TLDR
This PBS NewsHour segment investigates how companies use algorithms and personal data to charge different prices to different customers for the same products. Experiments reveal widespread personalized pricing on platforms like Instacart and Uber Eats, while patents show retailers like Walmart developing technology to track biometric data. Consumer advocates argue this erodes fairness norms, though public backlash has forced some companies like Wendy's to retreat from dynamic pricing plans.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Walmart holds patents for technology that could monitor a shopper's heart rate and blood sugar via wearable devices in the ice cream aisle to gauge physiological responses to specific products.
Uber Eats charged different delivery fees for the exact same meal ordered simultaneously to the same address, with no transparent explanation for the variation.
Target's app changes prices as a customer physically approaches the store, increasing prices when the system detects the shopper is in the parking lot and committed to purchasing.
McDonald's tracks what percentage of franchisees adopt its algorithmic pricing recommendations, effectively measuring compliance with centralized pricing guidance.
Key takeaways
An Instacart experiment found 75% of items were offered at different prices to different shoppers at the same store and time, with price differences up to 23%, prompting Instacart to halt the test after public scrutiny.
Companies now use algorithms that incorporate location data, IP addresses, purchase history, loyalty card data, and demographic profiles to estimate each shopper's willingness to pay and adjust prices accordingly.
Walmart has patented technology that could connect to wearable devices like Apple Watches to monitor heart rate and blood sugar, potentially using physiological responses to influence pricing decisions in real time.
Digital price tags being rolled out across Walmart U.S. stores could enable instantaneous price changes, though Walmart states it will not use individual customer data to set personalized prices.
A test by the reporting team ordering identical Uber Eats meals to the same address at the same time revealed delivery fees varying from $2.49 to $4.49, while the meal price remained constant at $13.59.
Expedia was found charging higher prices for the same Manhattan hotel room to users logging in from the affluent San Francisco Bay Area compared to users from less affluent regions.
McDonald's pushes algorithmic pricing recommendations to franchisees and tracks adoption rates, while Wendy's faced swift consumer backlash after announcing plans for dynamic pricing based on time of day, weather, and traffic.
Research by Nobel laureate Richard Thaler shows 80% of Americans consider it unfair when a hardware store raises snow shovel prices after a blizzard, a fairness norm that has persisted for 40 years.
Consumers can sometimes get better prices by comparing across platforms (app vs. website vs. in-store), using a VPN to change apparent location, or deliberately not logging into loyalty programs so the company cannot identify them as a 'sure thing.'
Lindsay Owens proposes policy solutions including a ban on using shopper data to set individualized prices, arguing that prices used to be tethered to production costs plus a fair margin rather than maximum extractable value.
Notable quotes
“AGE OLD IMPULSES TO NICKEL AND DIME YOU OR SQUEEZE YOU OR TURN A PROFIT HAVE BEEN SUPERCHARGED BY NEW TECHNOLOGIES.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:25“WE FOUND EVIDENCE OF WALMART CREATING THE TECHNOLOGY THAT CAN CONNECT TO YOUR APPLE WATCH OR OTHER WEARABLE DEVICE AND LOOK AT THINGS LIKE YOUR HEART RATE, YOUR BLOOD SUGAR.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:19“PRICES IN THIS COUNTRY USED TO BE MORE TETHERED TO THINGS LIKE THE UNDERLYING COST OF MAKING THE GOOD. ADD A FAIR MARGIN ON TOP, PUT A STICKER ON IT.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:19“IT'S VIRTUALLY COSTLESS TO CHANGE PRICING ON THE ELECTRONIC MENU BOARDS. ALL SORTS OF INPUTS COULD GO INTO THAT. WEATHER, LOCAL INCOME, TRAFFIC.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:26“AS YOU MIGHT GUESS, MOST PEOPLE, LIKE 80% OF PEOPLE, SAY NO, THAT'S NOT FAIR.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:31“THE COMPANY KNOWS SO MUCH ABOUT YOUR HABITS AND PURCHASE HISTORY THAT THEY KNOW MAYBE YOU'RE A SURE THING.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:38Chapters
0:03 — Introduction to Algorithmic Pricing: The segment opens with the premise that companies have always sought to maximize profits but now possess sophisticated algorithmic tools to adjust prices dynamically, drawing greater scrutiny amid consumer frustration with rising costs.
0:26 — Instacart Personalized Pricing Experiment: A controlled experiment with 400 shoppers on Instacart revealed 75% of items had different prices for different customers at the same store and time, with variations up to 23%, leading Instacart to halt the test after public exposure.
1:43 — Data Collection and Personalized Pricing Mechanics: Lindsay Owens explains how companies gather location data, IP addresses, purchase history, loyalty card information, and demographic profiles to algorithmically estimate each shopper's maximum willingness to pay.
2:00 — Walmart Patents and Digital Price Tags: Research into 315 Walmart patents uncovered technology to connect with wearable devices and monitor biometric data like heart rate and blood sugar; Walmart plans digital price tags in all U.S. stores but pledges not to use individual data for personalized pricing.
3:18 — Uber Eats and Other Real-World Examples: The reporting team's own Uber Eats test showed identical meals with delivery fees varying from $2.49 to $4.49; Expedia charged more to users from affluent areas, and Target's app raises prices as shoppers approach the store.
5:49 — Fast Food Algorithmic Pricing: McDonald's pushes algorithmic pricing recommendations to franchisees and tracks adoption rates, while Wendy's announced dynamic pricing plans based on time, weather, and traffic but retreated after intense consumer backlash.
7:06 — Consumer Fairness Norms and Behavioral Economics: Research by Richard Thaler shows 80% of Americans consider surge pricing unfair, a norm stable for 40 years; Thaler argues firms face reputational costs when caught violating fairness expectations, though whether this deters them remains an empirical question.
8:08 — Consumer Tactics and Policy Proposals: Owens advises consumers to compare prices across platforms, use VPNs, and avoid loyalty logins; she proposes policy bans on using shopper data to set prices, arguing pricing should return to cost-plus-margin models.
Speakers
AMNA — Host/Narrator
PAUL — Reporter
LINDSAY OWENS — Expert/Author
LIZ — Researcher