Caleb Williams or Jared Goff? Gerald McCoy and Evan Cohen GET INTO IT 😱 | First Take

Original Media · 17m · English · YouTube · ESPN

TLDR

Analysts debate the NFC North hierarchy after Kirk Cousins' return to Minnesota, with most placing the Vikings second behind the Bears. The panel then breaks down the Packers-Vikings matchup, favoring Brian Flores' defense over Jordan Love's hot streak. Finally, they argue over which quarterback to trust in the playoffs: Evan picks Caleb Williams for his "it factor" and roster support, Lou backs Jordan Love's current groove and playoff flash, while another panelist chooses Jared Goff for his two NFC Championship appearances and a Super Bowl berth — the only QB in the division with that resume. The conversation highlights the division's unusual depth and the tension between proven experience and current performance.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Bears won a game despite committing five turnovers, which the panel treats as a hallmark of a truly elite team rather than a fluke.

•

The Packers' remaining schedule is the third hardest in the league, a fact that could push a 6-3 team to last place in the division.

•

Jared Goff has been to two NFC Championships and a Super Bowl — more than any other active NFC North quarterback — yet is frequently dismissed in national conversations.

•

Jordan Love's playoff loss to the Bears last year came despite him playing exceptionally well; the loss was attributed to special teams failures and dropped passes, not quarterback play.

•

The panel agrees the NFC North's last-place team could realistically reach the Super Bowl, a rare assessment for any division.

Key takeaways

•

Gerald ranks the Vikings second in the NFC North behind the Bears, citing the Cousins-Jefferson reunion and a strong defense, but still trusts Chicago more after they won despite five turnovers.

•

Evan argues the NFC North is so strong that even the last-place team could reach the Super Bowl, noting the Packers' brutal remaining schedule (third hardest) could drop them to the bottom.

•

On the Packers-Vikings game, Gerald and Evan favor Brian Flores' defense, which disguises pressure and forces quarterbacks into chaos, while Lou and another panelist back Jordan Love's ability to hit deep throws against the blitz.

•

For playoff trust, Evan chooses Caleb Williams based on feel, coaching connection, and a superior supporting roster, acknowledging the Bears' five-turnover win as a sign of resilience.

•

Lou selects Jordan Love, citing his playoff performance against Chicago last year (lost on special teams and defense, not him) and his acceptance of the heavy offensive burden without a run game.

•

A panelist strongly advocates for Jared Goff as the only NFC North quarterback with multiple NFC Championship appearances and a Super Bowl trip, arguing experience under playoff lights is irreplaceable.

•

The group acknowledges Jared Goff's career is underrated — he's maintained a top-five offense even after Ben Johnson's departure, and Detroit was considered "purgatory" when he arrived.

•

Kirk Cousins is notably absent from the playoff-trust conversation, with one panelist joking he would have been the "wrong answer" before seeing him play in the new context.

Notable quotes

“The last place team in the NFC North could go to the Super Bowl.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:28

“Brian Flores is better at coaching his unit than any other coach in the entire NFL at their unit. Like he's number one overall.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:30

“I believe against the Vikings defense he needs to hit singles and doubles. And that may be asking a lot of him against the Brian Flores coached defense.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:43

“If you've never played and been in the situation, you do not know how you're going to handle it. He did it with two different offensive coordinators, Sean McVay and then Ben Johnson.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:29

“They thought they sent him to purgatory. All right, cool. I'm going to take this team to the NFC Championship too. And oh, Ben Johnson's not there. You can't be good. I have a top five offense again.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:56

“Caleb Williams just gives me that feel that he in those moments you're talking about he's going to show up in those moments. You ask me why? I just feel it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:56

Chapters

•

0:00 — Vikings NFC North Ranking: Gerald places Minnesota second behind Chicago, citing the Cousins-Jefferson reunion and defensive strength, but notes the Bears won despite five turnovers — a sign of a great team.

•

1:22 — Division Depth and Packers Schedule: Evan argues the NFC North is the best division in years; even the last-place team could reach the Super Bowl. He notes Green Bay's brutal remaining schedule (third hardest) may drop them to fourth.

•

4:29 — Packers vs Vikings Matchup: Panel debates whether Brian Flores' complex blitz packages or Jordan Love's deep-ball accuracy against pressure will decide the game. Most lean defense, but Love's current groove earns respect.

•

7:41 — Playoff QB Trust: Caleb Williams: Evan trusts Caleb Williams for his "it factor," coaching connection, and superior roster, viewing the five-turnover win as proof of team resilience.

•

8:21 — Playoff QB Trust: Jordan Love: Lou backs Jordan Love, citing his strong playoff game vs. Chicago last year (lost on special teams/drops) and his acceptance of carrying a one-dimensional offense.

•

9:26 — Playoff QB Trust: Jared Goff: A panelist chooses Goff as the only QB with multiple NFC Championship appearances and a Super Bowl trip, arguing playoff experience under lights is irreplaceable and his success post-Ben Johnson is overlooked.

•

10:41 — Experience vs. Feel Debate: The group clashes over whether proven playoff experience (Goff) or current performance and intangibles (Love, Williams) should dictate trust. No consensus emerges; Kirk Cousins is notably excluded.

Speakers

•

Gerald — Analyst

•

Evan — Analyst

•

Lou — Analyst

•

Host/Moderator — Host

⋮