TLDR
The hosts broadcast from Athens, Georgia ahead of Georgia vs. Missouri, debating four 'on the bus/off the bus' topics: Georgia as clear-cut #1 (all on board), whether Notre Dame deserves a top-4 seed and bye (Compton and Lewan say no, Josh says yes if chaos hits), whether Michigan and Ohio State should fire their coaches (Lewan wants change at Michigan, all off the bus for Ryan Day), and whether a Cinderella can win the new 12-team playoff (Josh says 0% chance, citing reduced G6 access).
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The 12-team playoff reduces G6 access to power-conference opponents in the regular season, making it harder for them to even qualify.
A 17-24 seed would face two true road games plus three neutral-site games against the best teams to win the title.
Notre Dame could play as few as 15 games to win a title while a conference champion plays 17.
Key takeaways
Georgia's defense is historically elite — holding opponents to 7 and 8 points in consecutive SEC road games, and could become the first SEC team since 1971 to hold three straight conference foes under 10 points.
Notre Dame's playoff resume is 50-50 in their two biggest non-conference games (beat Texas A&M, lost to NIU, beat BYU), leaving them at #5; the hosts agree they shouldn't jump to a top-4 seed without more chaos.
Taylor Lewan, a Michigan alum, says the program 'can't get worse than someone not caring' and wants a coaching change for his kids' sake, but acknowledges Michigan lacks an AD to execute a hire.
Ryan Day is 50-4 at home, won a national title as an 8-seed, and has been in the AP poll for 107 straight weeks; all three hosts reject firing him, though Josh suggests staff changes may be needed.
Josh argues the 12-team playoff actually kills Cinderella chances: G6 teams will get fewer regular-season games against power conferences, and a 17-24 seed would need to win four games (two true road, three neutral) against elite teams.
Indiana's 2024 run (undefeated regular season, playoff bye) is cited as proof a non-blue-blood can crash the party, but Josh notes they were a high seed, not a 17-24 Cinderella.
The playoff expansion contract was signed by all conferences including Notre Dame; Compton warns against demonizing independence because other schools may pursue it soon.
Notable quotes
“Clear-cut number one means that I can depend on you. Clear Here's what a clear-cut number one team does. They go on the road in a ranked matchup in prime time in Oxford, Mississippi, and they toss someone right in the wood chipper.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:16“It's it's it would be unfair if everyone didn't sign their names on that contract along with Notre Dame, but they did, right? They signed that playoff contract. That's kind of how we are where we are.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:32“I'm not worried about my happiness. I'm worried about my kids happiness. And there needs to be a change. Give me the next guy for 20 years. That's what I want.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:19“Cinderella's will never happen in that. Cinderella's had their best shot at happening the smaller the field is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:34“You got screwed. Fans got screwed. The G6 gets screwed. Everybody but two conferences really got screwed on this deal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:32“It feels like you open the fridge and it's it's spoiled milk. The expiration date is already in the past.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:27Chapters
0:00 — Georgia #1 debate: Hosts broadcast from Sanford Stadium; all three agree Georgia is the clear-cut #1 team after dominant road win at Ole Miss, citing elite defense, line of scrimmage control, and efficient QB play.
3:13 — Notre Dame playoff seeding: Debate whether Notre Dame deserves a top-4 seed and bye; Compton and Lewan say no based on 50-50 record in big games, Josh says yes if chaos occurs; all agree the contract was signed by all parties.
6:12 — Michigan and Ohio State coaching: Lewan calls for Michigan coaching change citing lack of care; all three defend Ryan Day's record at Ohio State; Josh suggests staff changes may be needed but not a head coaching move.
9:08 — 12-team playoff Cinderella chances: Josh argues expansion kills Cinderella hopes — G6 gets fewer marquee games, 17-24 seeds face brutal path; Will cites Indiana as proof non-blue-bloods can win; Lewan agrees high seeds can, but not low seeds.
Speakers
Josh P — Host
Will Compton — Co-host
Taylor Lewan — Co-host