‘A matter of how she’s going to win’: Mary Peltola edges closer to victory in Alaska's Senate race

Original Media · 12m · English · YouTube · MS NOW

TLDR

Mary Peltola holds a razor-thin lead in the Alaska Senate race at 49.98% — just shy of the 50%+1 threshold needed to avoid ranked-choice voting. With roughly 6,000 ballots left, mostly from rural areas that favor Democrats, both guests believe her victory is all but certain whether she crosses 50% outright or wins via ranked-choice tabulation, where data shows many Republican voters ranked her second.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Alaska voters preserved the ranked-choice voting system on the same ballot where a Democrat may flip a Senate seat in a state with only 12% Democratic registration.

•

The New York Times report alleging Peltola's campaign recruited the spoiler candidate was treated as a bombshell nationally but drew a 'meh' reaction from Alaskans, who already knew about 'Petersburg Dan' and largely shrugged it off.

Key takeaways

•

Peltola's 11,475-vote lead with 98% reporting makes her victory highly probable, but the AP has not called the race because she sits at 49.98% — just below the 50%+1 threshold that would trigger an automatic win under Alaska's system.

•

Even if the race goes to ranked-choice voting, the outcome likely won't change: a 50 MB data file on the Division of Elections website shows that more of the spoiler candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.'s voters ranked Peltola second than ranked the incumbent Dan Sullivan second.

•

Alaska's political landscape is uniquely nonpartisan: only 12% of voters are registered Democrats, yet Peltola may secure ~50% of the vote, reflecting a cross-partisan appeal built on affordability and economic populism rather than party loyalty.

•

The spoiler candidate — Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. of Petersburg — did not alter the race's trajectory; adding his votes to the incumbent's total still leaves Peltola ahead by ~15,000 votes, and ranked-choice data shows his supporters largely broke for Peltola as a second choice.

•

The AP's caution stems from the risk of calling a winner who then falls below 50% at 100% reporting, which would force a ranked-choice tabulation and create public confusion about whether the race was truly decided.

Notable quotes

“I would eat a whole raw salmon if Dan Sullivan incumbent pulls this one out.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:54

“This is sort of a cliffhanger that everybody knows the ending to.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:29

“Only 12 percent of voters in Alaska are actually registered Democrats. And yet, possibly 50 percent of voters voted for the Democrat in the Senate race.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:17

“There is a 50 megabyte zip file that's been hanging out on the Alaska Division of Elections website for the past two weeks that actually tells us pretty much exactly how this ranked choice voting tabulation plays out.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:08

“More of the secondary Dan Sullivan's voters actually ranked Mary Peltola second than ranked Dan Sullivan the incumbent second.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:29

Chapters

•

0:00 — Race status and 50% threshold: Peltola leads by 11,475 votes at 49.98% with 98% reporting; she needs 50%+1 to win outright and avoid ranked-choice voting, but remaining ballots favor her.

•

2:27 — Guest analysis: victory all but certain: Nathaniel Herz bets a raw salmon on Peltola winning; David Noriega reports ground confidence since election week as rural absentee ballots break heavily for Democrats.

•

4:17 — Alaska's nonpartisan politics and Peltola's appeal: Despite only 12% Democratic registration, Peltola nears 50% support by running on affordability and economic populism that crosses party lines in Alaska's independent political culture.

•

6:42 — Ranked-choice mechanics and AP caution: Published election data shows ranked-choice tabulation would still elect Peltola; AP hesitates to call the race because a sub-50% final count would trigger a confusing second round.

•

9:09 — Spoiler candidate impact debunked: Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.'s votes don't change the math — even combined with the incumbent they trail Peltola — and his voters ranked Peltola second, making the spoiler effect negligible.

Speakers

•

Ali Velshi — Host

•

David Noriega — Reporter

•

Nathaniel Herz — Editor

⋮