Walmart vs. Aldi Budget Cooking Challenge

Original Media · 34m · English · YouTube · Mythical Kitchen

TLDR

Mythical Kitchen tests whether grocery store choice matters by making identical carnitas burrito meals with ingredients from Walmart ($52) and Aldi ($55). After cooking pork shoulder braised in citrus and spices, Mexican rice, refried beans, pico de gallo, and avocado salsa, a blind taste test reveals the meals are nearly indistinguishable — Aldi wins slightly due to spicier serrano peppers and more flavorful avocados, but both cost about $3 per serving.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Traditional carnitas from Michoacán uses only pig and salt, confited in its own fat in a copper pot — no citrus, spices, or braising liquid required.

•

Arkansas is the number one rice-growing state in the US, not California or Louisiana.

•

The word 'avocado' comes from the Nahuatl word for testicle (āhuacatl), referencing the fruit's shape.

•

Paprika is literally just dried red pepper ground into powder — not a distinct spice but the same thing as chili powder.

•

Josh left cooked pork on the counter for 4-5 days in college and ate it without refrigeration, claiming 'the human body is deceptively hard to kill.'

Key takeaways

•

Aldi and Walmart offer nearly identical pricing and quality for staple ingredients — the total grocery bills were $55 at Aldi and $52 at Walmart for the same shopping list, averaging about $3 per finished burrito meal.

•

The carnitas recipe uses a 'bootleg' home method: pork shoulder braised for four hours with orange juice, lime, onions, garlic, and spices (cumin, oregano, chili powder, paprika), then shredded and crisped at 500°F — no initial searing needed because traditional carnitas confit in their own fat.

•

Rinsing canned beans thoroughly removes 'can stink' — a metallic, gooey residue that Josh insists makes beans taste like the can; he sautés onions, adds stock and rinsed beans, then mashes them for better texture and flavor.

•

Pico de gallo benefits from hand-mashing rather than spoon-mixing — crushing onions into tomatoes with clean hands releases juices and melds flavors, similar to a molcajete technique.

•

Avocado quality varied more than expected: Walmart avocados were larger but blander and lighter green; Aldi's were smaller, darker, and more flavorful, noticeably improving the avocado salsa.

•

Serrano pepper heat is unpredictable — Aldi's serranos were three times hotter than Walmart's despite using the same quantity, which made the Aldi salsa noticeably spicier and influenced the taste test.

•

Blind taste tester Blaine (from Arkansas, Walmart's home state) correctly identified Aldi as the spicier, better-avocado meal and preferred it, but noted the side dishes (rice, beans, pico) were completely identical.

•

The experiment concludes that for this high-calorie, high-flavor comfort meal, store choice barely matters — both discounters source from similar supply chains, with only produce (peppers, avocados) showing meaningful variation.

Notable quotes

“The single best way to feed a family of, let's say, large growing shotputting boys, because that's the only thing that I have any firsthand experience with, being a large growing shotputting boy myself since I was 12 years old, big-ass pork roast.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:12

“I've tried just doing the pork and salt and fat thing at home and it kind of just tastes like grocery pork and fat.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:00

“If more chefs and cooks just said that, I think I'd respect them more because like that's dead ass what it is. So many people just saying things. 'Oh, if you coat it in fat it prevents the gluten...' You don't know. You don't know. We don't know nothing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:35

“I think Aldi's literally getting all the same stuff from Walmart. I think it's just the same bean factory, the same light sour cream factory. They just have two different pepper guys and one of them grows way spicier peppers.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:59

“This is the most identical product we've ever had. To be fair.”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:39

“Almost identical for the entire recipe, almost identical per dish, almost identical. Just you have to grow some...”

▸ Notable quotes · 33:43

Chapters

•

0:00 — Setup: Walmart vs Aldi grocery haul: Josh introduces the challenge: make identical carnitas burrito meals using ingredients from Walmart ($52) and Aldi ($55) to test if store choice matters. He notes Aldi is rapidly competing with Walmart in the US discount grocery market.

•

3:17 — Carnitas prep and braise: Josh explains carnitas origins (Michoacán, pig + salt, copper pot confit) and his home adaptation using citrus, spices, and oven braising. He cuts bone-in pork shoulder, seasons it, and braises it for four hours without searing.

•

4:15 — Sponsor segment: Bombas: Josh promotes Bombas socks and clogs while demonstrating comfort during cooking, mentioning their donation model and 100% happiness guarantee.

•

15:10 — Pico de gallo and hand-mashing technique: Josh makes pico de gallo with tomatoes, red onion, jalapeño, cilantro, salt, and lime. He demonstrates his hand-mashing method to meld flavors, which the crew finds disgusting but he defends as similar to molcajete technique.

•

18:53 — Mexican rice and refried beans: Josh toasts rice in oil with onions and garlic, adds tomato sauce and broth, simmers. For beans, he rinses canned beans to remove 'can stink,' sautés onions, adds beans and stock, and mashes them.

•

24:28 — Avocado salsa and serrano pepper surprise: Josh blends avocado salsa with serranos, lime, water, salt. Tasting reveals Aldi's serranos are three times hotter than Walmart's. He notes Aldi avocados are smaller but more flavorful and darker green.

•

27:11 — Burrito assembly and blind taste test: Josh assembles burritos with carnitas, cheese, guac, pico. Blaine (from Arkansas) does a blind taste test, correctly identifies Aldi by the spicier salsa and better avocado, prefers it slightly, but finds sides identical. Cost per dish: $3.09 Walmart vs $3.00 Aldi.

Speakers

•

Josh — Host

•

Blaine — Crew member / Taste tester

•

Crew — Production team

⋮