TLDR
In Challis, Idaho, 70-year-old Alan Bruce murdered 47-year-old Patrick Shelton during a property dispute, dismembered him with a chainsaw, burned the body in burn barrels, and dumped remains in the Salmon River. Police initially investigated a missing person report, found blood evidence in Patrick's truck, and a cadaver dog led them to barrels on Alan's property containing bone fragments, bloodied clothing, and the murder weapon. Alan's brother Larry was briefly suspected as an accomplice but was cleared. Alan confessed after crime scene exposure, claiming self-defense, but the brutality and cover-up contradicted this. He entered an Alford plea to second-degree murder and destruction of evidence, receiving 20 years with 10 before parole eligibility. Patrick's body was never recovered.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The victim's pet pug survived two full days in the locked truck and his scent reactions became the strongest lead for deputies searching the mountains.
Alan Bruce returned to the active crime scene at night while police were monitoring it, believing he had already destroyed all evidence, which directly led to his confession.
Alan photographed the victim's dead body as 'proof' for potential future use, and this photo on his phone became the most critical evidence in the case.
Alan burned the chainsaw used to dismember the body in the same burn barrel, attempting to destroy the murder weapon along with the remains.
Key takeaways
Alan Bruce shot Patrick Shelton, then used Patrick's own chainsaw to dismember the body and burned the remains in burn barrels on his property over two nights.
A cadaver dog named Spie alerted to barrels containing bone fragments, Patrick's bloodied baseball cap, latex gloves, broken window glass from a bullet impact, and a vacuum filter with blood traces.
Alan returned to the crime scene at night while a deputy monitored Patrick's truck, attempting to destroy additional evidence — a move that accelerated search warrant approval and led to his arrest.
Alan's brother Larry arrived at the search warrant scene unannounced and provided text messages showing the escalating feud, but investigators ultimately determined Alan acted alone.
Alan confessed after detectives confronted him with the physical evidence, admitting he shot Patrick, chainsawed the body, burned it, cleaned the scene with bleach, and dumped remains in the river.
Alan took a photo of Patrick's dead body in the truck cab at 6:25 a.m. on May 8th, which was found on his phone and became critical evidence contradicting his self-defense claim.
Patrick's dog Ryder survived two days locked in the truck and his scent-tracking behavior initially led deputies toward the area where remains were scattered.
Alan entered an Alford plea to second-degree murder and destruction of evidence in October 2025, maintaining innocence while acknowledging sufficient evidence for conviction, and was sentenced to 20 years with 10 years before parole eligibility.
Notable quotes
“You can pick your friends, and you can pick your nose, but you can't pick your family.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:00“Oh, it stinks bad.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:49“I've used reduced it down to nothing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:43“I chopped him up. Like, did a chainsaw to him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:49“I tried to hide it and get away with it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:25“Should have just better pulled the trigger.”
▸ Notable quotes · 37:42Chapters
1:56 — Missing person report: Patrick Shelton's adoptive mother Helen reports him missing, mentioning a recent conflict with Alan Bruce over moved motor homes.
4:37 — First encounter with Alan Bruce: Deputies question Alan at his property; he gives rehearsed answers while barrels with Patrick's remains sit nearby.
11:24 — Discovery of Patrick's truck: Deputies find Patrick's truck at Big Hill with blood evidence, missing chainsaw, and his alive but dehydrated dog Ryder.
16:48 — Night encounter with Alan: Deputy Mike confronts Alan at Patrick's truck in the middle of the night; Alan claims he's protecting property from theft.
19:20 — Search warrant execution: Police execute search warrants on both properties; cadaver dog Spie alerts to barrels containing human remains and evidence.
26:36 — Larry Bruce interview: Alan's brother Larry arrives at the scene, provides text messages showing the feud, but shifts from defending Alan to expressing doubt.
32:12 — Alan's confession: Confronted with evidence, Alan admits to shooting, dismembering, burning, and dumping Patrick, claiming self-defense.
38:21 — Aftermath and sentencing: Alan enters Alford plea to second-degree murder; firearms found at associate's home; sentenced to 20 years with 10 before parole.
Speakers
Narrator — Podcast host
Deputy Mike/Kelly — Law enforcement
Alan Bruce — Suspect/Perpetrator
Larry Bruce — Alan's brother
Sergeant Tuttle — Law enforcement
Helen — Witness