BREAKING: Federal judge drops MAJOR Election Day ruling

Original Media · 13m · English · YouTube · Brian Tyler Cohen

TLDR

On election day, legal analysts Brian Tyler Cohen and Glenn Kirschner discuss a federal judge's injunction blocking the Trump administration from sending lists of allegedly ineligible voters to states, and the Supreme Court's unanimous refusal to intervene in a related California case. They argue these efforts constitute voter intimidation and suppression, noting courts are rejecting such tactics.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Supreme Court's unanimous denial (including Thomas and Alito) of Trump's election-related emergency appeal signals a potential shift.

•

The Nevada case revealed the federal government's list of 16,000 alleged noncitizen voters yielded zero actual ineligible voters after state investigation.

•

Judge Chutkan — who oversaw Trump's Jan 6 prosecution — was assigned this case and ruled against the administration on Privacy Act grounds.

Key takeaways

•

Judge Tanya Chutkan issued an injunction prohibiting DOJ and DHS from transmitting voter eligibility lists to states, ruling it likely violates the Privacy Act of 1974.

•

The Supreme Court unanimously denied the Trump administration's emergency appeal in a California case involving 20,000 voters — a 19-word order with no noted dissents.

•

The Ninth Circuit en banc ruling affirmed that states run their elections and can disregard federal voter lists.

•

In Nevada, a federal list of 16,000 alleged noncitizen voters was revised to 185, and state investigation found zero ineligible voters.

•

The executive branch has zero constitutional role in administering elections; states administer elections under the 10th Amendment.

•

Glenn Kirschner suggests the Supreme Court may be done enabling Trump's unconstitutional election interference attempts.

Notable quotes

“She is prohibiting the Department of Justice and DHS from transmitting these lists of potentially ineligible voters to the states deciding that among other things it likely violates the privacy laws specifically the privacy act of 1974.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:33

“The application for injunction pending appeal presented to Justice Kagan and by her referred to the court is denied.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:22

“States administer elections. So the federal government's role is not non-existent. Why? Because congress can pass some laws in the election arena. Guess what branch of government has zero role in administering our elections? That would be the executive branch.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:37

“Trump blows right through the express language and the express prohibitions of the Constitution.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:01

Chapters

•

0:00 — Judge Chutkan's Injunction Blocks Federal Voter Lists: Federal Judge Tanya Chutkan issues an injunction prohibiting DOJ and DHS from transmitting lists of allegedly ineligible voters to states, citing likely violations of the Privacy Act of 1974. Glenn Kirschner characterizes this as federal intimidation of state election workers.

•

2:51 — Supreme Court Unanimously Rejects Trump Appeal: The Supreme Court issues a 19-word unanimous order denying the Trump administration's emergency appeal in a California case involving 20,000 voters. Justice Kagan referred it to the full court; no dissents noted, including from Thomas and Alito.

•

5:49 — Ninth Circuit En Banc Ruling and Nevada Precedent: The Ninth Circuit's en banc ruling affirms states control their elections. The Nevada example shows a federal list of 16,000 alleged noncitizens revised to 185, with state investigation finding zero ineligible voters — demonstrating the unreliability of federal lists.

•

10:22 — 10th Amendment and Federal Role in Elections: Discussion of constitutional structure: states administer elections; Congress can legislate but the executive branch has zero role in election administration. Trump's actions violate express constitutional prohibitions.

Speakers

•

Brian Tyler Cohen — Host

•

Glenn Kirschner — Legal Analyst

⋮