TLDR
Brandon Sheiley and Ally Reagan provide a commentary track for Underworld: Rise of the Lycans, reacting in real-time to the prequel's origin story of the Lycans, Lucian's forbidden romance with Viktor's daughter Sonja, and the vampire-werewolf war. They praise Michael Sheen's performance, the film's grounded storytelling, and its connections to the broader franchise.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Lucian was born a Lycan rather than turned, making him unique among his kind — a detail the hosts found compelling and underexplained.
Viktor saves Selene in the first film because she resembles his executed daughter Sonja, and Selene ultimately kills Viktor — a poetic irony the hosts only fully appreciated during this rewatch.
The film contains no female Lycans, which the hosts note makes historical sense given the Lycans were bred as male laborers and soldiers.
Michael Sheen (Lucian) also played Aro in Twilight and co-leads Good Omens — the hosts were surprised by his range as a physical leading man here.
Key takeaways
The hosts consider Rise of the Lycans their favorite of the first three Underworld films due to its focused, easy-to-follow narrative and strong character work.
Michael Sheen's portrayal of Lucian as a feral, born-not-bitten Lycan leader is highlighted as a standout performance that anchors the prequel.
The forbidden romance between Lucian and Sonja (Viktor's daughter) drives the tragedy, with Viktor ultimately executing his own pregnant daughter to preserve vampire purity.
Practical effects, swordplay, and the medieval setting are praised over the gun-heavy action of the modern-set sequels.
The film reveals Lucian was the first naturally born Lycan who could shift at will, and his blood was used to create the enslaved Lycan race.
Bill Nighy's Viktor is noted for nuanced villainy — his cruelty stems from a twisted sense of order and legacy, not mere malice.
The hosts identify a potential plot hole regarding the necklace/key timeline but acknowledge future films may bridge the gap.
The commentary format enhances viewing by providing context, production insights, and emotional reactions to key scenes.
Notable quotes
“I really love how Michael Sheen is playing this. Like he feels a little feral.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:20“It's time we left this wretched night behind. There are some difficult decisions ahead.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:14“You cannot have one without the other. ... I would have thought after all these years you would have known.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:48“I love how poetic it is that he saved her. Victor saved Selene because she reminded him of his daughter. And in the end, the one who took his life was Selene.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:51“This one was just felt more grounded I guess. Very very easy to follow, very easy to understand.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:40“The fact that we already know what's going to happen in the future, but we still enjoyed the movie is nice because sometimes when you know what's going to happen, it's like, 'Oh, is this really even fun to watch?'”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:25Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Setup: Hosts introduce the commentary for Underworld: Rise of the Lycans, mention Kate Beckinsale's absence, and promote their Patreon for uncut viewing.
1:00 — Movie Opening & Lycan Origin: Reaction to the prologue explaining Viktor's creation of the Lycan race from Lucian, the first born Lycan who could control his transformation.
7:20 — Lucian & Sonja's Romance: Commentary on the forbidden relationship between Lucian and Viktor's daughter Sonja, including Lucian's key-making and escape plans.
14:30 — Viktor's Cruelty & Lucian's Punishment: Viktor orders 30 lashes for Lucian despite him saving Sonja, revealing Viktor's rigid adherence to law over loyalty.
18:50 — Nobles Arrive & Lycan Uprising Begins: Human nobles demand protection; Lucian rallies Lycans to rebel, leading to a mass escape from the vampire stronghold.
35:30 — Sonja's Pregnancy & Execution: Viktor discovers Sonja's pregnancy with Lucian's child and executes her by sunlight, triggering Lucian's full vengeance.
43:00 — Final Battle & Viktor's Survival: Lucian storms the castle, fights Viktor, but fails to kill him — Viktor escapes into water, setting up future conflict.
47:15 — Post-Movie Discussion & Review: Hosts compare this film to predecessors, praise performances, discuss plot connections, and speculate on remaining franchise entries.
Speakers
Brandon Sheiley — Co-host
Ally Reagan — Co-host