YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING EXPLAINED | WTF Is This Movie?

Original Media · 21m · English · YouTube · New Rockstars

TLDR

Erik Voss reviews A24's nearly three-hour documentary 'You Can See Everything,' directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, which gains unprecedented access to Elizabeth Holmes and her husband Billy Evans in the weeks before her prison sentence. The film evolves from a conventional profile into a meta-layered experiment when Fielder brings in Amanda Seyfried to reenact off-camera moments, exposes a profit-sharing demand from Evans citing the Harry and Meghan Netflix deal, and ends with ambiguous footage of Fielder swimming with Holmes that blurs the line between journalist and subject.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Billy Evans explicitly modeled his profit-sharing demand on the Harry and Meghan Netflix deal, treating a documentary about his incarcerated wife as a comparable commercial venture.

•

Elizabeth Holmes had never heard of the 'Who's on First' routine and could not grasp the joke, which the filmmakers treat as a revealing cognitive moment rather than a cultural gap.

•

Amanda Seyfried agreed to participate in the documentary reenacting Elizabeth Holmes reacting to Seyfried's own prior portrayal of Holmes — a recursive casting that the film presents as spontaneous but which required Seyfried to watch footage of the real Holmes watching her performance.

•

Nathan Fielder intentionally reveals his own recent breakup and move-out to the audience as a way to 'set up the possibility that he might be romantically compromised' regarding Holmes, a meta-disclosure that mirrors the film's theme of performed vulnerability.

•

The final shot of Billy Evans handing Holmes turkey jerky in the prison yard mirrors an earlier moment where Fielder claims Holmes asked him to get that exact snack from a vending machine, suggesting Fielder may have been unknowingly reenacting a spousal ritual.

Key takeaways

•

The documentary begins as a profile of Elizabeth Holmes in her final weeks of freedom but transforms into a hall-of-mirrors examination of media manipulation when Nathan Fielder casts Amanda Seyfried to restage his own interactions with Holmes, creating a recursive loop where an actor plays a real person playing a character.

•

Billy Evans, Holmes's husband, demanded a financial share of the film's profits during an off-camera meeting with A24 executives, citing the Harry and Meghan Netflix deal as precedent, and secured a temporary profit-sharing agreement that Fielder says he would walk away from if made permanent.

•

Evans controls Holmes's public persona to an extraordinary degree: he runs her Twitter account (admitting 80% of tweets are copied from her prison emails without her knowledge), licensed her likeness for publicity stunts including a nightclub recreation of her arrest, and obtained her power of attorney while she was incarcerated.

•

Fielder uses the Abbott and Costello 'Who's on First' routine as a Turing test for Holmes; she smiles but admits she doesn't understand the joke, which Fielder and Voss interpret as revealing a fundamental disconnect in her communication or cognition.

•

The film constructs an AI-generated version of Holmes — created via a 3D body scan at Evans's request — that reads bedtime stories to their children while she is in prison, echoing Holmes's earlier discomfort with being compelled to pose for the infamous magazine cover that defined her public image.

•

The ending refuses closure: previously unseen footage shows Fielder and Holmes swimming together and holding hands in the ocean, complicating the filmmaker-subject relationship, while on-screen text reveals Evans ultimately declined payment and the New York Times stands by its original quote — 'They're not playing me, they're playing a character I created' — now reframed by the film's own layers of performance.

Notable quotes

“They're not playing me, they're playing a character I created.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:00

“I knew they were talking about it, but hold up, wait.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:17

“No, you don't.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:23

“That is the ultimate Turing test. That just shows that something is wrong with Elizabeth Holmes.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:59

“By having Amanda Seyfried play Elizabeth Holmes for the back half of this movie, they're playing a character that I created.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:08

“We don't even know who the eye now of that sentence is.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:17

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Theranos Background: Erik Voss introduces the A24 documentary 'You Can See Everything' and summarizes the Theranos fraud case, Elizabeth Holmes's conviction, and the 2022 Hulu series 'The Dropout' that popularized the story.

•

2:34 — Filmmakers' Origins and Access: Lance Oppenheim cold-emailed Nathan Fielder after seeing he watched 60% of Oppenheim's film; they bonded at the Magic Castle where a magician's audience shout-out of 'Elizabeth Holmes' sparked the project idea.

•

4:46 — Beach Cottage: 34 Days Before Prison: Fielder and Oppenheim gain intimate access to Holmes and Evans at their Del Mar rental, where Fielder suspects evasiveness, challenges Holmes on the New York Times quote dispute, and becomes an on-screen subject himself.

•

9:47 — The 'Who's on First' Turing Test: Fielder shows the Abbott and Costello routine to Holmes and Evans; Holmes admits she doesn't understand the joke, which Fielder interprets as a revealing moment about her communication or cognition.

•

10:13 — AI Holmes, The Dropout, and Move to Texas: Holmes reacts negatively to 'The Dropout' portrayal; undergoes a 3D body scan for an AI avatar to read bedtime stories to her kids; the family relocates to Texas for her prison surrender at Bryan Federal Prison.

•

11:12 — Meta Turn: Amanda Seyfried and Reenactments: Two years later, Fielder brings in Amanda Seyfried to restage off-camera interactions; Christopher Abbott plays Billy Evans; the film reveals Evans's profit-sharing demand and temporary deal with A24.

•

13:13 — Evans's Control and Power of Attorney: Evans is shown running Holmes's Twitter, licensing her likeness for stunts, staging a nightclub arrest recreation, and obtaining her power of attorney; he embraces conservative politics and confronts Seyfried over her past comments.

•

14:28 — Prison Visit Reenactment and Swimming Footage: Fielder attempts a one-on-one prison visit (recreated with Seyfried); Holmes expresses resentment toward 'The Dropout' and vague awareness of the profit deal; unseen footage shows Fielder and Holmes swimming and holding hands.

Speakers

•

Erik Voss — Host

⋮