I Was An Air Traffic Controller | Creep Cast

Original Media · 1h 43m · English · YouTube · CreepCast

TLDR

Creepcast hosts Hunter and Harry read and discuss three classic creepy stories involving time loops and supernatural entities. The first follows a gas station employee who discovers customers repeating hourly loops on security footage, culminating in a new hire named Jeremy appearing on camera and vanishing motor oil — leading to a town-wide time freeze and an FBI cover-up tied to a 1993 arson. The second, told through a UK video doorbell forum, documents multiple users receiving 2:53 AM motion alerts with garbled footage; those who investigate outside are replaced by entities that post "It's 2:53, time to come outside." The third recounts an air traffic controller in 1970s Iowa stalked by a barefoot woman in a summer dress who appears during emergency landings, whispers to pilots who then flee, mimics speech with audio delay, and ultimately frames the narrator for assault — ending with his aunt saying the entity's catchphrase, implying replacement.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The gas station story's final twist reveals the narrator has been looping the entire day — his "final update" restarts the story from the beginning, meaning the FBI interrogation and arson revelation already happened but reset.

•

In the doorbell story, the Roost tech support's useless PDF (for a Samsung fridge) isn't incompetence — it's implied the support account is already compromised by the entity, deliberately sending wrong files.

•

The runway woman's "See you later, alligator" line seems campy until the narrator's aunt says it at the very end, retroactively making the catchphrase a marker of replacement rather than a quirk.

•

The air traffic controller's Vietnam experience — surviving combat — contrasts with his paralysis against the entity, suggesting supernatural fear operates differently than mortal danger.

•

The motor oil in story one connects to the 1993 arson (house soaked in oil, Molotov cocktail), implying Jeremy/the entity has a thematic link to accelerants and fire across decades.

•

The doorbell entity doesn't just attack — it recruits. Users who go outside at 2:53 don't disappear; they return to the forum posting the entity's message, becoming part of the lure.

Key takeaways

•

The first story uses a nested time-loop structure: customers repeat hourly, the narrator experiences a 5-hour blackout and frozen world, then the final update reveals he's restarted the same day — suggesting the loop encompasses the entire narrative.

•

In the doorbell story, the entity spreads through technology and proximity: all affected users live in the same UK council area, electrical devices glitch simultaneously at 2:53 AM, and the forum becomes a transmission vector where replaced victims recruit others.

•

The air traffic controller story establishes rules for the entity: it only appears during emergency landings, targets isolated night workers, mimics voices with a distinct audio delay, and replaces people (the security guard Jerry and possibly the narrator's aunt) after they encounter it.

•

All three stories feature ordinary workers (gas station clerk, homeowners, air traffic controller) confronting the inexplicable during mundane night shifts, emphasizing vulnerability in routine, low-stakes jobs.

•

The first and third stories end with institutional cover-ups: the FBI appears immediately after the arson connection surfaces in story one, while the police dismiss the narrator's account in story three, suggesting authorities are aware of these phenomena.

•

Each entity uses a distinct signature: Jeremy's creepy smile and motor oil theft, the doorbell entity's precise 2:53 timing and garbled audio/video, the runway woman's unblinking stare, delayed voice, and "See you later, alligator" catchphrase.

•

The doorbell story's forum format creates dramatic irony: readers see the pattern across multiple users before any single character does, and the final forum posts from replaced victims confirm the threat's scale.

•

The air traffic controller story spans decades (1979 to present), showing the entity's persistence: 41 controllers quit the same airport after the narrator leaves, implying a generational haunting tied to the location.

Notable quotes

“One second the store was empty. The next second his face was all I could see. He wasn't looking at the camera. He was looking at me.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:45

“It's like he wanted me to see what he could do, like he was showing off or something. The way he smiled into the camera, it's like a little kid showing you a sand castle they just built.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:32

“Run, run, run.”

▸ Notable quotes · 60:22

“Her voice came out with delay, just like on the camera. Her lips moved, but the words came out a few seconds later.”

▸ Notable quotes · 80:06

“See you later, alligator.”

▸ Notable quotes · 95:36

“Stories are our immortality. They're a kinder collective immortality.”

▸ Notable quotes · 54:10

Chapters

•

0:08 — Intro and Story 1 Setup: Hosts Hunter and Harry introduce the in-person recording session and three older creepy stories with a shared theme, beginning with "The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen" from 14 years ago.

•

2:52 — Story 1: Gas Station Time Loop: Narrator watches security footage of new hire Jeremy's shift; customers repeat identical actions hourly, Jeremy's face appears on camera staring at viewer, motor oil vanishes instantly, narrator experiences time freeze and blackout, FBI intervenes after discovering Jeremy's address is an empty lot from a 1993 arson.

•

18:47 — Story 1 Discussion: Hosts analyze the nested time loops, Jeremy as possible arsonist's son or entity, FBI's "another one" line implying pattern recognition, and the story's classic creepypasta structure.

•

33:30 — Story 2: Doorbell Forum: Told through Roost video doorbell forum posts: multiple UK users get 2:53 AM motion alerts with garbled footage, electrical glitches at same time, Dan King rages at support, users told to "go outside at 2:53, check camera," those who comply get replaced and post recruitment messages.

•

51:00 — Story 2 Discussion: Hosts discuss the entity's spread through technology and proximity, the "skin chap" joke, and the forum format's dramatic irony.

•

54:30 — Story 3: Air Traffic Controller Part 1: Nephew recounts uncle Alex's 1979 Iowa airport encounters: barefoot woman in summer dress appears on runway during emergency landings, whispers to pilots who flee, chases Alex, destroys control room, has unblinking eyes and delayed voice.

•

75:00 — Story 3: Air Traffic Controller Part 2: Camera installed; woman appears crying on feed, Alex lets her in, she mimics his speech with audio delay, screams from throat after mouth closes, points to cornfield, Alex tackles her, she says "See you later alligator" with delay, police arrest Alex, woman acts innocent, Jerry denies seeing her.

•

99:00 — Story 3 Conclusion and Discussion: Alex quits, moves to New York; aunt dismisses story as medication-induced delusion but says "See you later alligator" at departure, implying replacement. Hosts discuss unreliable narrator, entity's generational persistence (41 controllers quit), and author's real-life death from cancer.

Speakers

•

Hunter — Co-host / Primary narrator

•

Harry — Co-host

⋮