TLDR
This Rotten Mango episode examines the case against singer David Anthony Burke, arrested for the murder and dismemberment of 14-year-old Celeste Riveras Hernandez. The host analyzes potential accomplices in David's inner circle — including Neil Langston, manager Josh Marshall, tour manager Robert Morgan Roth, and friend Asia Collins — based on private investigator Steve Fisher's findings, grand jury testimony, and internet theories. The episode also covers the massive evidence trove (40-50 terabytes), defense attorney Blair Berk's controversial history, the preliminary hearing process, and reactions from both families.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The coroner's report was sealed specifically to prevent witnesses from tailoring testimony to match the cause of death details.
In California state court, a defendant can request a preliminary hearing even after a grand jury indictment — which David's team did, then repeatedly delayed.
Blair Berk gave the prosecution a 1 TB hard drive for 50 TB of evidence, then a 5 TB drive for 8 TB of iCloud data, prompting the DA to note evidence cannot be split across drives.
David transferred two Houston houses to a trust under his mother's name within 10 days of the body's discovery in September 2024.
The defense may argue Celeste overdosed, but further toxicology testing ruled out drugs; only low ethanol from decomposition was found.
Key takeaways
David Burke was arrested for the murder of 14-year-old Celeste Riveras Hernandez, whose dismembered body was found in his Tesla's front trunk.
Private investigator Steve Fisher alleges David had contact with at least two other minors besides Celeste and claims David was rarely alone during the murder window (April 23-25, 2024).
Neil Langston was arrested in Montana for failing to appear before the grand jury, testified for only 40 minutes, and made suspicious social media posts about being 'legally fine' and having 'receipts.'
Managers Josh Marshall (who rented the Hollywood Hills house) and Robert Morgan Roth (who testified for 3 days) are under scrutiny for possible knowledge of Celeste's presence and age.
The prosecution has 40-50 terabytes of evidence including wiretaps, CSAM on David's iPhone, and forensic data; the coroner's report is sealed to prevent witness coaching.
Defense attorney Blair Berk previously represented Harvey Weinstein and made controversial statements minimizing sexual misconduct; she appears less prepared than Deputy DA Beth Silverman.
David's brother Caleb (Caracova) released music days before the arrest, denied knowledge of Celeste's age, and condemned 'rapists' on Instagram, drawing mixed reactions.
Celeste's family denies receiving money from David and expresses devastation; the DA pledges to pursue proof beyond reasonable doubt for her killing.
Notable quotes
“I think he had help. I think there's going to be other people that go down.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:01“Based on the timeline, I do not believe David was alone for more than brief periods between April 23rd and April 25th.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:09“She's very pushy on why I didn't call the police. I said I feel like I didn't have the responsibility to do that and just wanted to continue with the tour.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:54“Just because you're a woman and make a claim on Instagram doesn't make you a victim.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:58“You are not the victim here. Your actions 20 years ago took away another person's voice and choice.”
▸ Notable quotes · 67:56“All files and rapists should die, period.”
▸ Notable quotes · 103:38Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Case Overview: Host introduces the case: David Burke arrested for murder of 14-year-old Celeste Riveras Hernandez; songs released by his brother Caleb (Caracova) around arrest time; overview of potential accomplices and legal updates.
4:17 — Private Investigator Steve Fisher's Findings: PI Steve Fisher hired by Hollywood Hills homeowner; found burn cage and chainsaw in garage; alleges David contacted at least two other minors; claims David was rarely alone during murder window; suggests accomplices likely involved.
14:22 — Neil Langston: Grand Jury Testimony and Behavior: Neil Langston arrested in Montana for failing to appear; testified 40 minutes vs manager's 3 days; conflicting reports on pleading fifth; suspicious social media posts about being 'legally fine' and having 'receipts'; PI speculates immunity deal.
37:00 — Managers Josh Marshall and Robert Morgan Roth: Josh Marshall rented house, denied receiving email about missing Celeste; Celeste seen at Fonda Theatre VIP with Marshall, David's parents, and Caleb. Robert Morgan Roth testified 3 days; allegedly told attorney he felt no responsibility to call police and wanted to continue tour.
48:00 — Asia Collins and 'Decoy' Celeste: Asia Collins, close friend, present during 4th of July stream; DMs suggest she learned Celeste was 13 and missing; denied knowledge publicly; faced backlash for calling victim 'the girl' and performative statements; PI says older Celeste was friend of Asia, not close to David.
61:00 — Legal Proceedings: Evidence, Attorneys, and Judge: 40-50 TB of evidence including wiretaps and CSAM; Blair Berk (defense) vs Beth Silverman (DA); Judge Charlene Olmedo (presided over Danny Masterson trial) denies sealing prosecution brief; preliminary hearing set for late June; defense requests discovery, delays hearing.
101:00 — David's Family and Brother Caleb: Parents fought grand jury subpoenas; transferred houses to trust after body found; publicly support David. Brother Caleb (18) released music as Caracova, denied knowing Celeste's age, condemned rapists, unfollowed David; mixed public reaction to his timing and statements.
112:00 — Celeste's Family and Case Outlook: Family denies receiving money; attorney describes gruesome details from medical examiner; family devastated, seeks privacy and justice. DA pledges proof beyond reasonable doubt. Death penalty possible; David in segregated jail; preliminary hearing expected to reveal more.
Speakers
Host — Podcast host
Co-host — Co-host/commentator