Connor Hellebuyck's Return To Winnipeg Went About As Bad As Possible...

Original Media · 6m · English · YouTube · The Pat McAfee Show

TLDR

The New Jersey Devils' decision to sit Connor Hellebuyck in his first return to Winnipeg after his trade request backfired completely. Devils GM Tom Fitzgerald cited analytics and expected win probability, but backup Jake Allen had historically poor stats against the Jets. Hellebuyck sat in the locker room due to Winnipeg's unique bench layout, the traded goalie got the win, and the drama now extends for a full year until the next matchup.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Three American players who just won Olympic gold over Canada immediately requested trades, with two of them playing for Canadian teams.

•

The Devils cited analytics to justify benching Hellebuyck, but the replacement goalie Jake Allen had the worst statistical matchup of his career against the Jets.

•

In Winnipeg's arena, the backup goalie sits in the corner among fans rather than on the bench, making it impossible for a high-profile backup to avoid direct fan interaction.

Key takeaways

•

The Devils' analytical justification for benching Hellebuyck was contradicted by Jake Allen's terrible historical performance against the Jets, making the decision appear disingenuous and purely narrative-driven.

•

Former teammate Hazel describes Hellebuyck as arguably the NHL's best goalie alongside Vasilevskiy, a fierce competitor who wants to play every game, making his benching even more surprising.

•

The NHL is experiencing an unprecedented wave of dramatic storylines, including three American Olympic gold medalists immediately requesting trades, two from Canadian teams.

•

Winnipeg's arena has a uniquely small bench forcing the backup goalie to sit among fans, meaning Hellebuyck could not dress as backup without creating a spectacle — the Devils should have either started him or not dressed him.

•

By not playing Hellebuyck, the Devils turned a one-night storyline into a year-long drama that will resurface when they next visit Winnipeg, whereas a single game would have provided closure.

•

The Devils' attempt to control the narrative with a pre-game statement citing 'expected win probability' was widely mocked and perceived as an insult to fans' intelligence.

Notable quotes

“I don't I don't think it's normal. But before I start, I just want to say happy Veterans Day to all the veterans.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:39

“I think the NHL stock is at an all-time high right now. Uh, the storylines that are coming out this season are are insane.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:56

“I played with Bucky. Uh Bucky is arguably the best goalie in the NHL. Um what he does on the ice, no one else really does. Maybe Vasileles, but no one else is really comparable to him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:22

“And Sunny Meta is he's like known to be very analytical which kudos to him. It's he he won cups in Florida. Uh Jerseyy's having a fantastic year. But I think he thought using that excuse would would make it easier on like the Jets fans and it just completely backfired.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:12

“Worst possible outcome by far. It was and also it was the best possible outcome for Winnipeg and the worst possible outcome for Jersey.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:34

“The crazy part is if he didn't go in the locker room cuz in Winnipeg the bench is so small that not the third goalie, the backup goalie sits over in the corner in the fans.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:13

Chapters

•

0:00 — Hellebuyck's Return and Devils' Decision: The episode opens with discussion of Connor Hellebuyck's first game back in Winnipeg after requesting a trade, where the Devils surprisingly chose not to play him despite his Olympic gold medal win.

•

0:39 — Hazel's Perspective on Hellebuyck and NHL Storylines: Former NHL player Hazel praises Hellebuyck as arguably the league's best goalie and notes the NHL's unprecedented level of dramatic storylines this season, including multiple American Olympians requesting trades.

•

1:53 — Devils' Analytical Justification Backfires: The Devils tried to get ahead of the decision with analytics, claiming reduced expected win probability, but Jake Allen's terrible historical stats against the Jets undermined their reasoning.

•

2:14 — Reading of Devils GM Statement: The hosts read the official statement from Devils GM Tom Fitzgerald explaining the organizational decision to sit Hellebuyck and coordinate a media availability instead.

•

3:00 — Why the Decision Failed and Prolonged Drama: Analysis of how the analytical excuse backfired, comparisons to other player returns like Brady Tkachuk and Quinn Hughes, and how this creates a year-long storyline until the next Winnipeg matchup.

•

4:44 — Winnipeg's Unique Bench Layout Complicates Situation: Discussion of how Winnipeg's small bench forces the backup goalie to sit among fans, making it impossible for Hellebuyck to dress as backup without a spectacle — he should have either played or not dressed.

•

5:45 — NHL Stock at All-Time High: Conclusion that despite the mishandling, the drama adds to the NHL's unprecedented storyline quality this season.

Speakers

•

Host — Host/Interviewer

•

Hazel — Former NHL Player / Analyst

⋮