TLDR
The Supreme Court heard oral argument in a case challenging Colorado's Universal Preschool Program (UPK), which requires participating preschools to comply with equal opportunity requirements that prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. Catholic preschools seek to participate but require families to affirm a statement of community beliefs consistent with Catholic teachings on marriage and sexuality. The central dispute is whether Carson v. Makin (2022) extends strict scrutiny to facially neutral public benefits programs that burden religious exercise, or whether Employment Division v. Smith (1990) applies, allowing generally applicable laws to stand. Petitioners argue Colorado's program is not generally applicable due to numerous exemptions and that Carson requires strict scrutiny whenever a public benefit is conditioned on forgoing religious exercise. Colorado argues UPK is neutral, generally applicable, and welcomes religious providers, with no evidence of animus. The United States supports petitioners, arguing Smith preserved Sherbert/Thomas strict scrutiny for public benefits. Justices probed the limits of each framework, the practical impact on families, and implications for anti-discrimination law.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The federal government and 40 states already apply strict scrutiny to public benefits cases under RFRA or state equivalents, and the Solicitor General argued this has not led to widespread exemptions from anti-discrimination laws.
Colorado's catch-all exemption was initially just an online form with no restrictions; new regulations restricting it were introduced only on the second day of trial, which petitioners argue shows the state manipulating the program to appear generally applicable.
The Catholic preschools have operated for decades without a single complaint of exclusion based on LGBTQ status, and there are currently two UPK preschools within three miles of every Catholic preschool in the archdiocese.
Maine changed its tuition program after Carson to impose nondiscrimination requirements that achieve the same exclusion of religious schools without using religious terminology, which petitioners cite as evidence that Carson's rule is easily circumvented.
The Solicitor General argued that Bob Jones University v. United States (1983) actually applied strict scrutiny and the government won — showing strict scrutiny is not 'strict in theory, fatal in fact' for the government in race discrimination cases.
Key takeaways
Petitioners argue Carson v. Makin established that public benefits programs trigger strict scrutiny when they force religious entities to choose between receiving a generally available benefit and engaging in sincere religious exercise, regardless of whether the law explicitly mentions religion.
Colorado's UPK program contains a catch-all exemption allowing over 1,000 preschools to limit enrollment for various secular reasons (e.g., specific competencies, communities), which petitioners argue makes the program not 'generally applicable' under Smith.
The Catholic preschools at issue require all families to affirm a 'statement of community beliefs' in good faith; testimony indicated this is not a categorical ban on children of same-sex couples but a case-by-case determination, and no family has actually been turned away under UPK.
Colorado argues UPK was designed to welcome religious providers (many participate) and that the equal opportunity requirement applies uniformly to all schools, with no evidence of anti-religious animus; the mandate predated the inclusion of religious schools.
The United States argues Smith explicitly preserved Sherbert and Thomas for public benefits cases, and that 41 jurisdictions (federal government under RFRA plus 40 states) already apply strict scrutiny in this context without causing the predicted 'parade of horribles.'
Several justices expressed concern that adopting petitioners' rule would require exemptions from anti-discrimination laws for religious entities excluding children based on race, national origin, or other protected characteristics, not just sexual orientation.
Justices debated whether the 'statement of community beliefs' requirement itself constitutes discrimination by exclusion, or whether it merely requires affirmation of teachings while welcoming all families who agree.
The case raises a potential anomaly: under petitioners' view, a funding condition would receive strict scrutiny while an outright ban on the same religious conduct would receive only rational basis review under Smith.
Notable quotes
“THE PROGRAM OPERATES TO IDENTIFY AND EXCLUDE OTHERWISE ELIGIBLE SCHOOLS ON THE BASIS OF THEIR RELIGIOUS EXERCISE.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:26“IF YOU LOOK AT THESE PEACE AND SAFETY PROVISOS THAT LOTS OF STATE CONSTITUTIONS HAD AT THE TIME, THERE WAS SOME UNDERSTANDING THAT, YOU KNOW, WE'RE GOING TO PROTECT THE FREE EXERCISE OF RELIGION UP INTO A UP UNTIL A PARTICULAR POINT.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:51“THE CONCURRENCE IN SMITH MAKES EXACTLY THE SAME POINT. THE CONCURRENCE SAYS, WHY ARE WE TREATING BENEFITS BETTER THAN DIRECT PROHIBITIONS? AND THE MAJORITY DOESN'T RESPOND TO THAT.”
