TLDR
In 2015, 28-year-old Heather Bogle was brutally murdered in Ohio. Detective Shawn O'Connell botched the investigation by fixating on three innocent people — Keona Bor, Omar Satchel, and Kayry Jeffries — despite DNA excluding them, while ignoring a coworker's tip about Heather's colleague Daniel Myers. O'Connell omitted exculpatory DNA evidence from a prosecutor's report, harassed Keona Bor (causing her to lose her job and housing), and had a personal vendetta against her. The corrupt sheriff, Kyle Overmyer, was later indicted on 43 charges. A new sheriff, Chris Hilton, subpoenaed Google GPS data (which O'Connell never did), placing Heather at Myers' trailer the night she died. Myers' DNA matched the foreign DNA under Heather's cuticle; his trailer showed replaced subflooring and a safe with women's underwear and violent sexual tapes. Myers had a history of violence against women (10 rape allegations) and a suspicious prior girlfriend's death. He pleaded guilty to life without parole; O'Connell was sentenced to two years for tampering with evidence. Heather's daughter survives, supported by family.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The detective who botched the investigation actively omitted DNA evidence that cleared three innocent people from a prosecutor's report — an illegal act — and continued pursuing them despite knowing they were excluded.
The overseeing sheriff was himself deeply corrupt (43 criminal charges for stealing opiates) and remained on the ballot for re-election while under indictment.
The killer, Daniel Myers, donated $125 to Heather's GoFundMe with a heartfelt note and attended her funeral after murdering her.
Myers fixed his own broken tooth with super glue after the murder.
A coworker emailed O'Connell days after the murder explicitly naming a dangerous coworker (Myers), but O'Connell never followed up or interviewed anyone from Heather's workplace.
The precise GPS data that solved the case was available via Google all along, but O'Connell only obtained vague cell tower pings (6-mile radius) and never subpoenaed the Google location history.
Key takeaways
Detective Shawn O'Connell fixated on Keona Bor, Omar Satchel, and Kayry Jeffries as suspects despite zero evidence linking them to Heather Bogle and DNA results that excluded all three, while ignoring a coworker's emailed tip days after the murder identifying Daniel Myers as a dangerous man capable of such violence.
O'Connell committed illegal acts: he omitted the exculpatory DNA results from a report to a prosecutor, conducted three search warrants at Keona Bor's home and a friend's place (throwing belongings into a dumpster), threatened to have her children taken by CPS, and obtained her DNA via armed officers at her workplace — causing her to lose her job and housing.
Sheriff Kyle Overmyer, O'Connell's superior, was simultaneously stealing opiates from police lock boxes and was later indicted on 43 criminal charges; he ran for re-election while under indictment but lost to Chris Hilton, who restarted the investigation.
New investigators subpoenaed Google GPS data from Heather's phone — a step O'Connell never took despite having a warrant for cell tower data — and pinpointed her location to Daniel Myers' trailer at Emerald Estates Trailer Park on the night of her murder.
Daniel Myers was Heather's coworker at Whirlpool with a known reputation as a creep; a mutual coworker emailed O'Connell days after the murder warning about him, but O'Connell never responded or interviewed any coworkers.
Myers' DNA matched the foreign DNA under Heather's cuticle; a search of his trailer revealed replaced subflooring (likely covering bullet holes and blood) and a safe containing women's underwear and tapes of violent sexual acts.
Myers had a documented history of violence against women: after his arrest, 10 women came forward alleging rape, and his daughter described disturbing behavior including a fixation on nails and hair (ripping off a woman's fingernails for not wearing polish, refusing to speak to his daughter after she cut her hair). A previous girlfriend, Lee Ann Slutter, died from a gunshot wound ruled suicide but with suspicious circumstances (rifle used, gun placed neatly beside her).
O'Connell was charged with multiple felonies including tampering with evidence, pleaded guilty to one felony count, and received a two-year prison sentence (which Kendall Rae considers too lenient). Myers accepted a plea deal for life without parole to avoid the death penalty.
Notable quotes
“I guess it's a little odd that, you know, you guys are I know it's a cold case. You guys are just, you know, grasping at straws trying to figure it out.”
▸ Notable quotes · 29:20“Heather, you were such an amazing person. Although we have only known each other for such a short time, I have come to appreciate our talks about our kids. I am distraught that there will be no more of your smiles at work. You will always be in my thoughts. Your daughter will always be in my prayers. God bless you, little Missy.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:52“I hope she haunts you for the rest of your days. At least we can go on with our broken lives knowing that you'll never be free. It makes me sick to know you even had the nerve to come to Heather's funeral and show absolutely no remorse for what you did.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:15“And by the way, I don't know if you have any suspects, but I know someone who works at Whirlpool that is very capable of doing that to a woman.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:38“He literally had no evidence that they even knew each other. This is just completely going off a whim here based on not much.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:44“The only apology he gave was to Heather's family. Although I'm not sure how sincere that could have been if he doesn't think he did anything wrong.”
▸ Notable quotes · 38:15Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Sponsor: Kendall Rae introduces the episode, thanks sponsor BetterHelp, and previews the case of Heather Bogle, emphasizing frustration with a detective who botched the investigation.
3:56 — Heather Bogle's Background: Heather, a 28-year-old single mom and Whirlpool worker studying nursing, faced a rough patch in April 2015: failing her LPN exam, receiving cruel texts from her brother, and a toxic breakup with her girlfriend Carmela.
6:58 — Disappearance & Body Discovery: Heather vanished after her overnight shift on April 9, 2015; her beaten body was found the next night in her car trunk at an apartment complex, with two gunshot wounds, hair sawed off, nails cut to cuticles, and foreign DNA under one cuticle.
8:52 — Detective O'Connell's Flawed Investigation: Detective Shawn O'Connell focused on Keona Bor, Omar Satchel, and Kayry Jeffries based on a search dog alert, a vague Facebook post, a Mickey Mouse shirt, and an Instagram photo of a white SUV — ignoring DNA exclusions and a coworker's tip about Daniel Myers.
19:35 — Harassment of Keona Bor & Sheriff Corruption: O'Connell harassed Keona Bor (search warrants, threats to take her kids, armed DNA collection at her job), causing her to lose housing and employment; Sheriff Kyle Overmyer was later indicted on 43 charges for stealing opiates.
25:00 — New Sheriff & GPS Breakthrough: Sheriff Chris Hilton took over, subpoenaed Google GPS data from Heather's phone (which O'Connell never did), and traced her to Daniel Myers' trailer at Emerald Estates Trailer Park on the night of the murder.
29:00 — Daniel Myers Arrest & Evidence: Myers, a coworker with a creep reputation, refused DNA; a warrant confirmed his DNA matched the foreign DNA under Heather's cuticle. His trailer showed replaced subflooring and a safe with women's underwear and violent sexual tapes.
37:10 — Myers' History, O'Connell's Conviction & Resolution: Ten women alleged rape by Myers; his daughter described disturbing nail/hair fixation. A prior girlfriend's death was suspiciously ruled suicide. O'Connell pleaded guilty to tampering with evidence (2 years); Myers took life without parole. Heather's daughter is supported by family.
Speakers
Kendall Rae — Host