Doctors Play Emergency Room Video Games

Original Media · 50m · English · YouTube · Doctor Mike

TLDR

ER doctor Dr. Donald Pettit and host Mike play three medical simulation games — a paramedic ambulance simulator, an ER simulator, and an 1889 period piece using humoral theory — critiquing each game's realism, medical accuracy, and gameplay mechanics while humorously failing triage, procedures, and diagnosis.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The paramedic game uses the term 'anamnesis' for history-taking, which the doctors found unnecessarily archaic compared to 'history' or 'HPI'.

•

The ER simulator's X-ray and CT scan showed the pneumothorax on opposite sides (right vs left), and the ultrasound view was anatomically nonsensical.

•

Getting an 'A' grade in the paramedic game despite one of two patients dying (triaged black) revealed a disconnect between scoring and clinical outcomes.

•

The 1889 game requires players to guess medication dosages (e.g., 'seven to nine doses') with no clinical rationale, and the doctor character self-medicates with absinthe during shifts.

Key takeaways

•

The paramedic game requires proper scene safety assessment before entering dangerous areas, triage categorization (red/yellow/green/black), and procedures like C-spine immobilization that the players initially missed.

•

Real paramedics can transport multiple patients simultaneously, but the ambulance simulator artificially restricts players to one patient per ambulance, forcing difficult prioritization choices.

•

The ER simulator includes detailed procedural steps for wound care, imaging interpretation, and interventions like chest decompression, but suffers from a cumbersome interface and medical inaccuracies such as contradictory X-ray and CT scan results for pneumothorax laterality.

•

In the ER game, the players administered IV tetanus (never done in real practice) and intubated a patient without sedation, highlighting how game mechanics can encourage unsafe practices.

•

The 1889 game 'First Do No Harm' uses humoral theory (blood, phlegm, yellow bile, black bile) as actual treatment mechanics rather than modern evidence-based medicine, with players matching symptom colors to humor vials.

•

Real emergency medicine relies heavily on teamwork — nurses, techs, registration staff — which is entirely absent in these single-player simulations where the doctor performs every role.

•

Triage in mass casualty events requires rapid simultaneous assessment of multiple patients, but the games present patients sequentially, missing the chaos and resource allocation challenges of real scenes.

•

Game mechanics often gamify complex clinical skills into mini-games (drawing burn dressings, timing needle insertion) that bear little resemblance to the actual psychomotor skills involved.

Notable quotes

“Can't help people if you're one of the patients.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:34

“They could have figured out a better word. All right, so blast injury. We're worried about a lot of things with blast injuries.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:52

“It's way harder than uh wrapping it life.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:39

“That's the most satisfying thing when you stick a needle in somebody's chest and the whole room just pauses for 1 second and you hear like... And then the patient can breathe.”

▸ Notable quotes · 39:14

“I would be a happy man if medicine only had four choices of medicines. Four choices with a book that tells you exactly how to do it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:17

“This is how RF imagines medicine to be.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:23

Chapters

•

0:00 — Ambulance Life paramedic simulator: The doctors play a paramedic simulator, responding to a blast injury and a house fire. They struggle with driving, triage categories, burn assessment, IV access, and chest compressions during transport. One patient dies despite their efforts, but they receive an A grade.

•

28:08 — ER Simulator: In the ER simulator, they treat a leg laceration requiring suturing and a patient with pneumothorax. They navigate wound care, imaging (X-ray, CT, ultrasound), chest decompression, and disposition. The game shows contradictory imaging results and unrealistic solo-provider workflow.

•

40:39 — First Do No Harm (1889 period game): The final game uses humoral theory in an 1889 island village. Players match symptom colors to humor vials (blood, phlegm, yellow bile, black bile) and guess dosages. The game devolves into hallucinations, self-medication with absinthe, and surreal narrative elements.

Speakers

•

Mike — Host/narrator

•

Dr. Donald Pettit — ER physician

⋮