TLDR
When 65-year-old Marilyn Gandert disappears after evicting her daughter-in-law Alyssa and grandson Drake from a rental property, police uncover a coordinated murder carried out by Alyssa, Drake, and their roommate Annie. Marilyn was beaten, stabbed nearly a dozen times by her own grandson, and her body burned in a remote area. All three pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, receiving sentences of 12 to 30 years. Marilyn's son Ryan's death three years earlier — initially ruled a suicide during a game of Russian roulette — was revisited but remained classified as suicide.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The grandmother's own grandson stabbed her nearly a dozen times in the neck after she allegedly asked him to kill her — a claim he made to protect his mother.
Police initially left the rental property without finding any evidence, missing blood spatter on walls and carpet, Marilyn's purse, keys, and medication — all in plain sight during a second search with a warrant.
The victim's best friend identified the murder within hours by recognizing that text messages from the victim's phone were uncharacteristic, while trained officers treated it as a routine missing persons case.
All three killers pleaded guilty to second-degree rather than first-degree murder despite the premeditated, coordinated nature of the killing, including transporting the body 30 miles to burn it.
Key takeaways
Marilyn Gandert's eviction of her daughter-in-law Alyssa and grandson Drake over unpaid rent and property damage triggered the murder plot, with Alyssa harboring resentment because Marilyn blamed her for her son Ryan's death.
Drake Bickett, who suffers from schizophrenia, initially confessed to killing his grandmother at her request — claiming she repeatedly asked him to end her life — but investigators suspected he was protecting his mother.
Roommate Annie provided the decisive confession: all three were high on meth when Alyssa nodded for Annie to tackle Marilyn, Drake beat and stabbed her, and they took turns assaulting her before burning the body.
Officers missed critical evidence during their first search of the rental home — including Marilyn's purse, medication, keys, and blood spatter — because they were misled by the seemingly orderly move-out scene.
Nancy, Marilyn's coworker of 15 years, was the only person who immediately recognized the text messages allegedly from Marilyn were fake, insisting Marilyn would never hand over keys without supervising the eviction herself.
Harry Gandert, Marilyn's brother, blamed himself for urging Marilyn to evict Alyssa, believing that decision set the murder in motion; he had no other family left after Marilyn's death.
The investigation revealed a pattern of domestic violence: Ryan Bickett allegedly abused Alyssa for years, and Drake had a history of battery charges and police encounters due to his schizophrenia.
Despite initial suspicions that Alyssa may have also killed her husband Ryan three years earlier (during an alleged Russian roulette game), no new evidence emerged to change the suicide ruling.
Notable quotes
“My grandmother said, "I'm too old. Will you please kill me? Multiple times, drunk and sober."”
▸ Notable quotes · 41:59“She just told me when she nods cuz she would pretend that she was the don like like the godfather. She just told me when I nod get her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:03“I started walking like quickly behind them and I got Marilyn and from behind and took her down. And at that point I had gotten off of Marilyn cuz I had her pinned down and Drake got on top of her.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:21“We I think we all took turns after that doing that. Started stabbing her and I seen him like going at it a bunch of times and I grabbed the knife from him. He had already cut her throat.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:56“Come get the key on Friday. That is so not Marilyn. That's somebody texting from Marilyn's phone.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:22“I would not put those people past making sure she disappeared just because I mean, you know, the history of the house, alleged Russian roulette games.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:41Chapters
1:14 — Missing Person Report: Marilyn Gandert's brother Harry calls 911 when she doesn't answer calls or door; her car is home, dogs unattended, note from yesterday still there.
4:16 — Initial House Search: Officer Barnhill searches Marilyn's home with Harry and neighbor Nancy; finds made bed, keys on counter, medication out, dogs barking — no sign of Marilyn.
9:21 — Rental Property Visit: Officers go to Marilyn's rental on Taylor Ridge where Alyssa and Drake were evicted; Alyssa claims she's moving out per Marilyn's Friday text, but Nancy insists the texts are fake.
14:25 — First Search Misses Evidence: Officers search rental property with Alyssa's permission but overlook blood spatter, Marilyn's purse, keys, and medication; neighbor mentions alleged Russian roulette games linked to Ryan's death.
18:58 — Body Discovered: 911 call reports burned body on remote Rio Rancho road; officers find charred remains with exposed organs, two sets of small footprints leading to and from scene.
22:32 — Identification and Arrests: Dental records confirm body is Marilyn; detectives arrest Alyssa, Drake, and Annie after finding blood evidence in rental house and Annie's car.
41:02 — Drake's Confession: Drake confesses to killing grandmother at her request, claiming she repeatedly asked him to end her life; detective suspects he's protecting his mother.
45:25 — Annie's Full Confession: Annie details coordinated murder: all three high on meth, Alyssa signaled attack, Annie tackled Marilyn, Drake beat and stabbed her, they took turns, then burned body.
Speakers
Narrator — Host
Detective Wattis — Detective
Officer Barnhill — Patrol Officer
Harry Gandert — Victim's Brother
Nancy — Neighbor/Friend
Alyssa Bickett — Suspect
Drake Bickett — Suspect
Annie — Suspect
Detective Meyers — Detective
Detective Aaka — Detective
Detective Gutman — Detective