Stephen A.'s MOST DIFFICULT A-List EVER ⁉️ Ranking the top 5️⃣ NFL teams through Week 9 | First Take

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

Stephen A. Smith unveils his Week 9 NFL top five: Bills at #1, Jaguars #2, Bears #3, 49ers #4, Broncos #5. The panel debates the order — arguing for the Lions over the Broncos and questioning the 49ers' drop — before previewing the Steelers-Bengals AFC North showdown and celebrating co-host Candy's birthday.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Jacksonville has been tied for the NFL's best record since Week 11 of 2023 yet receives minimal national attention

•

Jaylen Warren leads all Steelers in scrimmage yards through nine weeks — more than any Pittsburgh player since James Conner's 2018 season

•

The 49ers' defense held Kirk Cousins and the Falcons in check despite the offense missing multiple stars

•

Stephen A. Smith attributes his controversial 49ers ranking to jet lag from flying commercial

Key takeaways

•

Buffalo Bills ranked #1 for finding different ways to win each week behind Josh Allen

•

Jacksonville Jaguars at #2 are quietly tied for the league's best record since Week 11 last year but overlooked due to market size

•

Chicago Bears dropped from #1 to #3 after Caleb Williams threw four interceptions in a narrow win over Tampa Bay

•

San Francisco 49ers sit at #4 despite only one loss because key offensive players (Deebo Samuel, Christian McCaffrey) remain injured

•

Denver Broncos round out the top five at #5 after beating Kansas City to lead the AFC West, driven by defense and Bo Nix's late-game heroics

•

Panel consensus gives the list a B-minus; multiple analysts would place the Detroit Lions in the top five instead of Denver

•

Pittsburgh Steelers enter Sunday Night Football vs. Bengals as the AFC North's most physical team with the NFL's 4th-ranked defense

•

Jaylen Warren has emerged as the Steelers' offensive identity with the most scrimmage yards by a Steeler since James Conner in 2018

Notable quotes

“BAM. THE DENVER BRONCOS. WHY? YOU SEE THE WRECK. You see Bo Nix. You see Sean Payton. You see what they're doing. And you see that defense just stirring it up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:30

“I DAMN SURE DON'T LIKE CALEB WILLIAMS THROWING ABOUT FOUR INTERCEPTIONS. WE DON'T LIKE THAT. WE AIN'T GOING TO ACCEPT THAT.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:03

“That Jacksonville Jaguars team since week 11 of last year. They're tied for the best record in the National Football League. Trevor Lawrence is balling.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:28

“Bam. Right there. Josh Allen and the Buffalo Bills. I'm looking at the Buffalo Bills right now. Just finding ways to win football games.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:15

“We are sleeping. This is the most physical team in the AFC North. And I think people don't realize this team has found their way.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:05

“If you want to know what the 2024 Pittsburgh Steelers are all about, it's Jaylen Warren. He's a throwback.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:40

“Oh, it's for my New York Giants before the trade deadline. They got need at running back. They got need at defensive tackle. Let's go out and get Jonathan Taylor from your Colts and find a way to get Vea from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:33

Chapters

•

0:00 — A-List Top 5 Reveal: Stephen A. Smith presents his Week 9 NFL power rankings: Broncos (5), 49ers (4), Bears (3), Jaguars (2), Bills (1), explaining the rationale for each placement.

•

3:45 — Panel Debate & Grades: Co-hosts challenge the order — particularly the 49ers at #4 and Bills at #1 — advocate for the Lions in the top five, and collectively assign a B-minus grade.

•

6:47 — Steelers vs. Bengals Preview: Analysis of the AFC North showdown: Pittsburgh's elite defense and Jaylen Warren's breakout vs. Cincinnati's four-game win streak against weak opponents; Steelers' wide receiver production flagged as lone concern.

•

9:26 — Birthday Wishes & Sign Off: Candy's birthday celebrated; she wishes for the Giants to trade for Jonathan Taylor and Vita Vea before the deadline; show wraps with sign-off.

Speakers

•

Stephen A. Smith — Host

•

Jeff — Analyst

•

Candy — Analyst/Reporter

•

Other Panelists — Contributors

⋮