Infamous Reddit Crimes Ft. Angela Giarratana & Amanda Lehan-Canto || Two Hot Takes Podcast

Original Media · 1h 42m · English · YouTube · Two Hot Takes

TLDR

Three true crime podcasters discuss five Reddit-sourced stories ranging from a neighbor stealing baguettes through a ceiling vent, to a woman living behind a hotel mirror, a paramedic who stalked a domestic abuse survivor into marriage, a man whose wife killed their children after he filed for divorce, and the 20-year cold case of 'Grateful Doe' solved by an Imgur post.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The baguette thief was a neighbor who smelled fresh bread through a ceiling vent and systematically climbed through it night after night rather than simply asking to buy some.

•

The hotel intruder had been living behind the mirror long-term with bedding, cigarettes, and toiletries, and the guest had previously smelled cigarette smoke assuming it came through vents.

•

The stalker paramedic explicitly wrote that his mindset was to 'prey on this vulnerable woman and manipulate her into being with me' while believing he was keeping her safe.

•

The wife who killed her children had no prior history of violence according to the sheriff, and neighbors saw no signs of trouble — the tragedy was triggered by the divorce filing.

•

Jason Callahan's mother never reported him missing for 20 years because she assumed his free-spirited, off-grid lifestyle meant he was simply living his life.

Key takeaways

•

A woman discovered her neighbor was climbing through a ceiling vent onto her refrigerator and counter to steal her homemade baguettes, leading to his arrest after she set up a hidden camera.

•

A hotel guest found a stranger in her room who had been living in a crawl space behind the bathroom mirror, accessing multiple rooms through unpatched renovation holes covered by mirrors.

•

A paramedic confessed to stalking a domestic abuse survivor for three years, deliberately manipulating her vulnerability to make her dependent on him, marrying her, and only feeling guilt after she discovered his Reddit confession.

•

A man who sought Reddit advice about his cheating wife was told to leave; after he filed for divorce, she killed their two young children and attempted suicide, leaving him with lifelong trauma and hostile in-laws who blame him.

•

An unidentified 1995 car accident victim known as 'Grateful Doe' was identified as Jason Callahan after an Imgur post went viral, connecting his mother — who never filed a missing person report assuming he was living freely — to his remains after 20 years.

Notable quotes

“My mindset was that I should prey on this vulnerable woman and manipulate her into being with me instead of one of the fuckers she was seeing at the time so that I know she'd be safe.”

▸ Notable quotes · 43:18

“No one could have foreseen the tragedy that resulted from me filing for divorce. You guys perform a wonderful service to those in need, and I hope you continue to do so in the future.”

▸ Notable quotes · 70:56

“I had the fortune that the last thing my children ever heard me say was, 'I love you. Good night. I will see you in the morning.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 78:35

“This is purely a lead. We are not certain of his identity just yet. This is just a... We are not certain if this young man is our Doe. Grateful Doe has not been ID'd.”

▸ Notable quotes · 93:50

“The Grateful Doe has been positively identified as the missing man, Jason Callahan.”

▸ Notable quotes · 99:35

Chapters

•

5:38 — Baguette theft mystery: A woman's baguettes keep disappearing from her fourth-floor apartment. She sets up a camera and catches a neighbor climbing through a ceiling vent onto her refrigerator and counter to steal bread. The neighbor is arrested.

•

30:03 — Hotel mirror intruder: A business traveler finds a woman in her hotel room who crawled through a hole behind the bathroom mirror. The intruder had been living in a crawl space between rooms, accessing multiple rooms through unpatched renovation holes covered by mirrors.

•

41:00 — Stalker paramedic confession: A paramedic confesses to stalking a domestic abuse survivor for three years, manipulating her into marriage. She discovers his Reddit post, leaves with their baby, returns, but the relationship remains deeply abusive.

•

55:01 — Divorce leads to family tragedy: A man posts about his wife's affair on Reddit. Commenters urge him to leave. He files for divorce; his wife kills their two children and attempts suicide. He shares his grief journey on Reddit over two years, facing hostile in-laws.

•

87:50 — Grateful Doe cold case solved: An Imgur post about an unidentified 1995 car accident victim ('Grateful Doe') goes viral. A user recognizes him as Jason Callahan. His mother, who never filed a missing person report, confirms his identity. DNA confirms the match after 20 years.

Speakers

•

Morgan — Host

•

Angela — Co-host

•

Amanda — Co-host

⋮