TLDR
Annie Elise covers multiple true crime updates: the D4VD civil lawsuit naming his entire entourage, the Ohio House of Horrors grandfather ruled incompetent to stand trial, a 14-year-old missing after her newborn was found dead with her father accused of incest, and the 2016 Morgan Bauer murder solved with cannibalism allegations. The episode features an interview with Law & Crime correspondent Sierra Gillespie about the Lindsay Clancy mistrial, the holdout juror's behavior and criminal history allegations, and whether a plea deal or retrial is likely.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial appeared highly engaged and pro-defense during the trial — taking notes, laughing at defense counsel's jokes — yet allegedly disengaged during deliberations by scrolling on his phone.
Jonathan Warren, who pleaded guilty to Morgan Bauer's murder, asked the court to sentence him to death but received life without parole instead.
The Ohio House of Horrors case could result in zero criminal accountability if all four arrested adults are found mentally incompetent and non-restorable, despite 16 children suffering lifelong trauma.
Diana Ochoa's mother was arrested for child endangerment and posted bail while her husband and daughter remained missing, raising questions about what she knew about the incest and pregnancy.
Key takeaways
Celeste Reaves' family filed a civil lawsuit against D4VD (David Anthony Burke), his managers, security guard, mother, and companies for wrongful death, battery, assault, and human trafficking, despite having previously allowed their 15-year-old daughter to travel internationally with him.
Gary Siders Sr., the 73-year-old grandfather in the Ohio House of Horrors case where 16 children were rescued from deplorable conditions, was ruled mentally incompetent to stand trial with a 'not restorable' prognosis, meaning charges against him may be dismissed entirely.
A 14-year-old girl, Diana Ochoa, is missing under an Amber Alert after her newborn baby was found dead on a California roadside; her 38-year-old father Sergio Perez is accused of assaulting and impregnating her, and both vanished in a white Nissan Altima without plates.
Morgan Bauer, 19, was murdered in 2016 by coworkers Caitlyn Goble and Jonathan Warren, who were obsessed with serial killers and death; Jonathan pleaded guilty to murder, necrophilia, and admitted they dismembered and ate parts of her remains before burning them.
The Lindsay Clancy trial ended in a mistrial with an 11-1 split; the holdout juror was identified as a man who took diligent notes and appeared pro-defense during trial but allegedly scrolled on his phone during deliberations and has alleged domestic violence history.
Sierra Gillespie, who attended the Clancy trial daily, believes the defense was ahead until closing arguments, but the prosecution's rebuttal was strong; she now thinks a plea deal is likely to avoid the trauma and difficulty of seating an unbiased jury for a retrial.
Gillespie dismisses the Patrick Clancy conspiracy theories as internet speculation without evidence, noting that if Redington believed Patrick was responsible, he would have pursued that defense strategy instead of an insanity plea.
Notable quotes
“There wasn't a single piece of evidence or witness testimony that he used to prove why he was thinking the way he was.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:01“The grandfather of 16 children who were removed from their family home in June is not competent to stand trial.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:13“She lured Morgan to the house in Fort Lauderdale because she wanted to kill her because she's obsessed with death.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:26“This is really really dark and disturbing and so we're going to dive into that together. Don't worry. That episode is going to be out very soon and it will be a full deep dive.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:42“I would say leading up to closing arguments, I it felt you could just kind of feel the emotions in the courtroom. It felt like the defense was ahead.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:29“I don't think he actually killed the kids. I So it's it's tricky.”
▸ Notable quotes · 60:09Chapters
4:42 — D4VD Civil Lawsuit Update: Celeste Reaves' family filed a wrongful death civil suit against David Anthony Burke (D4VD), his managers, security guard, mother, and companies, alleging battery, assault, human trafficking, and emotional distress, despite previously allowing their daughter to travel with him.
9:22 — Ohio House of Horrors Competency Ruling: Grandfather Gary Siders Sr. was ruled mentally incompetent to stand trial with a 'not restorable' prognosis; charges may be dismissed. The other three adults await competency evaluations, raising concerns about accountability for the 16 rescued children.
12:55 — Diana Ochoa Amber Alert Case: 14-year-old Diana Ochoa is missing after her newborn was found dead; her father Sergio Perez, 38, is accused of incestuous assault and impregnating her. Both vanished; mother arrested for child endangerment. Amber Alert issued after surveillance footage found.
20:04 — Morgan Bauer Murder Case Resolution: 19-year-old Morgan Bauer's 2016 murder solved: coworkers Caitlyn Goble and Jonathan Warren killed, dismembered, and cannibalized her. Jonathan pleaded guilty to murder and necrophilia; Caitlyn convicted at trial after claiming coercion. Both sentenced to life without parole.
30:01 — Lindsay Clancy Trial Interview with Sierra Gillespie: Law & Crime correspondent Sierra Gillespie discusses the mistrial, holdout juror's behavior and alleged criminal history, courtroom dynamics, Patrick Clancy conspiracy theories, and predicts a plea deal is likely to avoid retrial difficulties.
Speakers
Annie Elise — Host
Sierra Gillespie — Guest