TLDR
Kendall Rae details the 2012 murder of Lisa Techel, a pregnant Iowa woman shot in her trailer. Her husband Seth Techel claimed an intruder killed her, but investigation revealed he orchestrated a feud with a mentally ill neighbor to frame him, lied about an affair with a coworker, and used a friend's shotgun as the murder weapon. After two mistrials, a third jury convicted Seth in four hours; he received life without parole plus 25 years for the death of their unborn daughter Zoe.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Seth orchestrated months of vandalism against Brian Tate specifically to create a plausible alternative suspect for Lisa's murder.
Seth's father physically tried to interrupt the police interrogation to protect his son, but Seth ignored him and kept talking.
The defense in the first trial argued a peanut butter and jelly sandwich found on the back deck proved an intruder had been there, claiming animals would have eaten it if left overnight.
Lisa's father Todd hand-crafted a heart-shaped headstone for Lisa and baby Zoe inscribed with the line from The Notebook: 'If you're a bird, I'm a bird.'
Seth was arrested at Lisa's funeral visitation, immediately after embracing her sister and declaring his love for her.
Key takeaways
Seth Techel murdered his pregnant wife Lisa to pursue a relationship with coworker Rachel McFarland, despite initially claiming a home intruder was responsible.
Seth deliberately vandalized neighbor Brian Tate's property — throwing rocks and dog feces — to provoke Tate (who had paranoid schizophrenia) into appearing threatening, then tried to frame Tate for the murder.
During police interrogation, Seth lied repeatedly about the affair and a secret second phone; his own father banged on the interrogation room door urging him to stop talking, but Seth continued.
The murder weapon was a shotgun belonging to Seth's friend Lucas, left in the trailer and later found dumped 20 yards from the back door — not brought by an intruder.
It took three trials over two years to secure a conviction: the first two ended in hung juries, and the third trial moved venues and introduced a new defense strategy blaming investigators and revealing Lisa's own affair.
Lisa's family, including her father Todd (a sheriff's deputy), initially refused to believe Seth was guilty because the two families were exceptionally close and interwoven.
At sentencing, Lisa's sister Presley told Seth, 'I'm no longer your sister and I no longer love you,' and her father called him a killer who kills 'out of convenience, not necessity.'
Seth was arrested at Lisa's funeral visitation, moments after hugging her sister and saying 'You'll always be my little sister. I love you.'
Notable quotes
“I'm telling you that right now I have to bury my wife and kid, my unborn kid, okay? Whoever did this is going to pay.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:42“Seth is a cold-hearted killer. I would call him an animal, but an animal only kills out of necessity. Seth kills out of convenience.”
▸ Notable quotes · 51:13“I'm going to leave you with one final thought, that I'm no longer your sister and I no longer love you.”
▸ Notable quotes · 51:56“And all I wanted to do was sit with her and hold her hand and stroke her hair and let her know that I was there. I was with her when she took her first breath and I only wanted to know that I was there moments after she took her last.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:15“For what, dude? For nothing, that's what. Men like Seth piss me off so deeply and I'll never, I'll never, no matter how many cases like this I cover, I will never understand someone's brain and how they can justify doing something like this.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:45“He did that because it was always a thing for the two of them to watch The Notebook together. It was something that they loved, and they would always use that famous, very famous quote from The Notebook, uh if you're a bird, I'm a bird.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:56Chapters
0:08 — Introduction and set update: Kendall Rae welcomes listeners, thanks them for feedback on her new studio, and mentions personal updates including her postpartum status and inability to cover certain cases.
4:23 — Sponsor: Chime: Kendall reads an advertisement for Chime's high-yield savings account and checking account bonus.
5:55 — Lisa Techel's background and family: Lisa Marie Caldwell's upbringing, close family bonds, relationship with stepmother Amy, and her career in law enforcement following her father's footsteps.
8:50 — Relationship with Seth Techel: Lisa and Seth's history from bowling alley coworkers to marriage, their families' closeness, and their careers in public service.
12:26 — The murder and 911 call: Lisa was 20 weeks pregnant when shot in her trailer on May 26, 2012; Seth claimed he was in the shower, heard a gunshot, and called 911 18 minutes later.
16:10 — Neighbor feud with Brian Tate: Escalating conflict with neighbor Brian Tate, a disabled veteran with paranoid schizophrenia, including vandalism, police calls, and Todd Caldwell's growing concern for Lisa's safety.
23:40 — Interrogation and affair discovery: Seth's interrogation reveals he lied about an affair with coworker Rachel McFarland, used a secret phone, and his father tried to stop the interview; investigators found the missing murder weapon.
36:30 — Three trials and conviction: First two trials end in mistrials; third trial moves venue, defense blames investigators and reveals Lisa's affair, but jury convicts Seth in four hours.
Speakers
Kendall Rae — Host