TLDR
This episode details the investigation into the disappearance and murder of 13-year-old Madeline Soto in Kissimmee, Florida, in February 2024. Her mother's boyfriend, Stefan Sterns, was the last person seen with her and became the prime suspect after surveillance footage, phone forensics, and physical evidence contradicted his accounts. Sterns was ultimately arrested on charges including sexual battery, possession of child sexual abuse material, and first-degree capital murder after Madeline's body was found hidden in a bamboo grove near St. Cloud. Her mother, Jennifer Soto, was not charged but faced intense scrutiny for her shifting statements and initial instinct to protect Sterns.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The surveillance footage of a girl at a church near the school that detectives initially thought was Madeline turned out to be a different child — a coincidental lookalike that wasted critical investigative time.
Sterns' father, Chris, is a retired Orange County deputy who ultimately cooperated with police and confronted his son in a recorded jail call, saying 'you participated in it which is just as bad as not starting it.'
Jennifer Soto's first reaction to seeing the abuse images on Sterns' phone was to ask his father to get him a lawyer, not to call police or protect her daughter.
Madeline had told her best friend she planned to run away when she turned 13 to access money she believed she would receive, providing an alternative narrative that initially diverted suspicion from Sterns.
The apartment complex security guard saw a 'woman like sleeping beside him' in the passenger seat when Sterns returned for his gate clicker — but Madeline was 13, not a woman, and appeared slumped over, possibly already deceased.
Sterns changed clothes between the early morning trash compactor visit (red shirt) and the vape shop visit, and discarded a damaged tire piece along with Madeline's belongings in the compactor.
Key takeaways
Stefan Sterns was the last known person with Madeline alive, dropping her off near school on February 26, 2024, but surveillance and license plate readers placed him miles away in St. Cloud during the time he claimed to be waiting for a vape shop to open.
Sterns factory-reset his phone the morning Madeline disappeared; forensic recovery revealed hundreds of images and videos of sexual abuse of Madeline dating back to when she was 8 years old, with a distinguishing mark on Sterns matching the perpetrator in the photos.
Madeline's backpack, school laptop, and one white Croc were found discarded in the apartment complex trash compactor, directly contradicting Sterns' claim that she walked to school with her belongings.
A search of Sterns' Google account revealed searches for the anesthetic sevoflurane and whether it would show up in toxicology tests, suggesting premeditation.
Sterns drove nearly 150 miles to Northport, Florida (his parents' home) at 4:35 a.m. the day after Madeline disappeared; his father later found a hard drive with over 35,000 child sexual abuse images in a storage unit.
Madeline's body was discovered hidden under hay and bamboo on private property near where Sterns changed a flat tire in St. Cloud; autopsy ruled cause of death as strangulation.
Jennifer Soto gave multiple inconsistent statements, initially claiming she saw Madeline get ready for school, later admitting she only assumed it; she also told Sterns' father to get him a lawyer before fully confronting the evidence against him.
Sterns faces 13 counts of sexual battery, 7 counts of lewd molestation, 39 counts of unlawful possession of obscene material, and first-degree capital murder; prosecutors intend to seek the death penalty at his trial set for September 2025.
Notable quotes
“I feel like sometimes people struggle to show real emotion when they're aware of what the truth is”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:18“if you've got nothing to hide give them your phone”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:12“I don't think she would run away... I feel like she was taken like on that short walk from where she was dropped off to the school”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:25“I assumed that I saw her I assumed that I heard her but I didn't in reality I didn't see her”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:43“we know he killed her we know he drove out of there Monday morning we know he discarded her backpack in the trash dumpster”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:24“you prioritized him by offering him or telling his dad to get him a lawyer not what the fuck did he do hey we need to figure out what happened no let's protect Stefan”
▸ Notable quotes · 60:18Chapters
0:00 — 911 Call and Initial Response: A 911 call reports Madeline Soto missing after she was dropped off at school but never arrived. Dispatchers are slow to respond due to other emergencies in the area.
2:54 — First Night Search and Surveillance Footage: Deputy Joseph arrives and interviews Jennifer and Stefan. Church surveillance shows a girl resembling Madeline sitting on property then walking away. K9 search fails to pick up her trail.
10:09 — Friend Interview and Runaway Theory: Madeline's best friend reveals she planned to run away at 13 to access money. Jennifer suggests Madeline's interest in WWII and 'living in the woods' may have motivated her.
15:29 — Contradictory Timelines Emerge: Jennifer and Stefan give conflicting accounts of when Stefan arrived, sleeping arrangements, and the morning routine. Jennifer admits she didn't actually see Madeline leave.
24:19 — Surveillance Contradicts Stefan's Story: Apartment cameras show Stefan at the trash compactor at 7:35 AM with Madeline slumped in the car. He returns at 8:19 AM. Security guard saw a 'woman sleeping' in the passenger seat. License plate reader places him in St. Cloud, 9 miles away, during the drop-off window.
30:18 — Phone Forensics and Factory Reset: Stefan claims his phone factory reset during an OS update. Forensics prove it was a manual reset requiring a password. Jennifer describes Stefan's panic about police having his phone.
34:07 — Flat Tire and Northport Trip: Stefan claims a flat tire on 192 but can't recall location. His father Chris reveals Stefan called about the tire hours before mentioning Madeline was missing. Chris suspects Stefan went to a storage unit.
46:05 — Trash Compactor Evidence and Confrontation: Madeline's backpack, laptop, and one Croc found in trash compactor. Detective confronts Stefan with evidence; he continues to deny. Stefan's changed clothing and multiple compactor visits noted.
49:00 — Digital Evidence of Abuse: Forensics recover hundreds of abuse images/videos from Stefan's phone and Google Cloud dating back to when Madeline was 8. Distinguishing mark on Stefan matches perpetrator. Searches for sevoflurane anesthetic found.
52:08 — Jennifer's Reaction and Interrogation: Jennifer is shown an abuse image; she asks about pressing charges and whether she can change her mind later. Detective accuses her of protecting Stefan and questions her sincerity.
68:00 — Body Discovery and Arrest: Witness leads police to bamboo grove near flat tire location in St. Cloud. Madeline's body found covered in hay. Autopsy rules strangulation. Stefan's hard drive with 35,000+ CSAM images found at father's storage unit. Stefan charged with capital murder and multiple sexual abuse counts.
Speakers
Narrator — Documentary narrator
911 Dispatcher — Emergency dispatcher
Jennifer Soto — Madeline's mother
Stefan Sterns — Jennifer's boyfriend / suspect
Deputy Joseph — Responding deputy
Detective — Lead investigator
Madeline's Friend — Best friend
Natalie — Roommate
Security Guard — Apartment complex guard
Chris Sterns — Stefan's father