Sandra Birchmore: Breakup or Murder Cover-Up? The Jury Has to Decide | Matthew Farwell

Original Media · 54m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

This episode covers the closing arguments in the federal trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, charged with murdering 23-year-old pregnant Sandra Birchmore in 2021 and staging it as a seated hanging. Prosecutors argue Farwell strangled her to silence her about their relationship that began when she was 15; defense claims suicide citing her mental health history. The jury is now deliberating. Key forensic disputes include a broken hyoid bone (more common in strangulation), a chest mark inconsistent with the ligature hardware, and a 26-minute window where Farwell was the only person in her apartment. Farwell did not testify. A critical legal hurdle: prosecutors must prove Farwell killed her specifically to prevent her from reporting to federal authorities, not just to his wife or local police. Reporter Christina Rex provides courtroom insights.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The medical examiner originally ruled the death a suicide despite a seated hanging with hands free — a rare and suspicious scenario.

•

The defense's own forensic pathologist, Dr. Thomas Andrew, first examined the actual ligature (the strap) on the very day he testified, saying 'Seeing the ligature today didn't change squat.'

•

On cross-examination, Dr. Andrew agreed that bruising in the neck muscles occurs in fewer than 6% of hangings but is much more common in strangulation — undermining his own suicide opinion.

•

The defense claimed 'not a shred of evidence' Farwell had a key to Birchmore's apartment, despite text messages showing they discussed making him one and the apartment was found locked from the inside.

•

The federal charge hinges on Farwell believing Birchmore would report him to the FBI specifically — not just to his wife or local police — a high bar the defense argues is a 'bridge too far' for the jury.

•

Christina Rex described Dr. Andrew's cross-examination as 'the toughest cross I've ever watched,' where he became so defensive it 'made you forget the credibility he had gained on direct.'

Key takeaways

•

Sandra Birchmore, 23 and pregnant, was found dead in a seated hanging from a closet door handle in Feb 2021; the medical examiner initially ruled suicide, later changed to undetermined.

•

Former Stoughton officer Matthew Farwell is on trial for her murder; federal prosecutors allege he strangled her and staged the scene to prevent her from disclosing their relationship that began when she was 15 and her pregnancy.

•

The defense argues suicide, citing Birchmore's 2017 journal entries about suicide, history of self-harm, a search for the suicide awareness ribbon color the night she died, and dire personal circumstances.

•

Forensic evidence is sharply contested: a broken hyoid bone (prosecution says more common in strangulation; defense says can occur in partial hanging), a chest mark from a carabiner not matching crime scene photos, and phone data showing her last steps at 9:40 PM with Farwell leaving at 9:43 PM.

•

Farwell did not testify. The defense's final expert, Dr. Thomas Andrew, was heavily impeached on cross-examination, admitting he first examined the ligature the day he testified and that neck bruising occurs in <6% of hangings but is common in strangulation.

•

The federal charge requires proving Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from reporting a federal crime (statutory rape/color of law violation) to federal authorities — a specific intent element the defense argues is unsupported because she only threatened to tell his wife or local police.

•

Reporter Christina Rex notes the defense's closing was more cohesive than its opening but still faces 'a tough set of facts'; she highlights the 3-minute window between Birchmore's last recorded steps and Farwell's departure as a major prosecution point.

•

Jury deliberations began Friday afternoon; historical metrics suggest one day of deliberation per week of trial (4-5 weeks), but overwhelming evidence could yield a faster verdict.

Notable quotes

“Seeing the ligature today didn't change squat.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:23

“When all hope is lost, when you're at rock bottom, do you pick up your phone? You do if you're Sandra Birchmore.”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:39

“When you have no one left who cares or whether you matter at all... are you going to pick up the phone and scroll Instagram? Or did she sit down and take that strap and sit down as she knew how to do and make that pain stop?”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:53

“At this time, I do not elect to testify.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:02

“The fact that the hyoid bone is broken on the side where she wasn't applying pressure makes no sense.”

▸ Notable quotes · 46:22

“He was so defensive and just getting so worked up that it was like it made you forget the credibility he had gained on direct.”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:23

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case Background and Charges: Ashley Banfield introduces the Sandra Birchmore case: 23-year-old pregnant woman found dead in a seated hanging in 2021; former Stoughton officer Matthew Farwell on trial for murder, accused of staging suicide to silence her about their underage relationship and her pregnancy.

•

4:00 — Defense Case: Suicide Argument: Defense presents psychiatrist citing Birchmore's 2017 journal entries, self-harm history, and a search for suicide ribbon color the night she died as evidence of suicidal intent; prosecution cross-examines expert's lack of personal knowledge of Birchmore.

•

7:00 — Forensic Battle: Hyoid Bone and Chest Mark: Defense calls medical examiner colleagues and a hyoid bone expert to challenge prosecution's strangulation theory; experts admit hyoid fractures more common in strangulation, chest mark inconclusive, and defense experts hadn't examined evidence firsthand.

•

10:00 — Digital Forensics and Phone Data: Defense digital expert shows Birchmore's phone saved a purple ribbon image while scrolling Facebook; challenges step-count reliability but confirms phone locked at 9:13 PM, last steps at 9:40 PM, no activity after — aligning with Farwell's 9:14 arrival and 9:43 departure on camera.

•

13:00 — Defense Final Expert Impeached: Dr. Thomas Andrew testifies hanging caused death, manner undetermined; on cross, admits first seeing ligature that day, agrees neck bruising rare in hanging but common in strangulation, and was unaware Farwell had been in Birchmore's closet before her death.

•

16:40 — Farwell Declines to Testify: Farwell informs the court he will not testify; defense rests. Banfield comments this was likely strategic given the damaging evidence.

•

17:20 — Closing Arguments: Two Narratives: Prosecution walks through 26-minute timeline, signs of struggle (flip-flops, glasses, phone), lack of goodbye notes, and Birchmore's excitement about motherhood. Defense counters with Birchmore's despondency, financial stress, texts blaming Farwell, and claims she killed herself immediately after he left.

•

26:00 — Federal Charge Element: Witness Tampering Intent: Critical legal issue: prosecution must prove Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from reporting to federal authorities specifically. Defense argues she only threatened to tell his wife or local police; reporter Christina Rex calls this a potential 'hiccup' for the jury.

•

29:00 — Courtroom Insights and Jury Deliberation: Christina Rex describes defense closing as theatrical but facing 'tough facts'; highlights 3-minute window, mask-wearing inconsistency, and disturbing crime scene photos shown repeatedly. Jury deliberating Friday afternoon; verdict timing uncertain.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

•

Christina Rex — Guest Reporter

•

Matthew Farwell — Defendant

•

Sandra Birchmore — Victim

•

Brian Fogerty / Liz Riley — Prosecutors

•

Kimberly Stevens — Defense Attorney

•

Dr. William Smock — Prosecution Expert

•

Dr. Thomas Andrew — Defense Expert

⋮