14-Year-Old Kills 10-Year-Old Cousin in the Most Gruesome Way | The Disturbing Case of Lily Peters

Original Media · 56m · English · YouTube · Annie Elise

TLDR

In April 2022, 10-year-old Lily Peters was murdered by her 14-year-old cousin Carson Petersburgger in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin. Carson lured her off a wooded trail, beat her with a stick, strangled her, and sexually assaulted her after death — a crime he had planned in advance. He went home, showered, laundered his clothes, and attended her vigil the next day. Carson's father is a convicted pedophile. After years of legal battles over whether Carson would be tried as an adult and a change of venue, he pleaded guilty in August 2026 to first-degree intentional homicide; the two sexual assault charges were dismissed in the plea deal. He was sentenced to life with possible extended supervision after 25 years.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A 14-year-old planned and carried out a sexually violent, premeditated murder of his own 10-year-old cousin.

•

The killer attended the victim's vigil the day after the murder, hugging and comforting grieving family members while knowing he was the perpetrator.

•

The grandmother (likely shared by both children) wrote a letter to the judge describing Carson as 'kind, caring, giving, and loving' and asking for juvenile court, framing him as the one who needs help.

•

Carson's defense attorney, Michael Cohen, had previously represented Carson's father for his child pornography conviction.

•

Despite autopsy confirmation of sexual assault, the two first-degree sexual assault charges were dismissed as part of the plea deal, potentially leaving Carson off the sex offender registry if released.

Key takeaways

•

The murder was premeditated: Carson told investigators he planned to assault and kill Lily before they even left the house, and he followed through on that plan during the two-minute bike ride from her aunt's home.

•

The killer was Lily's 14-year-old cousin Carson Petersburgger, who lived with or frequently stayed at the aunt's house, making this a familial homicide committed by someone Lily knew and trusted.

•

Carson's father, Adam Burgerer, is a convicted pedophile who served three years in prison for possession of child sexual abuse material, and a letter from his incarceration begged a judge for unsupervised visits with Carson.

•

After the murder, Carson went home, showered, put his clothes in the laundry, and the next day attended Lily's vigil where he was seen comforting family members, showing no outward remorse.

•

Carson was ultimately tried as an adult after an appeals court upheld the decision in January 2024, and a change of venue was granted in August 2025 by bringing in an outside jury rather than moving the trial.

•

The case ended in a plea deal in August 2026: Carson pleaded guilty to first-degree intentional homicide, and the judge dismissed the two first-degree sexual assault charges (causing bodily harm and child under 13).

•

He was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of extended supervision after 25 years, meaning he could be eligible for release in his early 40s.

•

The host and many in the community view the dismissal of the sexual assault charges as a failure of justice, especially given the autopsy confirmed sexual assault and the plea deal may mean Carson won't be on a sex offender registry.

Notable quotes

“Planned planned, premeditated, knew what he was doing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:09

“For me, the deaths of children are the worst kinds of cases.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:15

“He detailed his premeditated plans for Lily that he held as they left the home together. Plans that he followed through on.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:11

“The level of true disgust packed into this case haunts me because not only do you have murder, but you have necra, you know where I'm going. I mean, it is just packed with so much.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:51

“Carson is and always has been a kind, caring, giving, and loving person.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:28

“I don't see this as justice for Lily and it really pisses me off.”

▸ Notable quotes · 54:07

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case Introduction: Host Annie Eliss reintroduces the 2022 murder of 10-year-old Lily Peters in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, warning of disturbing details and significant updates since her original coverage.

•

2:10 — Initial Police Response: Police press conferences detail Lily's disappearance after leaving her aunt's house, the discovery of her bike and body near a wooded trail, and the immediate classification as a homicide with the suspect at large.

•

13:41 — Suspect Identified: The Cousin: The suspect is revealed as 14-year-old Carson Petersburgger, Lily's cousin. He confessed to premeditated plans, luring her off the trail, striking her with a stick, strangling her, and sexually assaulting her after death.

•

20:52 — Criminal Complaint and Autopsy Details: The unsealed complaint reveals Carson tricked Lily into leaving the trail, hit her with a stick, strangled her, bit her, then returned home to shower and launder clothes before covering her body with leaves the next morning.

•

28:13 — Family Dynamics and Grandmother's Letter: Carson's father is a convicted pedophile; family members describe Carson's unhappiness after his father's arrest. His grandmother writes a letter to the judge praising Carson's character and pleading for juvenile court.

•

32:41 — Court Hearings and Gag Order Motion: Defense attorney Michael Cohen argues for a gag order after a YouTube video leaks law enforcement evidence, including drone footage and 911 calls. The judge orders all parties to maintain confidentiality.

•

49:21 — Tried as Adult and Change of Venue: An appeals court rules Carson will be tried as an adult in January 2024. In August 2025, the judge grants a change of venue by importing an outside jury due to pretrial publicity.

•

52:07 — Plea Deal and Sentencing: The November 2026 trial is cancelled. In August 2026, Carson pleads guilty to first-degree intentional homicide; sexual assault charges are dismissed. He receives life with possible extended supervision after 25 years.

Speakers

•

Annie Eliss — Host/Narrator

•

Chief Matt Kelm — Chippewa Falls Police Chief

•

DA Wade Newell — District Attorney

•

Michael Cohen — Defense Attorney

•

Judge Steven Gibbs — Circuit Court Judge

⋮