“I Want Her Dead” | Caleb Flynn’s Mistress Testifies

Original Media · 41m · English · YouTube · Crime Weekly

TLDR

Crime Weekly News hosts Derrick Levasseur and Stephanie Harlow discuss the ongoing murder trial of Caleb Flynn, a former worship pastor and American Idol contestant accused of shooting his wife Ashley in her sleep on February 16, 2026. The prosecution's case centers on a year-and-a-half affair between Caleb and Aliyah Boatner, documented in over 100,000 messages where both repeatedly expressed hatred for Ashley and discussed killing her. Aliyah testified she did not believe Caleb would actually murder Ashley, yet she pressured him with ultimatums that made divorce impossible without Ashley's death, and the night before the murder sent him instructions for deleting digital evidence. Aliyah also conveniently lost her phone and laptop days prior, lied to the FBI initially, and visited Ashley's parents' home after the murder where Caleb told her, "It didn't happen the way we thought it would." The hosts debate whether Aliyah should face charges as an accessory or for conspiracy, drawing parallels to the Michelle Carter case. They announce this case will be their next deep-dive series.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Aliyah Boatner sent Caleb instructions for destroying digital evidence the night before he murdered his wife, yet she has not been charged and testified as a prosecution witness without immunity.

•

Both Caleb and Aliyah constantly invoked God and prayer in their messages while simultaneously plotting to kill Ashley, including saying "Praying now" and "Thank you for pray" in their final exchange before the murder.

•

Caleb worked for Ashley's father's business and stood to inherit $300,000–$400,000 annually upon the father's retirement — a financial motive that made divorce costly for him, yet he chose murder over simply waiting for the inheritance.

Key takeaways

•

Caleb Flynn and his mistress Aliyah Boatner exchanged over 100,000 messages in which both repeatedly stated they wanted Ashley dead, used dehumanizing nicknames like "douchebag," and discussed specific methods for killing her without legal consequences.

•

Aliyah Boatner gave Caleb multiple deadlines to leave Ashley but simultaneously demanded that after divorce, Ashley have zero contact with Caleb or their children — a condition Caleb could only meet if Ashley were dead, since she was a fit mother who would retain custody.

•

The night before the murder, Aliyah sent Caleb step-by-step instructions from ChatGPT on how to factory reset his phone and delete communications so evidence of their affair would not be recovered, indicating consciousness of guilt and coordination.

•

Aliyah Boatner lost both her cell phone and laptop in separate, highly convenient incidents during a solo Florida trip weeks before the murder, then initially lied to the FBI about the extent of her relationship with Caleb.

•

After Ashley's murder, Aliyah went to Ashley's parents' home where Caleb was present and he told her, "It didn't happen the way we thought it would, did it?" — suggesting a shared plan that went awry.

•

The hosts argue Aliyah should face criminal charges (accessory, conspiracy, or solicitation) because her relentless pressure, shared violent rhetoric, and evidence destruction go far beyond mere knowledge of Caleb's intent, drawing a comparison to Michelle Carter's manslaughter conviction for pressuring Conrad Roy to kill himself.

•

Caleb's defense appears to be that despite his affair and repeated statements about wanting Ashley dead, he did not actually kill her — an argument the hosts find implausible given the totality of digital evidence and his behavior on the 911 call and bodycam footage.

Notable quotes

“I want her dead, Caleb. It's so bad.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:18

“That makes two of us.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:19

“Here's I looked at ChatGPT and here's how you can completely like delete your communications. And how they they will be less likely to be recovered. Like here's how you go about deleting data and factory resetting your phone to keep the evidence of this affair from being found.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:24

“It didn't happen the way we thought it would, did it?”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:29

“I've been up till 4:00 in the morning thinking about ways to kill Ashley without going to jail.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:47

“We need a solution, Caleb. We need it to be you forever. No exceptions.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:54

Chapters

•

0:10 — Case Overview and Affair Details: Hosts introduce the Caleb Flynn murder trial: Ashley Flynn shot twice in the head while sleeping on Feb 16, 2026; Caleb called 911 claiming a home invasion; investigation revealed year-and-a-half affair with Aliyah Boatner and 100,000+ messages discussing killing Ashley.

•

4:00 — Financial Motive and Relationship Dynamics: Caleb earned $100k+ working for Ashley's father's business and stood to gain $300k–$400k annually upon the father's retirement, creating a financial incentive to stay married — yet he pursued an intense, controlling affair with Aliyah, who demanded total exclusion of Ashley from their future life.

•

9:00 — Escalating Violent Rhetoric and Pressure: Messages show both Caleb and Aliyah repeatedly stating they wanted Ashley dead, using dehumanizing nicknames, and discussing specific killing methods. Aliyah gave Caleb ultimatums to leave but also demanded impossible post-divorce conditions (zero contact with Ashley/kids), effectively requiring Ashley's death.

•

19:30 — Night Before Murder: Evidence Destruction Instructions: In their final messages before the murder, Aliyah sent Caleb ChatGPT-generated instructions for factory resetting his phone and deleting communications to hide their affair. Caleb responded he was choosing her and they exchanged 'Good night. Praying now.'

•

33:00 — Aliyah's Suspicious Behavior After the Murder: Aliyah conveniently lost phone and laptop weeks prior; initially lied to FBI about the affair; went to Ashley's parents' home post-murder where Caleb told her 'It didn't happen the way we thought it would'; later deleted messages asking Caleb if he was behind the killing.

•

35:00 — Legal Analysis: Should Aliyah Be Charged?: Hosts debate whether Aliyah's actions constitute accessory, conspiracy, or solicitation. Comparison to Michelle Carter case. Defense would argue hyperbolic venting, not genuine intent; prosecution would argue relentless pressure made murder the only path to their shared goal.

•

42:00 — Caleb's Defense Strategy and Upcoming Deep Dive: Caleb pleaded not guilty despite overwhelming digital evidence. Hosts speculate defense may claim Aliyah manipulated him. They announce this case will be Crime Weekly's next deep-dive series due to volume of material.

Speakers

•

Derrick Levasseur — Co-host

•

Stephanie Harlow — Co-host

⋮