TLDR
Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil recounts his life as a stateless refugee from Syria, his graduate studies at Columbia, and his arrest by ICE despite being a lawful permanent resident with a green card. He spent 104 days in detention after organizing campus protests for Palestine, and his case — now headed to the Supreme Court — tests whether the government can weaponize immigration law to punish First Amendment activity.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
ICE officers who arrested Khalil did not know the difference between a student visa and a green card, and one called a supervisor who said "bring him anyway" after learning he was a lawful permanent resident.
The White House requested updates on Khalil's booking within hours of his arrest, indicating direct political involvement in a supposedly routine immigration enforcement action.
A detainee who had lived in the U.S. since 2002, paid taxes, supervised 30 employees, had two citizen daughters (one in federal law enforcement) and a permanent resident wife was denied bond for "lack of connections to the community."
The Trump administration argues immigration judges — who are appointed by and can be fired by the Attorney General — are the proper venue for First Amendment challenges, effectively placing speech rights under executive control.
Khalil wore masks protesting Assad in Syria because he feared disappearance, but protested openly in the U.S. believing constitutional protections applied — only to be detained by the same tactics he fled.
Key takeaways
Mahmoud Khalil's family were expelled from Palestine in the 1948 Nakba and lived as stateless refugees in Syria for generations, denied citizenship and basic rights despite being born there.
He came to the U.S. on a scholarship, earned a green card, and was arrested by Homeland Security Investigations at his apartment building while his wife was eight months pregnant — officers initially claimed his student visa was revoked, then said "bring him anyway" when he showed his green card.
During 104 days in ICE detention, he met fathers separated from children, a DACA recipient deported overnight without seeing a lawyer, and a man who had lived in the U.S. since 2002 with two citizen daughters denied bond for "lack of community ties."
The Trump administration's removal determination explicitly states his "otherwise lawful" activities and associations are a threat to U.S. foreign policy — Marco Rubio confirmed the arrest was intended as a "blueprint" to deter pro-Palestine speech.
Columbia University created an Office of Institutional Equity that targeted pro-Palestine protesters, and Khalil emailed the president begging for help the day before his arrest; the university laid groundwork for his targeting.
A federal judge ordered his release, ruling the removal determination likely unconstitutional, but the government appealed and the Third Circuit reversed — the case now goes to the Supreme Court on whether federal courts can intervene in immigration cases involving First Amendment claims.
Khalil emphasizes that Palestinians face violence across borders: unsafe in Palestine, Syria, Lebanon, and now the U.S. — the book title "No Land to Stand On" reflects this transnational erasure.
He argues rights are won through collective struggle, not courts alone, citing civil rights movements; he seeks accountability through public awareness and political organizing, not just litigation.
Notable quotes
“Even they were incompetent and they were very incompetent. That's I think that's the most dangerous thing about this administration.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:15“The Palestine exception, the fact that the um freedom of speech, um rule of law, basic dignities are not extended to Palestine. You know, it's freedom of speech except for Palestine. Rule of law except for Palestine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:04“In Syria I used to wear masks when I would protest against Assad's regime because I knew it's a brutal regime that if they knew I was protesting they would come and kill me they would come and disappear me. That's why like I always wore mask. But here I didn't feel the need to.”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:07“The White House said my arrest is a blueprint for the administration to go after anyone who protests for Palestine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:30“Cruelty is the point of government. A lot of these practices were happening under Biden by the way like it's not just that Trump is is doing this but he's doing he's doing it in a way that's so vicious that's so horrendous to just to be cruel you know like that's the point.”
▸ Notable quotes · 43:57“All the rights that we have right now did not came because the Supreme Court woke up in the morning and decided to do it to do the right thing or the Congress woke up in the morning to do the right thing. It came as a result of people fighting for them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:35Chapters
1:13 — Palestinian refugee origins and statelessness: Khalil explains his grandparents were expelled in the 1948 Nakba, walked to Syria expecting to return, and lived in tents then mud houses. Palestinians in Syria are denied citizenship, travel documents, and basic rights — a condition shared across host countries.
4:12 — Childhood in Yarmouk camp and path to Columbia: He describes growing up in a refugee camp with unpaved streets until 2007, limited electricity and internet, UNRWA schools, and his family's emphasis on education as their only capital. He attended aviation school but fled to Lebanon when war broke out, then worked with Syrian refugees before winning a scholarship to Columbia SIPA.
10:24 — October 7th, campus protests, and Columbia's response: Khalil organized protests five days after October 7th, citing 2,000+ Palestinians killed and explicit genocidal rhetoric from Israeli officials. He details Columbia's Office of Institutional Equity targeting pro-Palestine students, the board of trustees' ideological commitment to Israel over academic freedom, and the media's role in manufacturing consent.
29:38 — Arrest by HSI/ICE despite green card status: On March 8, plainclothes HSI officers arrested Khalil at his apartment building while his wife was eight months pregnant. They claimed his student visa was revoked; when he showed his green card, a supervisor said "bring him anyway." They refused to show a warrant, hung up on his lawyer, and took him to Federal Plaza.
37:58 — 104 days in ICE detention and witnessing systemic cruelty: Khalil describes overcrowded cells, lights on 24/7, thin blankets, and meeting detainees including a DACA recipient deported overnight, a 20-year resident denied bond despite citizen daughters, a father of four with a wife in chemotherapy, and a single father who asked ICE to detain his 11-year-old son. Conditions are deliberately harsh to coerce deportation signatures.
45:00 — Legal battle, Supreme Court, and the Palestine exception: ACLU, CLEAR, and CCR represented him; a judge ordered release calling the removal determination likely unconstitutional. The government appealed; the Third Circuit reversed. The case now goes to the Supreme Court on whether federal courts can review immigration cases involving First Amendment claims. Rubio's determination explicitly targets "otherwise lawful" speech.
52:10 — No land to stand on: transnational Palestinian erasure: Khalil reflects on Palestinians being unsafe in Palestine, Syria, Lebanon, and now the U.S. The book title captures this reality. He argues every American is complicit through tax dollars funding Israel and political shielding from accountability, and that rights are won through collective struggle, not courts alone.
Speakers
Jen — Host
Mahmoud Khalil — Guest