TLDR
This Crime Weekly episode examines the murder of Ashley Flynn, who was shot in her home on February 16, 2026. Her husband Caleb claimed a break-in, but investigators uncovered a years-long affair with Aleah Boatner, a 22-year-old worship leader at their church. Despite Caleb's seemingly perfect life — a 15-year marriage, two daughters, a $200k job at his father-in-law's thriving business, and a close extended family — he and Aleah exchanged over 107,000 messages in one year, constantly discussing their hatred for Ashley and desire for her death, while Caleb lied to Aleah that Ashley had cheated and they were merely roommates. No evidence of Ashley's infidelity was found; her phone showed only desperate attempts to understand Caleb's distance and repair their marriage.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A 40-year-old worship pastor and a 22-year-old worship intern bonded over Harry Potter and got matching tattoos — he hid his in his armpit.
Aleah responded to Caleb's explicit statements about wanting to kill his wife with 'That affirms me so much. I love you, Caleb.'
Caleb claimed there was a statute of limitations on divorcing a spouse after infidelity, and Aleah never fact-checked this obvious lie during their nearly two-year affair.
Ashley's sister Kayla heard rumors of the affair but defended Caleb vigorously to police, saying she 'could not even fathom the thought' because she trusted him completely.
The couple used the code word 'douche' for Ashley because Caleb said he hated hearing her name — yet they discussed her constantly in their 300 daily messages.
Key takeaways
Caleb Flynn built a secret parallel life with Aleah Boatner, a worship leader 16 years his junior, while maintaining a public facade as a devoted husband, father, worship leader, and valued employee at his father-in-law's company.
The affair escalated rapidly: from daily texts and 'hugs' in March 2024 to a sexual relationship by May 2024, then to 107,000 recovered GroupMe messages in one year (averaging ~300 per day) filled with explicit fantasies about Ashley's death and plans to be together.
Caleb systematically deceived Aleah by claiming Ashley had cheated on him two years prior and they lived as roommates — a lie contradicted by Ashley's phone data, which showed only love, confusion, and efforts to reconnect with Caleb.
Aleah was not a passive participant; she demanded daily video proof Caleb was alone, grew jealous of his time with his daughters, and responded to his murder fantasies with affirmation, calling his desire for Ashley's death 'affirming.'
Ashley discovered the affair in October 2024 via messages on a shared iPad, searched whether iCloud could be hacked to fabricate conversations, and called Aleah — who refused to answer — before the couple switched to encrypted apps and daily deletion of messages.
The Smith family (Ashley's parents) had embraced Caleb completely: they vacationed together 25+ times, gave the couple $800 monthly for family experiences, and planned a succession where Caleb and Ashley would earn $600k annually — yet Caleb called them 'douche' and said he hated them in private messages.
Caleb hid a matching Harry Potter lightning bolt tattoo with Aleah in his armpit so Ashley wouldn't see it, while Aleah wore hers visibly; when questioned, Aleah admitted she 'understood' the concealment at the time.
The anniversary cruise in August 2025 became a flashpoint: Aleah pressured Caleb to avoid it, he falsely claimed he'd sent a cancellation letter, and when he went anyway, Aleah sent dramatic messages threatening self-harm if he didn't choose her.
Notable quotes
“I need her to die, to cheat again, to leave. I need you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 81:12“Kill douche.”
▸ Notable quotes · 82:48“I want her dead and gone. Is it fair to ask you to live this life with me the way we are now until I can figure this out?”
▸ Notable quotes · 83:54“If I could literally kill her and not go to hell, I would do it in a heartbeat. That's how dark and hateful I feel.”
▸ Notable quotes · 102:26“I've never wished that upon someone, but I have more than ever with her. That affirms me so much. I love you, Caleb. I just want you all to myself.”
▸ Notable quotes · 92:20“Why cater to Ashley and what she fucking wants? I'm so done with you. I know you have murdered my heart in every way. Hope you're glad you took my virginity and also my heart and stomped all over it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 104:16Chapters
0:13 — Introduction and victim background: Ashley Flynn was shot and killed in her home on February 16, 2026. Her husband Caleb claimed a break-in, but investigators soon uncovered a secret affair and a double life.
3:15 — Ashley and Caleb's life before the affair: Ashley and Caleb met at Lee University, married in 2010, had two daughters, and built a life deeply integrated with Ashley's close-knit family. Caleb worked for her father's successful flooring business, they attended church together, and the Smith family vacationed frequently and gave monthly financial gifts.
29:39 — Caleb's affair with Aleah Boatner begins: In summer 2022, Caleb met Aleah, a worship intern at their church. By March 2024, they were texting daily; he visited for 'hugs'; the relationship turned sexual by May 2024. Caleb lied that Ashley had cheated and they were roommates.
55:54 — Ashley discovers the affair: In October 2024, Ashley found messages on a shared iPad showing Aleah's hand with a drawn ring and texts about wanting to be Caleb's wife. She called Aleah, who didn't answer. The couple then switched to WhatsApp and GroupMe, deleting conversations daily.
69:00 — Escalation: 107,000 messages and murder fantasies: From February 2025 to February 2026, 107,000 GroupMe messages were recovered. They reveal constant discussion of hating Ashley ('douche'), wanting her dead, matching tattoos (hidden in Caleb's armpit), and Aleah demanding video proof Caleb was alone.
111:00 — The anniversary cruise and rising tension: Ashley's parents planned a 15th-anniversary cruise for August 2025. Aleah pressured Caleb to avoid it; he lied about sending a cancellation letter. When he went, Aleah sent dramatic messages threatening self-harm, and Caleb promised his heart would remain with her.
114:00 — Hosts' analysis and series preview: Stephanie and Derrick analyze the toxic dynamic, Aleah's manipulative behavior, and the legal question of her culpability. They preview the next episode covering the cruise, Ashley's further discoveries, and the murder investigation.
Speakers
Stephanie Harlow — Host
Derrick Levasseur — Co-host
Jill Smith — Ashley's mother
Kayla Smith — Ashley's sister
Todd Smith — Ashley's father
Matthew — Kayla's husband / Caleb's friend
Aleah Boatner — Caleb's mistress / worship leader
Caleb Flynn — Defendant / Ashley's husband
Savannah Clausen — Ashley's friend / former volleyball player