TLDR
This Supreme Court oral argument addresses whether a death row inmate can file a second or successive habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2244(b)(2) based on the DSM-5's revised intellectual disability criteria, when the governing precedent (Atkins v. Virginia) was decided before his first petition. The case centers on interpreting whether Atkins constitutes a "new rule of constitutional law made retroactive to cases on collateral review" that was "previously unavailable" to the petitioner.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The DSM-5 change (2013) is the sole basis for Johnson's claim; no prisoner has been authorized to proceed under the DSM-5-TR (2022) updates.
The state concedes that if the Supreme Court made Moore v. Texas retroactive, Johnson could proceed under that new rule, but Moore has not been made retroactive.
The federal government's position creates two different timing windows: "new rule" tied to conviction finality, "previously unavailable" tied to first habeas filing.
Johnson's counsel admits the DSM-5 is both a fact and part of the legal standard, blurring the statutory divide between § 2244(b)(2)(A) and (B).
The Court's hypothetical about a rule barring execution after age 70 revealed deep disagreement about ripeness and the nature of Atkins claims versus competency-to-be-executed claims.
Key takeaways
The state argues Atkins is not a "new rule" for Johnson because it was decided five years before his conviction, and the rule was "previously available" during his first habeas petition since he invoked Atkins then.
The federal government agrees with the state on "new rule" timing (tied to conviction finality under Teague) but argues "previously unavailable" timing is tied to the first habeas filing, creating two distinct temporal inquiries.
Johnson's counsel contends the DSM-5 change rendered the Atkins rule "previously unavailable" because his claim had no possibility of merit under DSM-IV, and that the DSM is part of the legal standard, not merely a factual predicate.
Justices debated whether "new rule" incorporates Teague's timing (relative to conviction finality) or is a term of art for watershed rules made retroactive by the Court.
The Fifth Circuit's "no possibility of merit" standard for "previously unavailable" was scrutinized, with analogies to PLRA exhaustion cases (Booth v. Churner, Ross v. Blake).
Justices questioned whether DSM updates are factual or legal changes, and whether allowing successive claims based on evolving diagnostic standards undermines AEDPA's finality goals.
Johnson's counsel acknowledges the claim could be framed under both § 2244(b)(2)(A) (new rule) and (B) (new fact), but the Fifth Circuit foreclosed the (B) pathway.
An amicus brief warns that DSM evolution could enable "eternal Atkins claims"; Johnson's counsel argues the Fifth Circuit's "possibility of merit" test prevents endless successive petitions.
Notable quotes
“Rather than pursue error correction at all costs, Congress chose to allow new claims in these applications only in limited circumstances that do not include changes in the diagnostic standards for intellectual disability.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:14“The rule of Atkins is not a new rule of constitutional law that was previously unavailable to him under Section 2244.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:48“We think that any claim based on the DSM or based on a diagnosis under an updated DSM would be properly reviewed under 2244. These sorts of updates in scientific evidence... can provide new factual predicates for claims.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:45“Atkins did leave the definition of intellectual disability to the states. And then even in Hall, where this court placed a greater emphasis legally on updated medical definitions, it's still reiterated that the legal determination of intellectual disability is distinct from a medical diagnosis.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:50“The Fifth Circuit correctly interpreted the federal successor statute. It did so according to the ordinary meaning of that statute's words. Under that interpretation, a rule is new when the case in question announced a novel legal standard.”
▸ Notable quotes · 42:42“The current medical standard for evaluating intellectual functioning in the DSM-5 created a previously unavailable factual basis for the claim. And the Supreme Court's decision in Moore versus Texas created a previously unavailable legal basis.”
▸ Notable quotes · 57:32Chapters
0:00 — State's Opening Argument: Texas argues that § 2244(b)(2) bars Johnson's successive petition because Atkins was decided before his crimes and was available during his first habeas petition; DSM-5 changes are factual, not legal, and do not create a new rule.
1:30 — Questioning on "Previously Unavailable" and "New Rule": Justices probe the meaning of "previously unavailable" — whether it focuses on the rule or the claim, and whether DSM updates are facts or part of the legal standard. Debate over Teague's role and the timing of "new rule".
28:25 — Federal Government's Argument: The U.S. supports Texas on "new rule" timing (conviction finality) but argues "previously unavailable" is tied to first habeas filing. Defends Fifth Circuit's "no possibility of merit" test and distinguishes Atkins from competency-to-be-executed claims.
42:42 — Respondent's Argument: Johnson's counsel argues the Fifth Circuit correctly interpreted "previously unavailable" to mean no possibility of merit; DSM-5 is both a factual and legal change because Atkins tethered the constitutional standard to medical criteria.
55:37 — Rebuttal and Submission: Texas clarifies agreement with the U.S. on dual timing framework; emphasizes that neither § 2244(b)(2)(A) nor (B) permits Johnson's claim under current law; case submitted.
Speakers
Mr. Petersen — Counsel for Petitioner (Texas)
Mr. Ferguson — Counsel for the United States (Amicus)
Mr. Shepard — Counsel for Respondent (Johnson)
Chief Justice Roberts — Chief Justice of the United States
Justice Thomas — Associate Justice
Justice Alito — Associate Justice
Justice Kavanaugh — Associate Justice
Justice Kagan — Associate Justice
Justice Gorsuch — Associate Justice
Justice Barrett — Associate Justice
Justice Jackson — Associate Justice
Justice Sotomayor — Associate Justice