TLDR
Emily D. Baker covers two major legal stories: Tom Girardi's denied motion for a new trial ahead of his December 20th sentencing for wire fraud, and Drake's pre-litigation petitions against UMG, Spotify, and iHeartRadio alleging racketeering, payola, and bot-driven streaming manipulation to artificially inflate Kendrick Lamar's diss track 'Not Like Us.' Drake's filings may have backfired, driving a 20% streaming increase and 440% sales spike for the song.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Drake's legal filings caused 'Not Like Us' to gain 14 million streams in a single day (Nov 25) and pushed it toward 1 billion streams faster — the lawsuits may have become the song's biggest marketing campaign.
Girardi retrieved a specific sweater from dirty laundry for expert visits, demonstrating intact memory formation while claiming severe impairment.
UMG allegedly 'whitelisted' 'Not Like Us' on YouTube and Twitch for the first time in company history, removing copyright restrictions to incentivize influencer promotion.
The Texas petition was filed in Travis County (iHeartMedia's HQ) rather than California (UMG's HQ), suggesting forum shopping to avoid California's anti-SLAPP laws.
Drake is effectively suing his own label (UMG) while still under contract, alleging they deliberately harmed his business to boost a rival artist's diss track.
Key takeaways
A federal judge denied Tom Girardi's motion for a new trial, finding he exaggerated cognitive impairment and was partially malingering to avoid prosecution; sentencing is set for December 20, 2024.
The court's 52-page competency order detailed how Girardi feigned memory loss selectively — forgetting charges against him but recalling them when presented as hypotheticals, and claiming not to know his wife Erika Jayne until she called him.
Drake filed pre-action discovery petitions in New York (against UMG and Spotify) and Texas (against UMG and iHeartRadio) seeking depositions and document preservation before filing lawsuits.
Drake alleges UMG engaged in a RICO-violating scheme: paying bots to inflate streams, securing discounted Spotify licensing rates for playlist placement, payola payments to radio stations and influencers, and manipulating Siri to play 'Not Like Us' when users requested Drake's album.
The New York petition cites UMG's 2006 $12M payola settlement with NY AG Eliot Spitzer as precedent; the Texas petition focuses on iHeartMedia's role in radio airplay manipulation.
Drake's company Frozen Moments LLC claims economic harm from UMG saturating the market with 'Not Like Us' at the expense of Drake's own catalog, which Frozen Moments owns.
Legal experts note defamation claims based on rap lyrics face high barriers due to artistic expression protections, hyperbole, and the context of ongoing 'rap beef' between the artists.
Since the filings, 'Not Like Us' streams surged 20% and sales jumped 440% — a Streisand effect where legal action amplified the song's reach.
Notable quotes
“the court concludes now as it did in the competency order that defendant is exaggerating symptoms of a mild cognitive impairment in order to support his council's claim that he is incompetent to stand trial”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:26“I don't want to persuade them to believe me I want them to believe me”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:17“streams for not like us sees a 20% increase in streams and a 440 per increase in sales”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:00“umg charge Spotify licensing rates 30% lower than its usual licensing rates for not like us in exchange for Spotify affirmatively recommending the song to users who are searching for other unrelated songs and artists”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:36“this practice also known as Peola is prohibited by the communications Act of 1934”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:10“lyrics in a song Especially lyrics and rap songs have come up quite a lot in courts not just in civil courts but in Criminal Courts about how much the lyrics can be relied upon”
▸ Notable quotes · 57:04Chapters
3:50 — Tom Girardi Motion for New Trial Denied: Federal judge denies Girardi's motion for new trial and judgment of acquittal, affirming he was competent to stand trial. The court's order details evidence of malingering: selective memory loss, feigning not knowing his wife Erika Jayne until she called, and coherent trial testimony. Sentencing set for December 20, 2024.
21:53 — Drake Files Pre-Litigation Petitions Against UMG, Spotify, iHeartRadio: Drake's company Frozen Moments LLC files two pre-action petitions: in New York (document preservation/discovery against UMG and Spotify) and Texas (Rule 202 depositions against UMG and iHeartMedia). Both allege a coordinated scheme to artificially inflate 'Not Like Us' through bots, payola, discounted licensing, and Siri manipulation.
24:31 — New York Petition: RICO, Payola, and Bot Allegations: Details UMG's alleged 30% discounted Spotify licensing rate for playlist placement, bot-driven stream inflation (30M streams in first days), $2,500 Zelle payments to a whistleblower, payola to radio stations and influencers, and Siri misdirection. Cites UMG's 2006 $12M payola settlement. Seeks pre-action discovery for civil RICO and NY deceptive practices claims.
52:41 — Texas Petition: iHeartMedia Depositions and Radio Payola: Seeks depositions from iHeartMedia and UMG corporate representatives. Alleges UMG-iHeart symbiotic relationship, payola scheme for radio airplay (40M additional plays after video release), and defamation-adjacent harm from lyrics calling Drake a 'certified pedophile.' Notes UMG could have blocked release but chose to amplify.
57:00 — Legal Analysis: Defamation in Rap Lyrics and Streisand Effect: Emily explains why defamation claims based on diss track lyrics face high hurdles: artistic context, hyperbole, rap beef history, and First Amendment protections. Notes the filings triggered a 20% streaming increase and 440% sales spike for 'Not Like Us' — the Streisand effect in real time.
Speakers
Emily D. Baker — Host / Legal Analyst