The Detective and the Chewing Gum Sting | Post Mortem

Original Media · 26m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This episode of Postmortem discusses the 48 Hours season premiere "The Detective and the Chewing Gum Sting," detailing how cold case detective Susan Logothetti solved the 1984 murder of Judy Weaver and the 1980 murder of Susan Veasey using an elaborate undercover operation to obtain DNA from serial predator Mitchell Allan Gaff (later Sam Wise Price). Gaff, a Level 3 sex offender with a history of violent assaults, was caught when detectives posed as a fake gum company and tricked him into a taste test, leading to his arrest, confession, and 50-year sentence. The case also exonerated Judy Weaver's fiancé Bill Richards, who died under suspicion. Detective Logothetti's victim-centered persistence and innovative tactics brought closure to two families after decades. The episode highlights the predator's chilling duality — a soft-spoken, seemingly gentle man who viewed rape as equivalent to murder — and the systemic failures that allowed him to reoffend.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Gaff received only 1 year work release + 5 years probation for a 1979 armed assault on Jackie Brown, a Washington State Patrol officer who fought him off.

•

The Special Commitment Center allowed Gaff significant freedoms (casual dress, intensive therapy but not prison) despite his Level 3 "most likely to reoffend" classification.

•

Detectives created an elaborate fake gum company "Zolt" with LGBT-owned branding specifically tailored to Gaff's personal life to gain his trust.

•

Gaff participated in the gum tasting "like a wine sommelier," giving extensive flavor notes ("notes of this and hints of that") for four pieces of gum.

•

During interrogation, Gaff stated "to me a rape is just murder," revealing a complete moral disconnect from the violence he inflicted.

•

Ken Veasey's voicemail requesting a re-investigation arrived on the exact 45th anniversary of his wife Susan's body being discovered.

•

Detective Logothetti insisted on personally handcuffing Gaff at sentencing, saying "a woman should be the one to put handcuffs on a predator of women."

Key takeaways

•

Advances in DNA technology can solve decades-old cold cases and exonerate long-standing suspects.

•

Detective Susan Logothetti devised an innovative "chewing gum sting" — creating a fake LGBT-owned gum company called Zolt — to obtain DNA from a reluctant suspect.

•

Mitchell Gaff (Sam Wise Price) was a serial sexual predator who committed at least two murders while evading detection for 40 years, despite being a known Level 3 sex offender.

•

The Washington Special Commitment Center civilly confined Gaff for 23 years but released him in 2018, after which he lived openly as a Buddhist married to a man.

•

Journalist Tom Junod's 1995 GQ profile captured Gaff's chilling duality: a constructed "voice of the nicest guy" masking a "shark-like" vacancy and complete moral disconnect.

•

The gum sting exploited Gaff's ego — he enthusiastically provided sommelier-like tasting notes on four gum flavors while depositing saliva evidence.

•

Solving Judy Weaver's murder unexpectedly cracked a second cold case (Susan Veasey, 1980) after her husband Ken Veasey left a voicemail on the 45th anniversary of her death.

•

Detective Logothetti's persistent, victim-centered approach — including nightly calls to Ken Veasey — exemplifies effective cold case work; she personally handcuffed Gaff at sentencing.

Notable quotes

“"Bite, fight, scratch, kick, do whatever you need to do to survive."”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:16

“The first thing that strikes you about Mitch Goff is his voice. The voice is not merely soft, not merely sincere, not merely considerate, not merely kind. It is the essence of softness, sincerity, consideration, and kindness. It is the kind of voice that seems incapable of telling a lie, mustering aggression, or even allowing itself the freedom of an insult. It is the kind of voice that begs you to trust it. That pleads with you to trust it. And if you heard it on the street or in a bar, you would trust it immediately. It is the voice of the nicest guy you've ever met. It is a voice Mitch Goff has put together, has devised and constructed with great care, great courage, great effort, and at the cost of great pain. And that is why he is horrified and heartbroken. When he opens his thoughtful mouth, starts speaking in his thoughtful syllables, and scares the living hell out of people.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:16

