TLDR
Federal Judge Anna Reyes is investigating whether Justice Department and Interior Department lawyers misled the court in a case over Trump's plan to convert the public East Potomac Golf Links into a private championship course. After the government cut down nearly 430 trees days after filing a declaration about routine maintenance, and Trump's public statements contradicted his lawyers' arguments, Reyes announced an ethics inquiry and intends to appoint Jesse Liu — a former U.S. Attorney Trump nominated three times before withdrawing her nomination over the Roger Stone prosecution — as special master to examine potential ethics violations.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The acting National Park Service director signed a declaration about routine tree maintenance, then 24 minutes later emailed staff for edits, and the very next day the Park Service cut down nearly 430 trees — not just dead invasive ones.
The Justice Department's opening position in court was essentially 'don't believe the President,' an extraordinary stance for government lawyers defending a presidential directive.
Trump nominated Jesse Liu three separate times for increasingly senior positions before their relationship collapsed over the Roger Stone case, and now a federal judge has selected her to investigate his administration's lawyers.
Key takeaways
Judge Reyes issued a preliminary injunction on October 26 halting further tree removal and requiring advance notice after the Park Service cut down nearly 430 trees the day after filing a declaration describing only routine maintenance of dead invasive trees.
Trump's own social media posts directly undermined his lawyers' arguments: his lawyers claimed the tree removal was part of a pre-approved maintenance plan, while Trump announced a full course redesign by Tom Fazio with closure starting November 15 and work beginning immediately.
Senior government officials under oath could not confirm the closure plan Trump had publicly announced, creating a discrepancy between the President's directives and the government's legal representations.
The Department of Justice initially told the court not to believe the sitting president, then two days after the injunction admitted the administration did plan to close the course on November 15 consistent with Trump's directive.
Judge Reyes appointed Jesse Liu as special master to investigate possible ethics violations by DOJ and Interior lawyers through October 31, focusing on the duty of candor — whether lawyers corrected material misstatements once they learned the truth.
Liu's appointment carries strategic irony: Trump nominated her three times (U.S. Attorney for D.C., Associate Attorney General, Treasury Undersecretary) but withdrew the last nomination after becoming furious over her office's handling of Roger Stone's prosecution.
Liu's conservative credentials and Trump-vetted background make her a 'bulletproof' choice who cannot be dismissed as a liberal activist, while her firsthand experience with Trump's DOJ operations gives her unique insight.
The inquiry could result in sanctions, referral to disciplinary authorities, or an explanation for the discrepancies, but the pattern of shifting government positions suggests deliberate misleading rather than innocent error.
Notable quotes
“Rarely, if ever, has the United States Department of Justice urged a federal court not to believe the sitting president.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:40“So his lawyers are saying, no, no, don't believe Trump. This plan to tear down the trees is not part of the new renovations for the golf course. It's part of a previous plan that had been approved and so you don't believe our client even though Trump's own social media posts are undermining what their lawyers are saying.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:52“The ethics rule to understand here is the duty of candor to the court. Lawyers get to argue their client's side hard. I mean, really, that's they have a duty to work for their clients, but they also have to be truthful with the judge.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:07“Be careful how you treat people on the way up because you may see them again on the way down.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:13“By picking Liu Reyes chose someone with unimpeachable conservative and federal credentials who is vetted and appointed by Trump himself. So that's what's so great about this appointment. Can say, ah, liberal activist lawyer. You appointed her three times.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:35“It's a perfect choice. It's like a bulletproof choice. Well done, Judge Reyes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:02Chapters
0:00 — Golf course controversy overview: Trump sought to convert the public East Potomac Golf Links into a private championship course designed by Tom Fazio; a preservation group and golfers sued, alleging the government began redesign steps before required environmental review.
1:07 — Tree cutting timeline and declaration: On October 6, acting NPS director Jessica Bowren signed a declaration about routine maintenance and removal of dead invasive trees; 24 minutes later she emailed staff for edits; the declaration was filed October 9, and the next day nearly 430 trees were cut down.
3:13 — Trump's statements vs. lawyers' arguments: Trump's lawyers argued the tree removal was part of a pre-approved plan unrelated to the new redesign, but Trump's own social media posts announced a full Fazio redesign with closure on November 15 and immediate work commencement, contradicting their position.
3:46 — Injunction and DOJ's shifting position: Senior officials under oath could not confirm Trump's announced closure plan; Judge Reyes issued a preliminary injunction on October 26 protecting remaining trees and requiring advance notice; two days later DOJ admitted the administration did plan to close the course November 15 per Trump's directive.
4:23 — Ethics inquiry and special master appointment: Judge Reyes announced an ethics inquiry on October 30 and on November 7 stated she intends to appoint Jesse Liu as special master to investigate possible ethics violations by DOJ and Interior lawyers through October 31, focusing on the duty of candor.
6:12 — Jesse Liu's history with Trump: Liu was nominated by Trump three times — U.S. Attorney for D.C. (2017), Associate Attorney General (2019, withdrawn amid conservative pushback), and Treasury Undersecretary (2020, withdrawn after Trump's fury over her office's handling of Roger Stone's prosecution).
7:26 — Strategic significance of Liu's appointment: Liu's Trump-vetted conservative credentials make her immune to 'liberal activist' attacks, while her insider experience with Trump's DOJ operations gives her unique investigative insight; the host calls it a 'bulletproof' choice by Judge Reyes.
Speakers
Dave Aronberg — Host