TLDR
The hosts critique Democratic consultant Liz Smith's career — from Cuomo's campaigns and cover-up to the IDC and Mallory McMorrow's failed bid — arguing she represents a consultant class financially incentivized to oppose progressive policies like Medicare for All. They dissect her recent Crooked Con comments equating Medicare for All with Republican ICE overreach, countering that M4A polls at 60-66% and is Democrats' strongest issue, while centrist consultants offer no coherent alternative vision.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Liz Smith changed her account of Cuomo's conduct in her book to be 'more convenient' after initially telling Letitia James she was unaware.
The IDC (moderate Democrats caucusing with Republicans) got 'nicer offices' as their main achievement, per Andrew Cuomo's approval.
Consultants like Smith appear on TV as neutral analysts while financially invested in defeating the very policies they criticize — a conflict rarely disclosed.
A candidate (Troy Jackson) successfully made the case for full Medicare for All replacement at an AOC town hall, showing the argument isn't 'too hard' as consultants claim.
Key takeaways
Liz Smith worked on Cuomo's 2018 campaign, his 2021 sexual assault cover-up (interviewed by Letitia James), Buttigieg's campaign, the IDC (breakaway Democrats who caucused with Republicans), and Mallory McMorrow's failed Senate bid.
Democratic consultants like Smith and Sarah Longwell have undisclosed financial conflicts: they earn commissions on ad buys for moderate candidates and lose money/power when leftists win with populist messaging and fewer resources.
The IDC's collaboration with Republicans in deep-blue New York inadvertently fueled the progressive/DSA backlash that brought AOC and others to power.
Liz Smith at Crooked Con compared Medicare for All to Republican ICE overreach, calling M4A 'political insanity' and claiming most Democrats didn't run on it.
Medicare for All consistently polls at 60-66% support, even when polls explain it replaces private insurance, contradicting consultant claims it's politically toxic.
Healthcare is Democrats' number-one advantage issue over Republicans, yet centrist consultants argue against leaning into the most popular policy (M4A).
Centrist Democrats have no coherent healthcare vision beyond 'expanding around the edges' and saving the ACA — a message they've failed to sell to voters.
Notable quotes
“I was at a progressive conference yesterday, um, Crooked Con. I heard people talking about two years Democrats are going to have 60 Senate seats and the first vote we need to do is to implement Medicare for all. And when I hear that, like I support celebrating this election. I do not support this irrational exuberance.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:21“This complete overreach with ICE uh where they created all this chaos in communities. We cannot make the same mistake.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:49“The majority of Democrats did not run on Medicare for all. You think Adam Hamilton... you think he got elected in Kansas by saying I want to kick everyone off their private insurance for expanding healthcare.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:03“That is the definition of political insanity.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:45“Medicare for all polls 60 66% different polling. Imagine thinking seeing a doctor will alienate the majority of Americans.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:49“Healthcare is the best issue that Democrats have. So maybe leaning into the policy that's most popular and that Abdullah Sayed has run on and norm and mainstreamed would behoove them if we were just looking at straight politics instead of what maintains the power of a certain class of Democrats like Liz Smith.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:33“You are as um devoid of ideas on healthcare at this point as the Republican party is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:50Chapters
0:00 — Liz Smith's Background and the IDC Legacy: Hosts detail Liz Smith's career: Cuomo 2018 campaign, 2021 cover-up (interviewed by Letitia James, changed story in book), Buttigieg campaign, IDC work (breakaway Democrats caucusing with Republicans for perks), and Mallory McMorrow's failed campaign. The IDC's GOP collaboration inadvertently fueled the progressive/DSA wave that elected AOC.
2:50 — The Consultant Class Conflict of Interest: Hosts argue consultants like Smith and Sarah Longwell have undisclosed financial incentives — commissions on ad buys for moderate candidates — and lose power when leftists win with populist messaging. They appear on media as neutral analysts while pushing spin that benefits their business model.
4:21 — Liz Smith at Crooked Con: Medicare for All vs. ICE: Smith compares Medicare for All to Republican ICE overreach, calling M4A 'irrational exuberance' and 'political insanity,' claiming most Democrats didn't run on it and citing a Kansas candidate as proof M4A is electorally toxic.
6:49 — Debunking the Anti-M4A Talking Points: Hosts counter that M4A polls 60-66% even when explained as replacing private insurance; healthcare is Democrats' top advantage issue; Troy Jackson successfully made the full-replacement case at an AOC town hall; consultants oppose M4A because their clients don't support it.
8:33 — Centrist Democrats' Vacuous Healthcare Vision: Hosts argue centrist Democrats offer only 'expand and prune around the edges' with no coherent policy goal, unlike single-payer as the clear best system. They've failed to sell their incrementalism and are 'devoid of ideas' on healthcare, mirroring Republicans.
Speakers
Host 1 — Primary host
Host 2 — Co-host