TLDR
Comedian Taylor Tomlinson joins host Morgan to react to six Reddit relationship stories, each with satisfying updates where the posters ultimately leave their partners. Stories include a boyfriend whose frat friends destroyed a piñata of his girlfriend, a man who let friends cut sentimental patches off his girlfriend's backpack, a 33-year-old with a mattress hoarding habit who gave his 21-year-old girlfriend lilies she hated while buying himself a $215 pillow, a Canadian family drama over sweet mashed potatoes, a wife who put a positive pregnancy test in the mailbox to panic her serially cheating husband, and a man who made his girlfriend pump gas in pajamas to 'teach her a lesson.' All posters broke up with their partners after recognizing patterns of disrespect.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Custom piñatas of specific individuals with details like septum piercings are readily available on Etsy for ~$200.
A 10-year Reddit update revealed the backpack patch thief never apologized and the friends who cut patches blamed the boyfriend.
The mattress-obsessed boyfriend found his girlfriend's Reddit post and wrote a multi-paragraph defense of his 'sleep science' hobby instead of addressing the anniversary gift issue.
The neighbor the husband cheated with was actually pregnant and showed up with ultrasound photos during the wife's move-out.
The gas-pumping boyfriend's own mother called his girlfriend to say she raised him to never mistreat a woman, effectively ending the relationship.
Key takeaways
Writing a book requires expanding ideas rather than compressing them like jokes, making the drafting phase uniquely difficult even for professional comedians.
Custom piñatas of real people exist on Etsy, and destroying an effigy of a partner with friends signals deep disrespect that cannot be excused as 'tradition.'
Sentimental objects carry irreplaceable emotional history; a partner who dismisses their destruction as 'not meaning as much' reveals fundamental incompatibility.
Large age gaps in early 20s relationships often reflect the older partner's desire for someone with lower expectations, not genuine compatibility.
Hoarding framed as a 'hobby' (six mattresses, thousands on bedding, silver bars) while neglecting a partner's stated preferences indicates misplaced priorities and emotional unavailability.
Small comments can crystallize years of tolerated behavior; the mashed potatoes incident became the catalyst for ending a 5-year relationship where the boyfriend consistently sided with his family.
Strategic petty revenge (a pregnancy test in the mailbox) can provide psychological closure when leaving a serial cheater, especially when paired with practical exit planning.
Making a partner perform tasks in uncomfortable conditions to 'teach a lesson' reveals contempt, not care; the boyfriend's own mother sided with the girlfriend after learning he called her a bitch.
Notable quotes
“the hardest thing about writing a book is you are so proud of yourself for writing it that it it actually makes it difficult to quality control it because you're just so like well done you for even doing it”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:45“being really good at writing jokes is not the same as like being really good at writing prose. Like it's the difference of like, oh yeah, I make amazing smoothies. That doesn't mean I can roast a chicken.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:51“Piñatas should only be things that don't exist like dragons and [__]”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:38“When you have kids with this man and he has friends over and they say, 'Oh, I'd like a daughter someday.' Will he go, 'Take mine?'”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:58“If you are 21 and someone in their mid-30s wants to date you, they want to date you because they think you are not going to have any expectations of them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 41:02“oldest daughter wound where like you are very independent, but you just want to be considered.”
▸ Notable quotes · 82:16Chapters
7:02 — Piñata Story: A 22-year-old woman discovers her boyfriend's frat friends made and destroyed a custom piñata of her at his surprise party; he lies repeatedly. Update: she breaks up with him, he sends a video of him making out with a mutual friend.
19:58 — Backpack Patches Story: A boyfriend lets his drunk friends cut 11 sentimental patches off his girlfriend's backpack, including gifts from her deceased father. Update: 10 years later, she recovered the patches, left him, and he never apologized.
35:02 — Mattress & Anniversary Gift Story: A 21-year-old with a 33-year-old boyfriend receives lilies she hates and a three-sentence note while he buys himself a $215 pillow; he owns six mattresses and spends thousands on bedding and silver bars. Update: boyfriend finds the post and defends his 'sleep science' hobby.
56:32 — Sweet Mashed Potatoes Story: At a Canadian family dinner, a woman honestly reacts to sweet mashed potatoes with brown sugar; boyfriend says she embarrassed him. Update: they break up after she realizes he always sides with his family over her.
66:18 — Pregnancy Test Revenge Story: A wife discovers her husband's affair with their neighbor (plus two other women) and puts a positive pregnancy test in the mailbox to panic him. Update: she moves out with friends' help, neighbor is actually pregnant, divorce papers served.
78:20 — Gas Pumping Lesson Story: A man makes his girlfriend pump gas in freezing weather while she wears pajamas to 'teach her a lesson' for picking him up from work. She leaves him at a sushi restaurant. Update: his mother calls the girlfriend, girlfriend moves his stuff out, they break up; he asks Reddit if he can sue.
Speakers
Morgan — Host
Taylor Tomlinson — Guest