Cop accused of murdering pregnant Sandra Birchmore — what does his twin brother know?

Original Media · 40m · English · YouTube · Brian Entin

TLDR

In the federal murder trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, reporter Michelle McPhee details how Farwell allegedly groomed Sandra Birchmore from age 12 in a police explorers program, began a sexual relationship when she was 15, and murdered her at 23 when she became pregnant. The case exposes a web of corruption involving Farwell's twin brother, another officer, and a state police investigation that immediately ruled her death a suicide despite evidence of a staged hanging, facial injuries, and 40,000 incriminating text messages. A lead investigator allegedly told Farwell's brother "we need this case like we need a bullet to the head." The twin brother appears to be cooperating with federal prosecutors. The trial is expected to last five weeks and may lead to charges against other officers. The police chief who pushed for a real investigation was placed on administrative leave.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The state police investigator who told Billy Farwell "we need this case like we need a bullet to the head" was the lead trooper on the death investigation and had personal ties to the Farwell brothers from high school.

•

Matthew Farwell was the police union president who publicly fought mask mandates, yet wore a COVID mask and hood to Sandra's house on the day she died — the only time colleagues saw him masked.

•

The complex ligature knot tied around a doorknob and Sandra's neck would have required her to perfectly slam the door to create a fatal hanging — a method a forensic expert called having a "narrow chance" of being self-inflicted.

•

Sandra's friend called the police department to report the affair out of spite over an unpaid debt, and the dispatcher who took the call tipped off Farwell instead of reporting it up the chain.

•

The baby's father was a U.S. Army recruiter introduced to Sandra through the Farwell brothers; videos of their sexual encounters were found on the brothers' phones, prompting investigators to alert the military.

•

Robert Devine, who started the explorers program that gave the Farwells access to Sandra, had previously used police power to jail a woman he had an affair with — the same "5150/crazy" narrative now used against Sandra.

Key takeaways

•

Matthew Farwell, a 27-year-old detective, allegedly began grooming Sandra Birchmore when she was 12 in the Stoughton Police Explorers program, friending her on Facebook at 15 and taking her virginity months later — statutory rape in Massachusetts — while he married his wife one month after.

•

The sexual relationship continued for eight years until Sandra's death at 23. She was pregnant and believed Farwell was the father; his wife was also about to give birth. Federal prosecutors argue he murdered her to prevent his life from unraveling after a friend reported the affair to the police department.

•

Farwell's twin brother Billy and another officer, Robert Devine (who founded the explorers program), also allegedly had sexual relationships with Sandra, often on duty. Devine used the alias "Marty Riggs" from Lethal Weapon. Federal prosecutors may charge this as theft of services and fraud on taxpayers.

•

The Massachusetts State Police initially ruled Sandra's death a suicide within hours, before the medical examiner examined the body. A lead trooper, John Fanning — who went to high school with Farwell — allegedly told Billy Farwell: "We need this case like we need a bullet to the head." The investigation missed facial injuries, a complex ligature knot, and 40,000 text messages.

•

Billy Farwell is on the witness list and appears to be cooperating with federal investigators, having provided the "bullet to the head" quote. His testimony against his twin brother could be a pivotal "Cain and Abel" moment in the trial.

•

Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara hired independent investigators who uncovered the misconduct, held a press conference, and got the officers decertified. She was then placed on administrative leave and claims in a lawsuit it was retaliation for pursuing the case.

•

Robert Devine had a prior sex scandal involving an affair with a subordinate; when she caused workplace issues, he had the Norfolk County DA arrest her. A respected police chief quit the department over it, calling Devine a "known liar." The town only demoted Devine, keeping him in a position to mentor the Farwell brothers.

•

The defense strategy relies on the state's failure to charge Farwell as proof of innocence. Prosecutors are taking the unusual approach of arguing the state investigation was a cover-up. A federal judge has already called the evidence against Farwell "overwhelming."

