TLDR
Three true crime podcasters discuss five Reddit-sourced stories ranging from a neighbor stealing baguettes through a ceiling vent, to a woman living behind a hotel mirror, a paramedic who stalked a domestic abuse survivor into marriage, a man whose wife killed their children after he filed for divorce, and the 20-year cold case of 'Grateful Doe' solved by an Imgur post.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The baguette thief was a neighbor who smelled fresh bread through a ceiling vent and systematically climbed through it night after night rather than simply asking to buy some.
The hotel intruder had been living behind the mirror long-term with bedding, cigarettes, and toiletries, and the guest had previously smelled cigarette smoke assuming it came through vents.
The stalker paramedic explicitly wrote that his mindset was to 'prey on this vulnerable woman and manipulate her into being with me' while believing he was keeping her safe.
The wife who killed her children had no prior history of violence according to the sheriff, and neighbors saw no signs of trouble — the tragedy was triggered by the divorce filing.
Jason Callahan's mother never reported him missing for 20 years because she assumed his free-spirited, off-grid lifestyle meant he was simply living his life.
Key takeaways
A woman discovered her neighbor was climbing through a ceiling vent onto her refrigerator and counter to steal her homemade baguettes, leading to his arrest after she set up a hidden camera.
A hotel guest found a stranger in her room who had been living in a crawl space behind the bathroom mirror, accessing multiple rooms through unpatched renovation holes covered by mirrors.
A paramedic confessed to stalking a domestic abuse survivor for three years, deliberately manipulating her vulnerability to make her dependent on him, marrying her, and only feeling guilt after she discovered his Reddit confession.
A man who sought Reddit advice about his cheating wife was told to leave; after he filed for divorce, she killed their two young children and attempted suicide, leaving him with lifelong trauma and hostile in-laws who blame him.
An unidentified 1995 car accident victim known as 'Grateful Doe' was identified as Jason Callahan after an Imgur post went viral, connecting his mother — who never filed a missing person report assuming he was living freely — to his remains after 20 years.
Notable quotes
“My mindset was that I should prey on this vulnerable woman and manipulate her into being with me instead of one of the fuckers she was seeing at the time so that I know she'd be safe.”
▸ Notable quotes · 43:18“No one could have foreseen the tragedy that resulted from me filing for divorce. You guys perform a wonderful service to those in need, and I hope you continue to do so in the future.”
▸ Notable quotes · 70:56“I had the fortune that the last thing my children ever heard me say was, 'I love you. Good night. I will see you in the morning.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 78:35“This is purely a lead. We are not certain of his identity just yet. This is just a... We are not certain if this young man is our Doe. Grateful Doe has not been ID'd.”
▸ Notable quotes · 93:50“The Grateful Doe has been positively identified as the missing man, Jason Callahan.”
▸ Notable quotes · 99:35Chapters
5:38 — Baguette theft mystery: A woman's baguettes keep disappearing from her fourth-floor apartment. She sets up a camera and catches a neighbor climbing through a ceiling vent onto her refrigerator and counter to steal bread. The neighbor is arrested.
30:03 — Hotel mirror intruder: A business traveler finds a woman in her hotel room who crawled through a hole behind the bathroom mirror. The intruder had been living in a crawl space between rooms, accessing multiple rooms through unpatched renovation holes covered by mirrors.
41:00 — Stalker paramedic confession: A paramedic confesses to stalking a domestic abuse survivor for three years, manipulating her into marriage. She discovers his Reddit post, leaves with their baby, returns, but the relationship remains deeply abusive.
55:01 — Divorce leads to family tragedy: A man posts about his wife's affair on Reddit. Commenters urge him to leave. He files for divorce; his wife kills their two children and attempts suicide. He shares his grief journey on Reddit over two years, facing hostile in-laws.
87:50 — Grateful Doe cold case solved: An Imgur post about an unidentified 1995 car accident victim ('Grateful Doe') goes viral. A user recognizes him as Jason Callahan. His mother, who never filed a missing person report, confirms his identity. DNA confirms the match after 20 years.
Speakers
Morgan — Host
Angela — Co-host
Amanda — Co-host