The Corn Rake Witness | Full Episode

Original Media · 42m · English · YouTube · 48 Hours

TLDR

This 48 Hours episode examines the 2018 death of Amy Mullis on an Iowa farm, where her husband Todd was convicted of murdering her with a corn rake. Their son Trysten, 13 at the time, found her body and testified at trial. New forensic and biomechanical experts now argue Amy's death was an accident — she fell on the rake due to medication-induced dizziness in a dark, cluttered shed, and her struggles to free herself created six puncture wounds from the four-tined rake. Despite this evidence, a judge denied Todd a new trial in 2024. The family continues to appeal.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The state medical examiner, Dr. Kelly Kruse, did not review Amy's medical records showing medications that cause dizziness — a potential cause of the fall.

•

Amy's coat — a critical piece of evidence showing only four holes for four tines — was never shown to the jury at trial.

•

Trysten signed an affidavit at 17 accusing his maternal stepfather and a family-hired attorney of pressuring him to say 'I don't know' about the time his father was out of sight, threatening juvenile detention if he didn't comply.

•

The defense's biomechanical engineer, Dr. Ngai, personally ran the distance the prosecution claimed Todd traveled to kill Amy and return, concluding it was impossible in the timeframe.

•

Todd's original defense attorney, Gerald Feuerhelm, explicitly stated he never considered an accidental death defense, despite Todd's letters from jail asking for an expert to evaluate that possibility.

•

The judge's denial focused on procedural grounds (counsel competence, jury credibility findings) rather than substantively analyzing the new scientific evidence contradicting the homicide ruling.

Key takeaways

•

Trysten Mullis, the only eyewitness, maintains his father is innocent and says he was pressured by his maternal stepfather to give ambiguous testimony about how long his father was out of sight.

•

The prosecution's case relied heavily on the state medical examiner's conclusion that six puncture wounds from a four-tined rake required multiple strikes, indicating homicide.

•

New experts Dr. Jennifer Hammers (forensic pathologist) and Dr. Valentina Ngai (biomechanical engineer) concluded Amy accidentally fell on the rake, and her subsequent movements while trying to free herself created the wound pattern — including two upward-trajectory wounds from rolling onto the rake.

•

Amy's coat had only four holes matching the rake's four tines, but her body had six puncture wounds — making multiple swings implausible since clothing would show more holes, not fewer.

•

Amy had undergone a medical procedure days earlier and was on three medications causing dizziness; Trysten observed her swaying and unsteady that morning.

•

The red shed where Amy was found was dark, narrow, and contained tripping hazards (augers on the floor), supporting an accidental fall scenario.

•

Todd's original defense attorney never argued accident, instead conceding murder but claiming Todd didn't do it — a strategy the family calls inexplicable.

•

Google searches on Todd's iPad about 'killing unfaithful wives' were cited as premeditation, but the defense notes they occurred before Amy's affair began, were on shared devices, and included historical queries (e.g., Aztec tribe punishments).

•

A post-conviction hearing in 2023 presented the new expert evidence, but Judge Laura Parrish denied relief after 15 months, ruling Todd received a fair trial and blaming him for not giving counsel time to investigate.

•

The Mullis family and their legal team (including the Iowa Wrongful Conviction Unit and the Exoneration Project) are appealing, arguing the scientific evidence remains on the record.

Notable quotes

“I walked in the barn and saw her laying on the ground with a corn rake sticking out of her back.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:42

“There's an innocent man rotting in prison right now for something he did not do.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:00

“He was convicted on swinging this rake multiple times into her body. How do you swing a four-tine implement multiple times and have less holes in the outer clothes and more holes in the body? That is illogical.”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:58

“Science doesn't pick sides.”

▸ Notable quotes · 39:21

“I thought they were going to let him walk right out of there, to be honest with you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 36:45

“I love you, and I'm... I'm fighting every day for you. I'm fighting to get you home.”

▸ Notable quotes · 41:48

Chapters

•

0:00 — The Discovery and Arrest: Trysten Mullis, 13, finds his mother Amy with a corn rake in her back on their Iowa farm. Four months later, his father Todd is arrested for murder. The prosecution argues Todd killed Amy due to her affair and planned divorce, citing Google searches and the wound pattern.

•

9:20 — The Trial and Conviction: At trial, the state medical examiner testifies the six puncture wounds from a four-tined rake indicate multiple strikes — homicide. Todd's defense attorney concedes murder but claims Todd didn't do it. Trysten testifies under pressure. Todd is convicted of first-degree murder.

•

21:00 — New Evidence: Accident Theory: New attorneys Dina and Daniel Nesheiwat hire experts Dr. Hammers and Dr. Ngai. They conclude Amy fell accidentally due to medication-induced dizziness in a dark, cluttered shed. Her struggles to free herself created the wound pattern. The coat had only four holes, contradicting multiple swings.

•

30:20 — Post-Conviction Hearing: A six-day hearing presents the new expert testimony. Dr. Hammers classifies the death as accident; Dr. Ngai says all physical evidence supports the fall hypothesis. The state calls no rebuttal experts. The judge takes 15 months to rule.

•

37:20 — Denial and Appeal: Judge Parrish denies a new trial, ruling Todd had competent counsel and the jury found the state's expert credible. She barely addresses the new scientific evidence. The family is devastated but vows to appeal, arguing the science remains on the record.

Speakers

•

Trysten Mullis — Son of Todd and Amy; key witness

•

Todd Mullis — Defendant; Amy's husband

•

Amy Mullis — Victim

•

Dr. Kelly Kruse — State Medical Examiner

•

Dr. Jennifer Hammers — Forensic Pathologist (Defense Expert)

•

Dr. Valentina Ngai — Biomechanical Engineer (Defense Expert)

•

Jon Turbett — Retired DCI Special Agent

•

Dina & Daniel Nesheiwat — Post-Conviction Attorneys

•

Gerald Feuerhelm — Original Defense Attorney

•

Judge Laura Parrish — Post-Conviction Judge

•

Peggy (Amy's mother), Jeff (Amy's brother), Randy (Amy's stepfather) — Maternal Family

⋮