•

Sandra left a detailed digital roadmap: texts about Farwell looking in her closet and shower curtain days before her death, arranging pet care for her cats, picking up baby clothes, and planning her future — all inconsistent with suicide. The last text she sent was "Doors open" after Farwell asked to stop by during a blizzard wearing a mask and hood despite being anti-mask.

Notable quotes

“She's a small child and she's a vulnerable child. Remember, today Sergeant Robert Koon took the stand and said that the the kids who were in the stolen police explorers program primarily came from broken homes. They were kids that were looking for direction, and certainly Sandra fit into this category.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:17

“This girl got allegedly raped when she was 15. You know, this is somebody who went to this program to find mentorship, to find male guidance, and instead and her family has made these allegations in a civil suit, instead she was groomed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 13:23

“Fanning told him, "Sandra Birchmore committed suicide. We're not investigating this. The job needs this case like it needs a bullet to the head."”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:35

“We're talking about cops, some of whom have a GED, who are looking at this crime scene and calling it a suicide without any any investigation whatsoever.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:59

“The defense pretty much is the state never charged Farwell, so he didn't do it. The prosecution is saying the state didn't tell didn't um charge Farwell because they were covering it up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:18

“He leaves roughly 20 minutes later. She never moved again. We know now know that that's when she died and drives back to the hospital where he is photographed cradling his newborn son wearing the same clothes he wore to Sandra Birchmore's home.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:30

Chapters

•

2:17 — Courtroom atmosphere and Farwell's presence: Michelle McPhee describes the federal courtroom vibe: no supporters for Farwell, his imposing 6-foot-plus stature contrasted with tiny 5'2" Sandra, and the defense's implausible claim she tied a complex ligature knot around a doorknob and her neck to stage her own hanging.

•

4:57 — Sandra's background and grooming timeline: Sandra joined explorers at 12, lost both mother and grandmother within a month at 15, leaving her alone. Farwell, then 27, friended her on Facebook, lured her to library tutoring sessions, and allegedly took her virginity at 15 — statutory rape — one month before marrying his wife.

•

9:24 — Multiple officers allegedly exploited Sandra: Internal affairs report alleges Farwell's twin brother Billy and explorers founder Robert Devine also had sexual relationships with Sandra. Devine used the alias "Marty Riggs." Federal prosecutors may charge on-duty exploitation as theft of services and fraud.

•

10:54 — The tip, cover-up, and failed state investigation: A friend reported the affair to Stoughton PD; the dispatcher tipped off Farwell. He panicked. State police ruled it suicide immediately, missed facial injuries and the complex knot, didn't take Farwell's phone, and a lead investigator with personal ties to Farwell allegedly said they needed the case "like a bullet to the head."

•

18:12 — Prosecutors vs. investigators: unusual dynamic: Defense uses state's non-prosecution as proof of innocence. Prosecutors argue the state investigation was a cover-up. A federal judge has called evidence "overwhelming." This role reversal — prosecutors attacking the police investigation — is highly unusual.

•

21:14 — Sandra's last day and digital roadmap: Sandra spent her last day planning her future: arranging pet care for her cats, picking up baby clothes, texting about school. She texted a friend days earlier that Farwell was strangely looking in her closet and shower curtain. Last text: "Doors open" after Farwell asked to visit during a blizzard.

•

24:54 — Surveillance video, mask, and timeline: Video shows Farwell arriving at Sandra's home masked and hooded despite being anti-mask union president. He left 20 minutes later; she never moved again. He drove back to the hospital in the same clothes, photographed holding his newborn son.

•

33:40 — Billy Farwell cooperation and Devine's pattern: Billy Farwell is on witness list and appears to be cooperating, having given feds the "bullet to the head" quote. Robert Devine has a history: used police power to jail a former affair partner; a police chief quit over it; town only demoted him, keeping him as mentor to the Farwells.

Speakers

•

Brian Entin — Host

•

Michelle McPhee — Guest reporter

⋮