TLDR
Election lawyer Mark Elias discusses the Department of Justice's emergency petition to the Supreme Court challenging California's vote-counting procedures just 24 hours before Election Day. The DOJ seeks to invalidate ballots from over 20,000 voters flagged as potential non-citizens, but Elias argues the factual basis is deeply flawed and the move represents an unprecedented federal assault on state election authority.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Solicitor General's brief explicitly disclaims knowledge of the voter list ('As this office has been informed...') and attributes identification to vague 'executive branch' rather than a specific agency
DOJ previously argued they couldn't wait a week for 9th Circuit ruling (claiming ballots would be co-mingled), but that deadline passed without crisis — now manufacturing new emergency
Petition was not addressed to Justice Kagan as circuit justice, which is highly unusual for 9th Circuit emergency applications
DOJ admits the voter roll data they used is a year old and from a 'publicly accessible version' of unknown provenance
Key takeaways
DOJ filed emergency Supreme Court petition Monday after losing in district court and 9th Circuit, seeking to block counting of ~20,000 California ballots flagged as potential non-citizens
Case tests whether federal government can dictate to states which ballots count — a 'must-win' with national implications for state election authority
Purcell principle (courts shouldn't change election rules near elections) strongly favors California; DOJ filing 24 hours before election violates this precedent
Factual predicate is weak: 40% error rate on flagged voters, DOJ won't disclose source of list, Solicitor General's brief uses hedging language ('appear to be', 'believes are likely')
Justice Kagan (9th Circuit justice) will set briefing schedule and rule on administrative stay; resolution expected within days
Elias calls this a 'full-blown constitutional crisis' driven by Trump administration desperation ahead of expected Republican losses
Notable quotes
“if DOJ wins this case, if Donald Trump wins this case, then they will be able to go state by state by state by state just saying, 'Hey, uh uh Iowa, hey Ohio, hey uh Texas, hey uh Michigan, hey uh Maine and Alaska, we get to tell you we don't think these ballots count.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:02“We are in a fullblown constitutional crisis. Anyone who wants to tell you that a constitutional crisis is on we we see we see it in the future or we're on the verge of it. They are simply not accepting the reality at the point in which the federal government is trying to dictate to sto states what ballots can count, what ballots uh can't count.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:09“the Purcell principle which says that federal courts should not be mcking around or changing election rules or vote counting rules uh uh in short proximity to elections that clearly should control”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:39“As this office has been informed after processing a publicly accessible version of California's voter role ahead of the 2026 midterm elections, the executive branch identified more than 20,000 individuals who appear to be registered as voters in California... whom the United States believes are likely to be aliens.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:50“The solicitor general's office is not vouching for any piece of this crap. Like, they know this is and they're not owning it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:42Chapters
0:00 — Breaking: DOJ Files Emergency Supreme Court Petition: DOJ files emergency petition to Supreme Court after losing in district court and 9th Circuit, challenging California's counting of ~20,000 ballots from voters flagged as potential non-citizens. Case filed Monday, election is Tuesday.
0:30 — What's at Stake: Federal vs. State Election Authority: Elias frames case as fundamental test of whether federal government can dictate to states which ballots count. Warns DOJ victory would enable state-by-state ballot challenges nationwide. His firm represents California voters.
1:50 — Legal Precedent Strongly Favors California: States set time, place, manner of elections per Constitution. Purcell principle bars federal courts from changing election rules near elections (usually months; here 24 hours). Lower courts cited Purcell in ruling against DOJ.
3:00 — Constitutional Crisis Declaration: Elias declares 'full-blown constitutional crisis' — federal government attempting to dictate state ballot counting at Trump's direction. Questions whether Supreme Court will uphold precedent or 'throw Donald Trump a bone.'
4:30 — Supreme Court Process & Timeline: Petition goes to Justice Kagan (9th Circuit justice). She will set briefing schedule and rule on administrative stay (whether to segregate ballots). Resolution expected within days. Unusual: petition not addressed to Kagan by name.
6:30 — Mootness & DOJ's Shifting Urgency Claims: DOJ previously claimed they couldn't wait a week for 9th Circuit ruling; that passed without crisis. Now manufacturing new emergency. If Court doesn't order ballot segregation, case becomes moot as ballots get counted.
8:30 — Factual Flaws in DOJ's Case: 40% error rate on flagged voters. DOJ won't disclose list source. Solicitor General brief uses hedging: 'as this office has been informed,' 'publicly accessible version,' 'executive branch identified,' 'appear to be registered,' 'believes are likely aliens' — disclaiming ownership of facts.
11:50 — Closing: Election Eve & Ongoing Coverage: Elias and host urge subscriptions to Democracy Docket channels for real-time updates. Election Day tomorrow; post-election litigation expected. Elias thanks viewers for support.
Speakers
Mark — Election lawyer / litigator
Brian — Host / interviewer