Why You Don’t Actually Want to Lose Weight...

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · StarTalk

TLDR

Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice explain the fundamental difference between mass and weight. Mass is the total amount of matter in an object (sum of all molecules), which stays constant regardless of location. Weight is the force of gravity acting on that mass, which changes depending on where you are — on the Moon you weigh 1/6th, on a mountain slightly less, in orbit zero, and in a spinning space station you can weigh double. They cover measurement tools (spring scales measure weight, balances measure mass), the obscure imperial mass unit 'slugs' (32.2 lbs), and note that Earth's mass is about 6 septillion kilograms while its weight depends on what it's attracted to. The distinction matters for future interplanetary commerce. The episode ends with a joke comparing Catholic mass to Black church services. The hosts are Neil deGrasse Tyson (astrophysicist, StarTalk host) and Chuck Nice (comedian, co-host).

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The imperial unit of mass is called a 'slug' and equals about 32.2 pounds, a unit so obscure that even scientists have abandoned it.

•

If you stood on a scale in a free-falling elevator, the scale would read zero because both you and the scale are accelerating downward at the same rate — you are not squeezing the spring at all.

•

Earth does not have a single 'weight'; its weight is only defined relative to another object's gravity, so asking 'what is the weight of Earth?' is a category error.

•

A balance scale would give the same reading on the Moon as on Earth because both the test mass and the standard masses are pulled by the Moon's weaker gravity in the same proportion.

•

In metric countries, people routinely say an object 'weighs' 70 kilograms, but kilograms measure mass, not weight — the correct weight unit is newtons.

Key takeaways

•

Mass is the invariant quantity of matter in your body — the sum of all molecules and their energy equivalence — and does not change whether you are on Earth, the Moon, or in deep space.

•

Weight is the force of gravity pulling on your mass, so it varies with location: you weigh 1/6th on the Moon, slightly less on a mountaintop, nothing in free-fall orbit, and twice as much in a space station spinning at 2g.

•

A spring scale measures weight because it reads how hard gravity squeezes the spring; a balance measures mass because it compares an unknown mass to known standard masses, which works identically on any world.

•

The imperial system's unit of mass is the slug (about 32.2 pounds), which is so rarely used that even scientists have abandoned it, while the metric system uses kilograms for mass and newtons for weight.

•

Earth's mass is approximately 6 septillion kilograms (6 × 10²⁴ kg), but its weight is not a single number — weight only exists as a mutual gravitational attraction between Earth and another object.

•

In everyday language, especially in metric-using countries, people conflate mass and weight by saying something 'weighs' 70 kilograms, but kilograms are strictly a unit of mass.

•

The distinction between mass and weight will become legally and commercially important when interplanetary trade begins, because shipping costs will depend on mass (fuel to accelerate) while planetary surfaces will measure weight (force on a scale).

•

Being overweight in orbit is less stressful on the heart and joints than on Earth because weightlessness removes the mechanical load, though cardiovascular health risks from fat remain.

Notable quotes

“It's not weight that you want to lose. It's mass.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:29

“I can make you lose weight by just sending you to the moon. And then you weigh 16th what you weigh here. You weigh 30 something pounds on the moon.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:35

“If you stand on a scale that has a spring, they all have springs, even if you can't see it. Okay? That spring is measuring how much your weight is squeezing it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:06

“A scale with a spring in it measures weight whereas a balance measures mass.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:32

“What is the weight of Earth? ... Its weight is just whatever is the gravitational attraction between it and something else.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:06

“That's how much you weigh on Earth. That's how much Earth weighs on you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:32

Chapters

•

0:00 — Mass vs weight introduction: Chuck and Neil open with banter about weight loss, then Neil clarifies that people want to lose mass, not weight, because weight changes with gravity while mass is constant.

•

0:16 — How weight changes with location: Neil explains weight varies by location: 1/6th on the Moon, slightly less on a mountain, zero in orbit, and double in a 2g rotating space station.

•

1:02 — Defining mass and energy equivalence: Mass is the sum of all molecules in your body; molecular motion adds a tiny energy-equivalent mass per E=mc², but it's negligible.

•

6:06 — Measurement tools: spring scales vs balances: Spring scales measure weight (force on a spring); balances measure mass by comparing against standard masses, which works the same on any world.

•

4:11 — Imperial and metric units: The imperial mass unit is the slug (~32.2 lbs), now abandoned; metric uses kilograms for mass and newtons for weight, though people colloquially confuse them.

•

8:04 — Earth's mass and weight: Earth's mass is ~6 septillion kg; its weight is not a fixed number but depends on gravitational attraction to another body — Earth weighs on you exactly as much as you weigh on Earth.

•

7:41 — Interplanetary commerce and closing jokes: The mass/weight distinction will matter for space trade; episode ends with jokes about Catholic mass vs Black church services and 'keep looking up.'

Speakers

•

Neil deGrasse Tyson — Host / Astrophysicist

•

Chuck Nice — Co-host / Comedian

⋮