Why Trump's meeting with Xi and Putin may be 'deeply unnerving' for U.S. allies and partners

Original Media · 9m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Former CIA China analyst John Zin discusses President Trump's upcoming Asia trip, where he'll meet with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in an unprecedented three-way summit. Zin argues Trump enters weakened after midterm losses, while Xi and Putin's tight alliance — rooted in shared opposition to the U.S. — puts Trump at a strategic disadvantage. The NVIDIA chip controversy is unlikely to arise directly but is shifting domestic China policy toward a more hawkish stance.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Trump explicitly said he would not raise the NVIDIA matter with Xi, suggesting Xi could bring it up instead — an unusual public abdication of leverage before a summit.

•

Zin argues a 'happy' Trump-Xi-Putin meeting would be more unsettling than a failed one, because it would signal alignment among three adversarial powers at U.S. expense.

•

The Xi-Putin relationship dates to the very start of Xi's tenure, not just a reaction to recent events — their 'back to back' framing has been consistent for over a decade.

Key takeaways

•

Trump's midterm election losses weaken his leverage heading into the Asia summits, a common pattern for second-term presidents entering a lame-duck period.

•

Xi and Putin have cultivated a deep strategic alignment over four years, framing their partnership as 'standing back to back' against the United States, which they believe the U.S. cannot effectively counter when they act in concert.

•

The unprecedented three-way meeting with Trump, Xi, and Putin carries heavy symbolic weight — allies will see it as Trump conciliating adversaries rather than countering them, evoking unsettling historical parallels to the Yalta Conference.

•

Any outcome from the Trump-Xi-Putin meeting is fraught: a friendly outcome suggests U.S. accommodation of adversaries, while a contentious one risks open conflict among three nuclear-armed powers.

•

The NVIDIA export-control controversy is unlikely to be raised by Xi (who would find it awkward) or pressed by Trump (who has shrugged off similar issues), but it is reshaping domestic politics in Washington toward a more hawkish China policy.

•

Republican and Democratic incentives are converging on tougher China legislation — Republicans to counter perceptions of corruption and elite capture, Democrats to define a post-midterm China strategy — which could trigger renewed escalation if Congress passes stricter export controls.

•

Trump's personal affinity for pomp and circumstance makes him susceptible to being 'played' by Xi and Putin, who understand how to flatter him into feeling like a world-historical figure while extracting strategic gains.

•

The timing of potential NDAA legislation tightening export controls — right before a scheduled Trump-Xi meeting next month — creates a diplomatic trap: China may view congressional action as violating a leader-level understanding, prompting retaliation.

Notable quotes

“I think what it underscores is that he's not going into this meeting in a particularly advantageous situation.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:09

“There's a really tight nexus between President Trump and between President Xi and President Putin.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:22

“I think for a lot of U.S. allies and partners, this is going to be deeply unnerving and unsettling to see these three men sitting together.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:37

“If this meeting goes very well, and these three men walk out of it very happy, that could be unsettling.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:09

“They see their shared animus towards the United States as a linchpin of this relationship, right?”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:08

“Their calculation is that if they do so, there's not a good way for the United States to be able to counter them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:23

Chapters

•

0:00 — Trump's Asia trip and weakened position: Trump heads to Asia for the East Asia Summit and APEC, including an unprecedented three-way meeting with Xi and Putin. He enters weakened after midterm losses, a typical lame-duck dynamic where staff wants him on the world stage.

•

1:22 — Xi-Putin strategic alignment: Xi and Putin have built a deep four-year partnership rooted in shared opposition to the U.S., framing it as 'standing back to back.' This alignment complicates Trump's ability to play them against each other.

•

2:33 — Symbolic weight of the three-way meeting: The visual of Trump, Xi, and Putin together unnerves allies, evoking Yalta. A friendly outcome suggests U.S. accommodation; a hostile one risks open great-power conflict. Neither advances U.S. interests cleanly.

•

4:46 — NVIDIA controversy and domestic politics: The NVIDIA chip issue is unlikely to surface in the summit but is shifting Washington toward hawkish China policy. Republicans and Democrats converge on tougher export controls, risking escalation if Congress acts before the next Trump-Xi meeting.

Speakers

•

Rachel Maddow — Host

•

John Zin — Guest

⋮