▸ Notable quotes · 42:01“COLORADO WELCOMES RELIGIOUS PRESCHOOLS TO UPK. THE ONLY THING COLORADO ASKS IS THAT THEY COMPLY WITH THE SAME CONDITIONS THAT EVERY PUBLICLY FUNDED PRESCHOOL MUST MEET RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR ALIKE.”
▸ Notable quotes · 87:06“THIS COURT HAS NEVER HELD THAT KNOWING THE EFFECT OF AN ACTION ESTABLISHES WITHOUT MORE THE GOVERNMENT'S INTENT TO SINGLE OUT RELIGION FOR DISFAVOR.”
▸ Notable quotes · 98:50“THE IDEA THAT THE ANSWER TO THE RACE HYPOTHETICAL SHOULD BE PRESERVED. SMITH AND THE MAXIMAL NUMBER OF CONTEXTS IS ALREADY REFUTED BY OTHER CONTEXTS.”
▸ Notable quotes · 86:24Chapters
9:58 — Petitioners' Opening Argument: Mr. Reeves argues Colorado's UPK program denies Catholic families access to universal preschool funding because of sincere religious exercise, triggering strict scrutiny under Carson, Sherbert, and Thomas. He contends the 10th Circuit wrongly limited Carson to explicit religious exclusions and misapplied Smith, because Colorado's program has numerous exemptions making it not generally applicable.
11:57 — Justices Probe Carson's Scope: Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Kagan, Jackson, and Sotomayor question whether Carson extends to facially neutral laws. They explore whether petitioners seek equal treatment or a special exemption, and whether the program's effect on religious schools is distinguishable from Carson's explicit exclusion.
15:52 — Nature of Catholic Schools' Admission Policy: Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Gorsuch press on whether Catholic schools categorically exclude children of same-sex couples or require affirmation of beliefs. Reeves explains the 'statement of community beliefs' applies to all families and enrollment decisions are case-by-case; no family has been turned away under UPK.
36:02 — Sherbert/Thomas vs. Smith Framework: Justices Kagan, Jackson, and Gorsuch debate whether Smith overruled Sherbert/Thomas for public benefits. Reeves argues Smith distinguished those cases twice and preserved them for benefits; the Solicitor General later supports this reading. Justices probe the anomaly of stricter scrutiny for benefits than bans.
44:09 — General Applicability and Exemptions: Justice Kavanaugh asks petitioners to detail the Smith general applicability argument. Reeves identifies over 1,000 schools with enrollment preferences and the catch-all exemption, arguing Colorado accommodates secular but not religious interests. Colorado's own expert testified the catch-all exemption was unrestricted until trial.
57:30 — United States Argument: Solicitor General Harris argues Carson distilled the Sherbert rule for public benefits and that Smith preserved it. She emphasizes 41 jurisdictions already apply strict scrutiny here without chaos, and that the Court should resolve the tension between Carson and Smith, and between parents' rights (Mahmoud) and schools' rights.
87:05 — Colorado's Defense: Ms. Norton argues UPK is neutral, generally applicable, and welcomes religious providers. The equal opportunity requirement predated religious inclusion and applies uniformly. She distinguishes Carson as explicit religious discrimination and warns petitioners' rule would require exemptions for race and other protected characteristics.
128:29 — Rebuttal and Practical Realities: Reeves cites record evidence: no complaints of LGBTQ-based exclusion in decades, two UPK preschools near every Catholic preschool, Colorado's expert called harm speculative. He argues the case is an as-applied challenge protecting families like the Shealys who lose $18,000 in benefits due to religious exercise.
Speakers
Mr. Reeves — Counsel for Petitioners (Catholic preschools)
Ms. Harris — Solicitor General of the United States
Ms. Norton — Counsel for Respondent (Colorado)
Chief Justice Roberts — Chief Justice of the United States
Justice Thomas — Associate Justice
Justice Alito — Associate Justice
Justice Sotomayor — Associate Justice
Justice Kagan — Associate Justice
Justice Gorsuch — Associate Justice
Justice Kavanaugh — Associate Justice
Justice Barrett — Associate Justice
Justice Jackson — Associate Justice