horror scenes is noted as quirky, sexist, and hyper-specific — characters speak in idiosyncratic, grounded vernacular.

Key takeaways

•

Rob Zombie's Halloween 2 leans into gritty, visceral realism with shaky cam and prolonged practical violence that feels uncomfortable rather than glorified.

•

Laurie Strode's trauma is portrayed with raw authenticity — panic attacks, dissociation, and self-destructive behavior — making her arc the emotional core.

•

Michael Myers is humanized through grunting, inner-child visions, and a shared psychic connection with Laurie via their mother's ghost/white horse imagery.

•

Sheriff Brackett (Brad Dourif) and Annie (Danielle Harris) provide grounded, heartbreaking relationships that elevate the stakes beyond typical slasher fare.

•

The theatrical ending (Laurie puts on the mask) was a studio-mandated reshoot; the director's cut kills Laurie, Loomis, and Michael in a bleak finale.

•

Rob Zombie initially refused a sequel; the studio greenlit it anyway, leading him to attempt killing all main characters in his preferred cut.

•

The franchise's multiple timelines are a feature, not a bug — they offer distinct entry points for different horror tastes (grounded, supernatural, camp, psychological).

•

Both hosts rank the 1978 Carpenter original #1, but John places Rob Zombie's 2007 remake at #2 while Jackie ranks it #6, citing its overwhelming realism as initially off-putting.

Notable quotes

“It's not pretty, you know. Yeah. I do have an appreciation for that. There's no shine to it. There's no... Yeah. It's very gritty, which I understand.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:04

“I think what makes it interesting too is that one of the haunting figures that is a part of Michael's psychosis is mom, the maternal figure. It's another woman.”

▸ Notable quotes · 53:11

“The mission has transferred. The mission has transferred. She does look like the child. That's why they recast him. And you know what? Hell yeah. It really works.”

▸ Notable quotes · 61:22

“I like that these were different. I agree. Which I think is kind of funny because I really have hated how the Friday the 13th ones are so different than the original.”

▸ Notable quotes · 84:41

“It's iconic and classic for a reason. So that's our ranking. What? What? What do you say? All right, everyone start arguing in the comments.”

▸ Notable quotes · 102:27

Chapters

•

0:00 — Reaction: Watching Halloween 2 (2009): Jackie and John watch Rob Zombie's Halloween 2 with live commentary, reacting to the hospital opening, Laurie's trauma dreams, Michael's grunting physicality, the white horse/mother imagery, and the brutal kills of Annie and others.

•

64:19 — Post-Movie Discussion: They discuss Rob Zombie's directing style (texture, shaky cam, grounded dialogue), the psychological vs supernatural elements, Laurie's realistic PTSD portrayal, and the heartbreaking Brackett/Annie relationship.

•

69:35 — Viewer Q&A: They answer questions about Michael's grunting, the director's cut ending, franchise timeline multiplicity, Season of the Witch, gaming channel plans, and whether the film belongs in their top 5.

•

89:00 — Franchise Rankings (All 13 Films): Both hosts rank all 13 Halloween movies. Agreement on #1 (1978 original) and bottom tier (6, 5, Ends, Resurrection), but divergence on Rob Zombie entries: John has 2007 at #2 and 2009 at #3; Jackie has 2007 at #6 and 2009 at #5/6.

Speakers

•

Jackie — Co-host

•

John — Co-host

⋮