Dollar Tree vs. Costco Cooking Challenge

Original Media · 33m · English · YouTube · Mythical Kitchen

TLDR

Mythical Kitchen compares Thanksgiving sides made with Dollar Tree vs Costco ingredients. They prepare sweet potato casserole, green bean casserole, and stuffing using each store's products — Costco haul totaled $229, Dollar Tree $55. Guest judge Trevor Evarts blind-tastes both spreads and prefers the Costco versions overall, though the green bean casserole showed the only glaring canned-vs-fresh difference. Surprisingly, Dollar Tree's chicken stock tasted better than Costco's, and artificial vanilla outperforms real vanilla at high heat.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Dollar Tree's chicken stock tasted better than Costco's despite the huge price difference.

•

Artificial vanilla extract beats real vanilla in high-heat applications because volatile compounds burn off.

•

Canned sweet potatoes are nearly as good as fresh for casserole, and the syrup-packed version adds desirable sweetness.

•

The green bean casserole was the only dish with a glaringly obvious canned-versus-fresh difference.

•

The host considers Stove Top boxed stuffing superior to any homemade or restaurant version.

Key takeaways

•

The Costco ingredients cost $229 total versus $55 at Dollar Tree, making each casserole $32 at Costco and $24 at Dollar Tree.

•

Canned sweet potatoes (Bruce's yams packed in syrup) held up well against fresh yams — the canned version was sweeter, but fresh had superior texture.

•

Artificial vanilla extract outperforms real vanilla in high-heat baking because volatile compounds burn off, leaving only vanillin.

•

Dollar Tree's chicken stock tasted better than Costco's — more chicken flavor, not just salt or MSG.

•

The green bean casserole showed the biggest difference: canned green beans have a metallic taste that fresh beans avoid, though the homemade condensed cream of mushroom soup was convincing.

•

Peanuts substituted for pecans in the Dollar Tree sweet potato crumble, and the host believes peanuts may outperform pecans due to personal preference.

•

Stove Top boxed stuffing is considered the best-tasting version, and both homemade stuffings were modeled after it.

•

The blind taste tester preferred the Costco plate overall but noted the price difference might not justify the gap for all dishes.

Notable quotes

“Actual yams are like native to Africa, and they're super, super starchy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:40

“Artificial vanilla extract in blind taste tests often outperforms real vanilla because you're just getting the one thing, the vanillin, and that's left over after all those volatile compounds burn off.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:07

“No food in the world is better than Stove Top in a box.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:22

“Green beans really soak up the pennies.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:46

“I think that you've done a really beautiful thing here though. I think that you've made some really beautiful food all around, and I actually would love to take some home.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:45

“Now more than ever, we gotta find the things to be thankful for. So hug your loved ones and be kind.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:40

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro & Shopping Haul Comparison: Josh introduces the Thanksgiving sides showdown: Dollar Tree vs Costco. The Costco haul cost $229, Dollar Tree $55. They'll make sweet potato casserole, green bean casserole, and stuffing with each store's ingredients.

•

3:20 — Sweet Potato Casserole Preparation: Josh explains the yam vs sweet potato marketing history. Costco gets fresh yams boiled whole; Dollar Tree gets canned Bruce's yams in syrup. He makes a syrup with margarine, brown sugar, OJ, cinnamon, and artificial vanilla, noting artificial vanilla wins at high heat. Peanuts replace pecans for the Dollar Tree crumble.

•

13:42 — Green Bean Casserole Preparation: Dollar Tree version uses canned green beans, cream of mushroom soup, and bootleg fried onions. Costco version uses fresh French-cut green beans boiled until floppy, homemade condensed cream of mushroom soup with soy sauce and half-and-half, and Fresh Gourmet fried onions.

•

18:57 — Stuffing Preparation: Costco stuffing uses rustic loaf, fresh mirepoix, raw Smithfield sausage, and fresh herbs. Dollar Tree uses Bimbo white bread, frozen pepper-onion mix, jarred garlic, cooked sausage patties, and dried herbs. Both modeled after Stove Top boxed stuffing. Dollar Tree chicken stock surprisingly tastes better.

•

25:45 — Taste Test & Judging: Guest judge Trevor Evarts blind-tastes both plates. He prefers the Costco plate overall but identifies the green bean casserole as the only glaringly canned-tasting dish. Costco per-dish cost $32 vs Dollar Tree $24. Trevor plugs kindness and his history YouTube channel.

Speakers

•

Josh — Host/Chef

•

Lily — Producer/Crew

•

Trevor Evarts — Guest Judge

•

Producer — Off-camera Producer

⋮