ETERNALS REACTION - The Movie We Both Got WRONG?! | ROAD TO DOOMSDAY COMMENTARY

Original Media · 1h 34m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Two hosts rewatch Marvel's Eternals (2021) as part of their 'Road to Doomsday' MCU retrospective. Greg initially hated the film at its premiere but grew to defend it, while Coy liked it initially but enjoys it less on rewatch. Both converge on a B- rating, agreeing the film's ambitious concepts — celestials, the trolley problem on a cosmic scale, mythology-as-superheroes — are stronger than its execution, and that the story would have worked far better as a TV series.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Eternals are essentially 'fancy robots' — their memories are wiped after each planetary emergence, and they've done this on countless worlds.

•

Ikaris murdered Ajak (his leader/mother figure) centuries ago to protect the Emergence secret, then lived with the guilt for millennia.

•

The Deviants were Arishem's first attempt at planetary predators; they went rogue, so he built the Eternals to fix his mistake — making the 'heroes' the cleanup crew for a god's error.

•

Druig, who opposes blind obedience, runs a mind-controlled peaceful compound — a hypocrisy the film acknowledges but never fully explores.

•

Harry Styles was cast as Eros/Starfox in a post-credits scene teasing a major cosmic franchise that never materialized due to the film's reception.

•

Chloé Zhao (fresh off an Oscar win for Nomadland) directed this; its failure reportedly impacted her career trajectory.

•

The film's 'present day' scenes feel less engaging than its historical flashbacks — the opposite of typical superhero structure.

Key takeaways

•

The film's visual scope, location shooting, and celestial imagery are widely praised and hold up better than remembered.

•

The central twist — Eternals are synthetic beings with erased memories, created by Arishem to cull Deviants (his earlier mistake) — reframes them as unwitting villains and poses a universe-scale trolley problem.

•

Character dynamics are uneven: Thena/Gilgamesh and Druig's moral complexity shine, but the leads (Sersi/Ikaris) lack chemistry and feel underdeveloped.

•

Pacing is the film's fatal flaw: too much exposition, not enough lived-in history; a ticking clock arrives far too late.

•

Action choreography — especially speed/flying sequences — is underappreciated and arguably the best in the MCU.

•

The star-studded cast (Jolie, Hayek, Madden, Chan, Nanjiani, Keoghan, Styles) reflects peak MCU goodwill post-Endgame, but most characters get insufficient screen time.

•

Poor reception likely killed planned sequels and cosmic storylines (Eros/Starfox, Ten Rings/Kang connections, Black Knight).

•

Both hosts agree an 8-10 episode series would have allowed the concepts, debates, and relationships to breathe.

Notable quotes

“This is top third Marvel. It is right at the bottom of the top third, but top third Marvel.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:06

“I'm 10 toes down on this. This is one of them. I'm glad that you feel that passionately about it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:25

“Still the best speed I think in a comic book movie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:58

“This movie's biggest enemy is runtime. Unfortunately, it would be such a good show.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:34

“The twist that allows for the perception of them as heroes is so genius. We're following villains of humanity in a way.”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:17

“It's the trolley problem but on like a universal scale.”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:53

“I think this movie was like a couple of rewrites away from being a great movie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:37

“I enjoy more what they posit than how it's actually executed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 80:34

“The concepts still work for me. The last two action scenes I thought were great.”

▸ Notable quotes · 79:04

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Initial Reactions: Hosts Greg and Coy introduce their Eternals rewatch as part of 'Road to Doomsday.' Greg hated it at premiere but defended it later; Coy liked it initially but expects to like it less. Both note the film's polarizing reception.

•

2:10 — Opening Sequence & Visual Praise: The prologue with Arishem, the Celestials, and the Deviants is visually stunning. Hosts praise the location shooting, scope, and IMAX cinematography — a departure from typical MCU green-screen work.

•

6:00 — Present Day & Character Introductions: Sersi, Sprite, and Dane Whitman in modern London. Deviant attack reveals powers. Hosts note the adult tone, real-world logic (Dane deducing Sersi's nature), and the challenge of introducing 10+ characters.

•

14:00 — Historical Flashbacks & Mythology Building: Flashbacks to Babylon, Tenochtitlan, and other eras show Eternals guiding humanity. Hosts prefer these scenes — they're prettier, more clever, and answer 'where were they during history?' questions.

•

35:00 — The Twist: True Purpose Revealed: Ajak's death leads to Arishem revealing the truth: Eternals are synthetic, memories wiped, created to cull Deviants so Celestials can emerge. Earth is a host planet. The trolley problem on a cosmic scale.

•

39:00 — Reuniting the Team & Action Sequences: Sersi and Ikaris recruit others: Kingo, Gilgamesh/Thena, Druig, Phastos. Action in Druig's compound and the Amazon. Hosts praise the team choreography and Gilgamesh/Thena's dynamic.

•

55:00 — Character Dynamics & Moral Debates: Druig's mind-control hypocrisy, Phastos' faith in humanity, Ikaris' rigid loyalty, Thena's Mahd Wy'ry. The Uni-Mind plan forms. Hosts note the leads lack chemistry but supporting dynamics shine.

•

72:00 — Final Battle & Uni-Mind: Ikaris betrays the team; Tiamut emerges. Sersi leads Uni-Mind, turns Tiamut to marble. Ikaris flies into the sun. Arishem judges Earth. Hosts call the climax visually spectacular but emotionally unearned.

•

77:00 — Post-Credits & Future Implications: Eros/Starfox (Harry Styles) and Pip appear; Dane Whitman touches Ebony Blade. Hosts discuss how poor reception likely killed sequels and cosmic MCU plans. Both rate it B-.

Speakers

•

Greg — Co-host

•

Coy — Co-host

⋮