Bombshell in 'Rich Kid's' Sorority Sister Killing Case

Original Media · 24m · English · YouTube · Law&Crime Network

TLDR

Fraser Bohm, 22 at the time, allegedly drove 104 mph in a 45 mph zone on Pacific Coast Highway's Dead Man's Curve in Malibu on October 17, 2023, killing four Pepperdine sorority sisters. He faces four counts of second-degree murder, a rare charge for a fatal crash without drugs or alcohol. The case has dragged over three years with repeated defense motions to dismiss. A new prosecution theory cites a nitrous oxide canister in the car as a distraction, while defense attorney Alan Jackson argues the star witness lied about seeing Bohm texting — phone forensics show the device was locked. The latest hearing was continued to November 20 after Jackson missed it due to surgery, and prosecutors expect the December 1 trial date to slip.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Bohm is one of the only defendants in the last decade involved in a fatal crash on that stretch of PCH to face murder charges, despite no evidence of drugs or alcohol playing a role.

•

The prosecution's star witness Victor Calandra testified under oath that he personally saw Bohm texting with both thumbs, but forensic phone data proved the device was locked and had zero user interaction for the entire 15 minutes before the crash.

•

The 10–12 lb nitrous oxide canister found in Bohm's car is of a type commonly installed in race cars for performance enhancement, and a factory kit exists for his exact BMW M5 model that includes such a canister.

•

Defense attorney Alan Jackson has now missed hearings in two separate high-profile cases within weeks, each time citing a serious medical issue requiring surgery, leading observers to question whether the absences are strategic delays.

Key takeaways

•

Fraser Bohm, then 22, allegedly accelerated to 104 mph in a 45 mph zone on PCH's Dead Man's Curve, striking and killing four Pepperdine seniors — Niamh Rolston, Peyton Stewart, Asha Weir, and Deslyn Williams — who were walking on the roadside.

•

Prosecutors charged second-degree murder, not vehicular manslaughter, arguing Bohm's decision to speed excessively while knowing the area's dangers and that speed could kill demonstrates implied malice.

•

The defense, led by high-profile attorney Alan Jackson, has filed multiple motions to dismiss the murder charges, contending the case is properly vehicular manslaughter; all such motions have been denied.

•

Phone forensics contradicted prosecution witness Victor Calandra's testimony that he saw Bohm texting with both thumbs at a red light moments before the crash — the phone was locked with zero user interaction for the 15 minutes prior.

•

A 10–12 lb nitrous oxide canister, dented and with blood on it, was found in Bohm's BMW after the crash; prosecutors argue it was a distraction, but the judge barred any suggestion Bohm inhaled it or was impaired.

•

Such large nitrous oxide canisters are commonly used in race cars for performance enhancement, and a BMW kit exists for Bohm's exact 2016 M5 model that includes a similar canister, raising questions about its purpose.

•

The defense sought to admit a 45-minute hospital video of Bohm after the crash containing alleged excited utterances, but the judge denied admission and ordered redactions.

•

Alan Jackson missed the November hearing due to an undisclosed injury requiring surgery and a cast — he also missed a separate hearing in October citing a major injury — prompting courtroom speculation about delay tactics; the case was continued to November 20, and prosecutors do not expect the December 1 trial date to hold.

Notable quotes

“The phone data later produced and analyzed by a forensic expert contradicted that testimony completely.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:06

“That phone was locked from 8:15 and 59 seconds p.m. until 8:30 and 6 seconds p.m. There was no user interaction with that device during the entire 15 minutes prior to the accident.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:15

“The expert established unquestionably that Mr. Colandra's testimony was false.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:31

“When he suggested that he personally saw Mr. Baum with both thumbs sort of gripping away at the keyboard, texting away, that was in fact a lie.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:37

“Defense has made multiple motions for multiple reasons to get the four counts of second-degree murder dismissed. They've made it clear they believe this is simply a vehicular manslaughter case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:09

“Fraser Bohm apparently stated he knew that area like the back of his hand and he was aware that speed could kill.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:44

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case introduction and victims: Host Chris Stewart outlines the case: Fraser Bohm, 22, allegedly killed four Pepperdine sorority sisters with his BMW on PCH's Dead Man's Curve in October 2023; he faces four second-degree murder counts; trial set for December 1 but delays persist.

•

0:52 — Crash details and murder theory: The four victims were seniors set to graduate; Bohm was driving a BMW M5 gifted by his parents at 104 mph in a 45 mph zone; prosecutors argue his acceleration from 93 to 104 mph seconds before impact shows implied malice, not accident.

•

4:56 — Star witness and defense challenge: Witness Victor Calandra claimed he saw Bohm texting at a red light and warned him to slow down; defense attorney Alan Jackson presented phone forensics showing the phone was locked with no user interaction for 15 minutes before the crash, calling Calandra's testimony a lie.

•

6:02 — Defense strategy and Alan Jackson: Alan Jackson, who defended Karen Read, argues the case is vehicular manslaughter, not murder; he has filed multiple dismissal motions, all denied; he compares the charges to the Bryan Kohberger case to highlight the unusual murder charge for a traffic crash.

•

8:08 — Latest hearing continued: The November hearing lasted minutes; Alan Jackson absent due to surgery and a cast; defense plans another motion to dismiss alleging failure to disclose exculpatory evidence; prosecutor Nathan Bartos says the December 1 trial date will not happen.

•

15:01 — Nitrous oxide canister theory: Prosecutors introduced a new theory in September: a 10–12 lb nitrous oxide canister found in the car (dented, with blood) may have distracted Bohm; judge barred any suggestion he inhaled it or was impaired; such canisters are common in race cars and a BMW kit exists for Bohm's model.

•

18:05 — Hospital video and attorney absence: Defense sought to admit a 45-minute post-crash hospital video of Bohm for excited utterances; judge denied admission and ordered redactions; Julia Dang notes Jackson missed another hearing in October citing a major injury, raising questions about delay tactics.

•

21:25 — PCH Dead Man's Curve context: Julia Dang describes driving the crash site: a curving, scenic but dangerous road with 45 mph limit, frequent speeding, pedestrians, parked cars, and homes; a civil lawsuit is pending; Bohm allegedly knew the area well and that speed could kill.

Speakers

•

Chris Stewart — Host

•

Julia Dang — Correspondent

•

Alan Jackson — Defense attorney

•

Fraser Bohm — Defendant

•

Victor Calandra — Prosecution witness

•

Nathan Bartos — Prosecutor

•

Thomas Rubinson — Judge

⋮