TLDR
This episode covers the federal murder trial of former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell, accused of killing 23-year-old pregnant Sandra Birchmore in 2021 to silence her about their sexual relationship that began when she was 15 in a police Explorer program. The case involves 40,000+ disturbing text messages, a staged suicide scene with glaring inconsistencies, catastrophic police investigation failures, and a shocking DNA revelation that the baby's father was neither Farwell nor his twin brother Billy (who also had a sexual relationship with Sandra), but an Army recruiter named Jason Packard. Farwell has pleaded not guilty; his lawyers claim Sandra took her own life. The FBI took over the case after two years, and the trial is revealing systemic corruption in both Stoughton and Canton police departments. Farwell's wife Michelle remains with him; their youngest child was born the day after Sandra's death. The judge has ordered the prosecution to stop distributing graphic trial exhibits publicly to protect the jury. The host argues the evidence overwhelmingly points to homicide, not suicide. The episode contains extremely graphic and disturbing content from the text messages read in court. The host urges listeners to subscribe for ongoing trial coverage. The episode was recorded on October 21st, with the trial ongoing.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The baby's father was Jason Packard, an Army recruiter — not Matthew Farwell, not his twin brother Billy, and this revelation came out during cross-examination of the FBI agent, shocking everyone in the courtroom.
Sandra's 'suicide note' from 2017 ('I'm wonderful. I'm amazing') was written in completely different handwriting, but this has not been addressed in trial yet.
The police dispatcher who took the call reporting Farwell's relationship with Sandra threw away his notes after every shift and was told by Farwell and another officer to 'never tell anyone about this call again.'
Farwell searched for how to recover deleted iMessages and revoke consent on the exact day police examined his phone for communications with Sandra.
Sandra's phone registered movement (8 steps while locked) 30 minutes after her last voluntary movement, right before surveillance showed Farwell leaving her building — then zero movement ever again.
The broken flamingo necklace with a clump of Sandra's hair was visible in crime scene photos on her body, but police never collected it; her family found it on the floor weeks later.
Farwell's twin brother Billy also had a sexual relationship with Sandra (starting when she was 18), and Farwell messaged about 'punishing' her for it, saying 'Big Brother is always watching.'
The Stoughton Police Chief was sidelined for doing her job — pushing for an investigation — while the department had a history of corruption allegations similar to neighboring Canton PD (Karen Read case).
Key takeaways
Matthew Farwell (27) began a sexual relationship with Sandra Birchmore (15) while supervising her in the Stoughton Police Explorer program, continuing for years.
Over 40,000 text messages between them were recovered, including explicit sexual content, discussions of deleting evidence, and Farwell using sex as 'punishment' for Sandra's perceived failures.
Sandra was found dead in a highly atypical 'suicide' scene: seated on the floor, hands free, with a strap around her neck tied to a doorknob only 2.5 feet above her — easily within reach to stop herself.
The initial police investigation was catastrophically flawed: no recording or notes of Farwell's interview, failure to collect key evidence (broken necklace with hair clump found weeks later by family), no neighbor interviews, and the lead investigator missed the autopsy.
DNA testing revealed Matthew Farwell was NOT the father of Sandra's baby — nor was his twin brother Billy (who also had a sexual relationship with Sandra). The father was Jason Packard, an Army recruiter and government witness.
Farwell's lawyers claim he wore a mask during affairs due to COVID, but multiple colleagues testified he opposed mask mandates and rarely wore one unless required.
Sandra's phone password was 'M. Farwell 1'; on the day police examined Farwell's phone, he searched 'Can deleted iMessages be recovered by Cellebrite?' and 'Can you revoke consent in Massachusetts?'
Sandra's 'I'm wonderful. I'm amazing' note from 2017 was written in completely different handwriting than her other writings, suggesting someone else wrote it.
Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara was placed on forced leave after pushing for a fuller investigation into Sandra's death and opening an internal affairs probe into Farwell.
Farwell's wife Michelle remains married to him; their youngest child was born the day after prosecutors allege Farwell killed Sandra and her unborn baby.
Notable quotes
“Prosecutors say that the secret that Matthew Farwell and little Sandra Birchmore shared was so disturbing that Matthew Farwell, officer Matthew Farwell, killed Sandra to keep that secret buried forever.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:41“The DNA testing showed that Matthew Farwell, Officer Matthew, was not actually the father of Sandra Birchmore's baby. And when you find out who was, uh as I usually say, you're going to need to pour a drink. Nay, a double. Maybe even a triple.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:10“She's seated, and can just reach up and say, 'You know, this isn't working out. I'm not enjoying this. I think I'm going to change my mind.' This is definitely not a typical hanging.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:59“I advised them that it appears to be a suicide.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:29“The strategy was to, quote, keep the temperature of the interview low. End quote.”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:41“I can't wait to crush this motherfucker.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:34“M. Farwell 1.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:19“Can deleted iMessages be recovered by Cellebrite?”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:46“What color is the suicide ribbon?”
▸ Notable quotes · 50:00“I'm in tears, not okay at all, really struggling and want to K M S.”
▸ Notable quotes · 50:34“I absolutely would have fucked you in 2012.”
▸ Notable quotes · 53:28“I loved it from the first day I touched you and my hand was soaked. And then I had you on my dick and it was so wet and sweet.”
