Ep. 724 | The Dead Man’s Secret Mission - MrBallen

Original Media · 2h 01m · English · YouTube · MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries Podcast

TLDR

This episode presents ten distinct true stories spanning historical espionage, cryptid encounters, a 1992 Christmas killing spree, multiple mysterious disappearances in national parks (Missing 411 cases), suspicious drownings of young men linked to the 'Smiley Face Killers' theory, and a man's 14-year medical odyssey culminating in a self-diagnosis of ultra-rare hypophosphatasia. The narratives explore themes of deception, the unknown, human cruelty, and the failure of institutions to protect or explain.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Dayton killers threw a party in the house with their first victim's decomposing body in the bedroom, and shot a partygoer who argued with one of the women.

•

Dakota James's body was found 10 miles downstream but showed no damage from passing through a violent dam, and a forensic pathologist found ligature marks on his neck disputed by the official examiner.

•

Lucas Holman's phone was found under his bed the morning after he vanished, though his roommate was home all night and never heard him enter — police never subpoenaed the phone records.

•

Todd Geib's body was upright in the lake (shoulders above water) after 21 days with almost no water in lungs, minimal decomposition, and a high dose of an unprescribed antidepressant in his system.

•

Theodore Roosevelt, future U.S. president, published the Bigfoot-like encounter in an 1893 book, describing the creature as 'something either half human or half devil, some great goblin beast.'

•

Aaron Blocker's doctors never connected his consistently low alkaline phosphatase results across a decade of blood tests, despite it being a hallmark of the rare metabolic bone disease HPP.

Key takeaways

•

Ian Fleming's rejected misinformation ideas for WWII British intelligence included dropping painted soccer balls and message bottles, but one corpse-based scheme became Operation Mincemeat, a pivotal deception that helped the Allies invade Sicily.

•

Theodore Roosevelt documented an 1830 encounter with a bipedal, clawed creature in Montana's Bitterroot Mountains — 60 years before the term 'Bigfoot' existed — based on a trapper's firsthand account.

•

Over three days in December 1992, four young people in Dayton, Ohio murdered six people and attempted to kill three more, driven by a thrill for killing rather than profit, leaving distinctive .25 caliber aluminum casings at each scene.

•

Multiple young men across the U.S. (Dakota James, Lucas Holman, Todd Geib) vanished after nights out, were found days or weeks later in water with pristine bodies, no water in lungs, and high levels of GHB — a pattern cited by 'Smiley Face Killer' theorists.

•

Experienced outdoorsmen Tom Messick (55-year hunter) and Dale Stehling vanished without trace in familiar terrain under clear conditions, with the FBI inexplicably joining the Messick search on day four.

•

Gia Fuda drove 90 miles into the Washington Cascades, abandoned her car, walked uphill into dense forest with only a Bible and journal, and was found alive nine days later with no memory of the missing time.

•

Aaron Blocker endured 11 surgeries, multiple hip replacements, and years of misdiagnoses (Crohn's, avascular necrosis) before discovering a decade of ignored low alkaline phosphatase levels in his own records, leading to a correct diagnosis of hypophosphatasia (HPP).

•

Enzyme replacement therapy for HPP halted Aaron's bone decay and dissolved calcium deposits, but only after irreversible damage required nine additional corrective surgeries.

Notable quotes

“Killing was actually quite fun. The trio left the bedroom and began eating Wilkerson's food and watching his TV and looking for things to steal. All the while happily talking about how amazing the killing experience had just been.”

▸ Notable quotes · 57:33

“It felt like his life's goals were slipping away from him. Aaron had had to take time off of school after the surgery and he didn't want to delay getting his degree any longer.”

▸ Notable quotes · 103:48

“All of his symptoms matched up with what he was reading. Aaron had no doubt he had just found what he was looking for.”

▸ Notable quotes · 115:46

“The writer would go down in history for what he did 8 years after publishing that book. That was when he was elected as America's 26th president. The writer was Theodore.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:08

“His body was pristine. It did not have any of the hallmarks, the bloating you would expect from being in water for 21 days. In fact, it was concluded that it was impossible for his body to have been in the water for all 21 days that he had been missing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 84:32

“The only remedy he could suggest for now was to remove the damaged old implants and replace them again with larger ones. Aaron left the doctor's office in silence and headed for the parking lot. Then, alone inside of his car, Aaron burst into tears.”

▸ Notable quotes · 112:57

Chapters

•

0:01 — Ian Fleming and Operation Mincemeat: Ian Fleming, as a naval intelligence assistant (code 17F), proposes wild misinformation schemes. One — planting a corpse with false plans — becomes Operation Mincemeat, deceiving Germans about the Sicily invasion. Fleming later channels his spy creativity into creating James Bond.

•

8:06 — The Bitterroot Mountains Encounter (1830): Trappers Smith and Bowman encounter a bipedal, clawed creature at a 'cursed' Montana pond. Smith finds two-legged tracks. The creature destroys their camp, kills Smith, and Bowman flees. Decades later, Bowman tells his story to Theodore Roosevelt, who publishes it in 1893 as an early Bigfoot account.

•

27:24 — The Dayton Christmas Killing Spree (1992): Over three days, four young adults (Marvales Keen, Demarcus Smith, Laura Taylor, Heather Matthews) murder six people and wound three in random attacks across Dayton, Ohio. They kill for thrills, not money. Distinctive .25 caliber aluminum casings link the crimes. A tip from a partygoer leads to their arrest. Keen is executed in 2009; others get life sentences.

•

67:28 — Gia Fuda and the Missing 411 Phenomenon: College student Gia Fuda drives 90 miles into the Washington Cascades, abandons her car, and walks uphill into dense forest with only a Bible and journal. Found alive nine days later near a creek, emaciated but coherent, with no memory of the missing time. The area is known for multiple baffling disappearances.

•

73:03 — Vanished Outdoorsmen: Messick and Stehling: Experienced survival instructor Tom Messick vanishes during a deer drive in familiar New York woods; FBI joins search on day four. Dale Stehling, an avid hiker, disappears on a well-marked trail in Mesa Verde National Park in 100°F heat with no water. Neither is ever found.

•

81:00 — The Smiley Face Killers? Suspicious Drownings: Three young men — Todd Geib (Michigan, 2005), Dakota James (Pittsburgh, 2017), Lucas Holman (Wisconsin, 2006) — vanish after nights out, are found days/weeks later in water. All have pristine bodies, no water in lungs, high GHB levels, and unexplained gaps between disappearance and water entry. Theories include a 'Smiley Face Killer' group.

•

92:59 — Aaron Blocker's 14-Year Medical Mystery: Aaron Blocker suffers from Crohn's disease and catastrophic bone deterioration. Endures 11 surgeries, double hip replacements, and years of misdiagnoses. By reviewing his own records, he discovers a decade of ignored low alkaline phosphatase levels, self-diagnoses hypophosphatasia (HPP), and confirms it via bone scans. Enzyme replacement therapy halts decay, but irreversible damage requires nine more surgeries.

Speakers

•

Narrator (Mr. Ballin) — Host/Storyteller

⋮