“When you look into the eyes of a shark, they don't look like they hate you. They look like they don't care about you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:01

“He chewed that gum. It was like he was at a wine tasting. You know? He was talking about the notes of this and hints of that. He wound up chewing four pieces overall. Two tropical, two watermelon.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:50

“I I left her tied up, but that was it. I left she was fine. ... I didn't do anything to her. And I mean don't get me wrong, I tied her up for it. Well, I I think you should get your DNA thing and then I just probably talk to him again. Yeah, I think the system is really bad and to me a rape is just murder.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:22

Chapters

•

0:01 — Introduction & Judy Weaver Case Background: Host Anne Marie Green and correspondent Peter Van Sant introduce the season premiere about the 1984 murder of Judy Weaver in Everett, Washington. Her fiancé Bill Richards was the prime suspect but never charged; he died in 1994 under suspicion.

•

2:12 — Detective Logothetti Takes Over Cold Cases: In 2023, Detective Susan Logothetti volunteers to take over cold cases when her supervisor retires. She is passionate about DNA science and making perpetrators "look over their shoulder."

•

3:28 — DNA Match Reveals Unexpected Killer: DNA testing matches evidence to Mitchell Allan Gaff, a stranger to Judy and her family — not Bill Richards. Gaff is a Level 3 sex offender with a violent history.

•

4:25 — Gaff's First Known Attack: Jackie Brown (1979): In 1979, Gaff attacked Jackie Brown at gunpoint in her garage. She fought back using her father's advice, escaped, and identified him. Despite the violence, Gaff received only 1 year work release and 5 years probation.

•

6:35 — Subsequent Attacks & Civil Commitment: While on probation, Gaff murdered Judy Weaver (1984) and attacked sisters Angela and Myra (1984). He served 10 years for the latter, then was civilly committed to Washington's Special Commitment Center for 23 years as a sexually violent predator.

•

8:11 — Tom Junod's GQ Profile & Gaff's Release: Journalist Tom Junod profiled Gaff in 1995, describing his constructed gentle voice and "shark-like" vacancy. Gaff was released in 2018, married a man, changed his name to Sam Wise Price, and became a Buddhist.

•

12:13 — The Chewing Gum Sting Operation: Detective Logothetti creates fake gum company "Zolt" with LGBT branding. Detectives pose as salespeople, get Gaff to taste-test four gum flavors at his home. He provides detailed tasting notes, leaving DNA on the gum.

•

17:38 — Arrest and Interrogation: Police lure Gaff to the station under false pretenses. Logothetti interviews him about past crimes, then confronts him with a murder warrant. Gaff claims he left Judy alive and "fine," equating rape with murder.

•

20:33 — Second Cold Case Solved: Susan Veasey (1980): Ken Veasey leaves a voicemail on the 45th anniversary of his wife's murder. Logothetti runs Gaff's DNA — it matches Susan Veasey's crime scene (hog-tied, sexually violated, strangled with electrical cords).

•

22:27 — Resolution: Guilty Plea, Sentencing & Aftermath: Gaff pleads guilty to both murders in 2026, receives 50 years. Logothetti personally handcuffs him. Jackie Brown, now a "tower of strength," keeps broken fence boards as a reminder to never let her guard down.

•

24:10 — Closing Reflections: Peter Van Sant reflects on the damage left in Gaff's wake: lives lost, trauma, and men wrongly suspected. The case highlights dogged investigative work and the power of DNA to deliver justice decades later.

Speakers

•

Anne Marie Green — Host

•

Peter Van Sant — Correspondent

•

Detective Susan Logothetti — Cold Case Detective

•

Tom Junod — Journalist/Author

•

Jackie Brown — Survivor/First Victim

•

Ken Veasey — Husband of 1980 Victim

⋮