▸ Notable quotes · 56:03“I would have slipped inside you and come with no condom. I thought I was going to hurt you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 56:48“Clear that part out, baby.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:33“Good girl.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:38“You are truly the worst person on the face of the earth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:29“I should have just walked away and let you hurt yourself.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:45“Well, if that's how you feel, maybe I will hurt myself then.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:53“Big Brother is always watching.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:50“I want you to feel like it's really happening and that you can't stop me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 69:02“You won't say a word to anyone or you'll be sorry.”
▸ Notable quotes · 69:22“The father of Sandra Birchmore's baby was not Matthew Farwell, but it wasn't Billy Farwell, either. The DNA, according to this FBI special agent, identified a guy named Jason Packard as the dad.”
▸ Notable quotes · 71:06“I was surprised. We had no indications of her destabilizing when we last communicated.”
▸ Notable quotes · 74:00“He got visibly and audibly upset with me. Matthew Farwell told him to quote, 'Never tell anyone about this call again.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 75:10“I routinely discarded my notes after each shift.”
▸ Notable quotes · 75:59Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Case Overview: Host Ashley Banfield introduces the federal murder trial of former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell, accused of killing 23-year-old pregnant Sandra Birchmore in 2021 to silence her about their sexual relationship that began when she was 15 in a police Explorer program. The case involves 40,000+ text messages, a staged suicide scene, and catastrophic police investigation failures.
15:00 — Background: Sandra Birchmore and the Explorer Program: Sandra joined the Stoughton Police Explorer program as a preteen, where Matthew Farwell supervised her. Prosecutors allege he began sexually exploiting her at age 15, continuing for years. Sandra became pregnant in 2021 and told Farwell he was the father, pressuring him to be involved. Farwell, married with children, allegedly saw the baby as a 'physical manifestation of his crimes' and killed her to bury the secret.
45:00 — The Death Scene and Initial Investigation Failures: Sandra was found seated on the floor with a strap around her neck tied to a doorknob 2.5 feet above her — hands free, easily able to stop herself. Police initially ruled it suicide. The scene was not secured as a homicide; investigators failed to record Farwell's interview, took no notes, missed the broken necklace with hair (found weeks later by family), didn't interview neighbors, and the lead investigator skipped the autopsy. The medical examiner later changed the manner of death to 'undetermined.'
80:00 — Trial Testimony: Early Witnesses and Digital Evidence: Witnesses included Sandra's friends (describing her excitement about the baby), the first responding officer (who called it suicide), and state police investigator Matthew Dunn (who admitted failures: no recording/notes of Farwell interview, missed evidence). Digital forensics examiner Nicholas Garin found Farwell's phone had no messages initially (returned next day), but later recovered 40,000+ messages. Sandra's laptop password was 'M. Farwell 1.' FBI examiner Christopher Beckstrom presented phone movement data showing Sandra's final steps coincided with Farwell's visit, and Farwell searched for deleting messages and revoking consent on the day his phone was examined.
120:00 — The Text Messages: Grooming, Abuse, and Evidence Tampering: FBI agent Heidi Kelsh read disturbing messages from 2013 onward: Farwell (27) describing taking Sandra's (15) virginity as 'best day of my life,' explicit sexual content, discussions of deleting messages ('Clear that part out, baby' / 'Good girl'), 49 documented meetings (some while Farwell was on duty), 'sexual punishment' messages for grades, choking/throat-grabbing (15 messages), role-play personas, and Farwell tracking Sandra's location ('Big Brother is always watching').
180:00 — Pregnancy, Escalation, and Motive: Sandra announced pregnancy in Dec 2020; Farwell reacted with rage ('worst person on earth,' 'should have let you hurt yourself'). After a friend reported the relationship to Stoughton PD in Jan 2021, Farwell's behavior changed 180° — affectionate, asked for apartment key, snooped in closets/bathroom. Sandra feared for baby's safety, discussed telling Farwell's wife, and sought legal advice on custody. She ordered baby onesies and planned a baby shower days before death.
240:00 — The DNA Twist: Baby's Father is Jason Packard: Autopsy DNA revealed Farwell was not the father. For years, it was believed his twin brother Billy (who also had a sexual relationship with Sandra) was the father. During cross-examination, FBI agent Heidi Kelsh revealed the father was Jason Packard, an Army recruiter and government witness — a complete shock. This doesn't absolve Farwell if he believed the baby was his, but adds a major twist.
270:00 — Recent Developments and Ongoing Trial: Sandra's OBGYN testified she was excited about the pregnancy, had a heartbeat at 6 weeks, and scored zero on suicidal ideation screening. The 911 dispatcher who took the report about Farwell was told to forget the call and discarded notes. The judge ordered the prosecution to stop publicly distributing graphic trial exhibits (crime scene photos, messages) to protect the jury. The trial continues with more witnesses expected, including potential testimony from Jason Packard and further exposure of police corruption in Stoughton and Canton.
Speakers
Ashley Banfield — Host
Matthew Farwell — Defendant
Sandra Birchmore — Victim
Michelle Farwell — Defendant's Wife
William 'Billy' Farwell — Defendant's Twin Brother
Jason Packard — Baby's Biological Father
Heidi Kelsh — FBI Special Agent
Donna McNamara — Stoughton Police Chief
Robert Kuhn — Stoughton Police Sergeant
Leslie Davis — Sandra's Longtime Friend
Nicholas Garin — Digital Forensics Examiner
Christopher Beckstrom — FBI Forensics Examiner