Why won’t investigators give back Kaylee Goncalves’ phone? Ongoing Bryan Kohberger investigation?

Original Media · 37m · English · YouTube · Brian Entin

TLDR

In the Brian Coberger case, the families of three victims have received their loved ones' phones back, but Kaylee Goncalves' phone remains with authorities who claim they are still trying to crack its passcode via brute force — a process that could take years. The Goncalves family and their attorney Shannon Gray argue there is no legal basis to retain the phone after Coberger's guilty plea, and they are fighting a FOIA request that could release all victims' phone data to the public. Meanwhile, Coberger is seeking to withdraw his plea and remove the judge, with a hearing set for October.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The prosecutor is using a brute-force attack on a victim's phone years after the case concluded, despite the defendant having pleaded guilty and waived appeals.

•

A small-town police department (Walla Walla PD) holds the extracted data of all four victims' phones, and a single FOIA request could force public release of that data unless a court intervenes.

•

The other three victims' phones were fully downloaded and returned, yet the prosecutor refuses to return Kaylee's phone or even provide the family a copy of the 18 GB already extracted.

Key takeaways

•

Kaylee Goncalves' cell phone is the only one of the four victims' phones not returned to the family; police say they are still attempting a brute-force passcode crack that could take three to four years.

•

All phones were sent to Walla Walla Police Department for data extraction; the other three phones were fully accessible (89–125 GB each), but only 18 GB of thumbnails and fragmented data came off Kaylee's locked phone.

•

A Freedom of Information Act request has been filed with Walla Walla PD for all extracted phone data, prompting the families to seek an injunction to block release of private photos and information.

•

Prosecutor Bill Thompson insists on continuing the phone search, allegedly to address 'rumors and social media noise,' but the family's attorney says no legal duty exists to gather more evidence after a guilty plea with waived appeals.

•

Steve Goncalves believes Thompson accepted a weak plea deal without securing concessions (e.g., location of a second weapon) and is now using the phone as a fishing expedition to find a connection to Coberger.

•

Apple refuses to assist in unlocking phones per company policy, and the family notes other avenues (iCloud, Apple Watch, laptop) were never pursued by investigators.

•

Coberger's new attorney, Jason Goldman from New York, is viewed by the family as seeking publicity; he is not licensed in Idaho and would need pro hac vice admission.

•

Judge Hippler scheduled a procedural deadline on the November anniversary of the murders, which the family's attorney calls poor taste because it will shift media focus back to Coberger on that date.

Notable quotes

“They're doing a brute force. So, I mean, it could be it could have happened 10 minutes ago, but on the long end on the long side of it, it could be years from now, three or four years before it gets through all the combinations that are possible.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:43

“There's no obligation by a prosecutor after a case has been closed and the person has been convicted and pled guilty to try to get more information or to access more discovery on the case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:33

“Best case scenario for them. They get into the phone. They find all of this information connecting BK to one of the victims. All right. So, what? So, what what do you benefit from?”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:06

“If you're going to do a plea deal, then, you know, negotiate this stuff out. Don't do it half ass and then like string the family and say, 'Oh, well, this family is going to get, you know, dragged through the mud for the next three or four years while we try to figure out if, you know, we can find something.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:05

“I think it was in poor taste to schedule the next hearing date on the anniversary of the deaths... on this date on the anniversary of the deaths of the four people, the news will be about Coberger, not about the victims.”

▸ Notable quotes · 32:32

Chapters

•

1:00 — Case updates: plea withdrawal and family statement: Coberger is seeking to withdraw his guilty plea and change judges; his family released a statement supporting post-conviction relief while expressing sympathy for victims.

•

4:20 — Crime scene photo leak concern: Prosecutor, Moscow PD, and Idaho State Police warn of potential release of unredacted crime scene photos; Kaylee's mother condemns anyone who would share such images.

•

6:10 — Kaylee's phone: extraction and FOIA threat: All victims' phones were sent to Walla Walla PD for data extraction; only Kaylee's remained locked (18 GB recovered). A FOIA request now seeks all phone data, prompting an injunction effort.

•

11:50 — Legal battle over phone retention: Family attorney argues no legal duty exists to keep searching the phone after a guilty plea; prosecutor insists on continuing brute-force attempts, allegedly to counter rumors.

•

15:00 — Steve Goncalves on plea deal failures: Kaylee's father says the prosecutor missed leverage to secure concessions (second weapon, full confession) and is now fishing for a Coberger connection via the phone.

•

26:20 — New defense attorney and upcoming hearings: New York lawyer Jason Goldman joins Coberger's team; family views it as publicity-seeking. October hearing set on judge removal and plea withdrawal; November deadline falls on murder anniversary.

Speakers

•

Brian Anton — Host

•

Steve Goncalves — Victim's father

•

Shannon Gray — Family attorney

⋮